Making sense of big questions that require multiple subjects: preliminary theorisation of an integrative philosophy of knowledge and empirical indications of a lack of subject connection within school curricula
Journal article
Bowie, R. A., Aantjes, R., Woolley, M., Hulbert, S., Revell, L., Thomas, C. and Riordan, J. 2024. Making sense of big questions that require multiple subjects: preliminary theorisation of an integrative philosophy of knowledge and empirical indications of a lack of subject connection within school curricula. Journal of Religious Education. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40839-024-00237-0
Authors | Bowie, R. A., Aantjes, R., Woolley, M., Hulbert, S., Revell, L., Thomas, C. and Riordan, J. |
---|---|
Abstract | This paper provides theorisation about a novel concept for education: an integrative philosophy of knowledge (IPK). This is proposed for school curricula to relate multiple subjects to big questions of personal and existential importance. Critical contemporary issues such as climate change education require multiple subject contributions but there is little clarity in the English education guidance on this drawing together, beyond the encouragement to do so in priority areas. Leading British thinkers have engaged the idea of the unity of knowledge, not without difficulty and criticism. The paper identifies reasons for a practical approach to consilience in school curricula. In addition to preliminary theorisation, in methodological ‘harmony’, this paper adds tentative empirical findings from a related research project that provides quantitative indications that such multi-subject connection is likely not happening. The findings are not definitive, but the perceptions of three groups of beginning and experienced teachers (secondary Religious Education (RE), secondary science and primary teachers) indicate that school curricula do not reflect an integrative approach to climate change education, and sex and relationships education, despite policy priority. A significant national survey could not detect many signs of connection. The paper speculates that RE could have a key epistemic role for the curriculum as a whole in this regard. |
Keywords | Integrative philosophy of knowledge (IPK); Consilience; Unity of knowledge; Science education; Religious education; Personal relationships education; Sustainability; Climate change education |
Year | 2024 |
Journal | Journal of Religious Education |
Publisher | Springer Nature |
ISSN | 2199-4625 |
Digital Object Identifier (DOI) | https://doi.org/10.1007/s40839-024-00237-0 |
Official URL | https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40839-024-00237-0 |
Related URL | https://link.springer.com/journal/40839 |
Funder | Templeton World Charity Foundation (TWCF) |
Publication dates | |
Online | 01 Oct 2024 |
Publication process dates | |
Accepted | 17 Sep 2024 |
Deposited | 02 Oct 2024 |
Accepted author manuscript | License All rights reserved File Access Level Restricted |
Publisher's version | License File Access Level Open |
Output status | Published |
References | References |
https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/992q0/making-sense-of-big-questions-that-require-multiple-subjects-preliminary-theorisation-of-an-integrative-philosophy-of-knowledge-and-empirical-indications-of-a-lack-of-subject-connection-within-school
Download files
86
total views5
total downloads7
views this month0
downloads this month
Export as
Related outputs
Counter terrorism in a pre-crime space: Safeguarding, radicalisation and extremism in schools in England
Revell, L. 2025. Counter terrorism in a pre-crime space: Safeguarding, radicalisation and extremism in schools in England. in: Patterson, K. J. and Hidalgo-Tenorio, E. (ed.) Multidisciplinary Approaches to the Discourses of Extremism Abingon Routledge.Islam as educational knowledge: challenges and barriers to the development of a Religion and Worldviews approach to teaching Islam in schools
Christopher, Kate and Revell, L. 2024. Islam as educational knowledge: challenges and barriers to the development of a Religion and Worldviews approach to teaching Islam in schools. Journal of Beliefs & Values. 45 (2), pp. 140-152. https://doi.org/10.1080/13617672.2024.2315404Teachers’ use of questions and the science – religion encounter: Basil Bernstein and the impossibility of the unthinkable
Revell, L., Bowie, R. A., Woolley, M. and Riordan, J. 2024. Teachers’ use of questions and the science – religion encounter: Basil Bernstein and the impossibility of the unthinkable . Journal of Religious Education. 72, pp. 295-309.Understanding sustainability pedagogy in practice
Riordan, J. P. 2024. Understanding sustainability pedagogy in practice. in: Bainbridge, A. and Kemp, N. (ed.) Good Education in a Fragile World: The Value of a Collaborative and Contextualised Approach to Sustainability in Higher Education Abingdon Routledge. pp. 125-136Multimodal classroom interaction analysis using video-based methods of the pedagogical tactic of (un)grouping
Riordan, J., Revell, L., Bowie, B., Hulbert, S., Woolley, M. and Thomas, C. 2024. Multimodal classroom interaction analysis using video-based methods of the pedagogical tactic of (un)grouping. Pedagogies: An International Journal. https://doi.org/10.1080/1554480x.2024.2313978Nexus researching church toddler groups
Casson, A., Pittaway, A., Woolley, M., Watts, T., Clemmey, K., Kemp, N. and Bowie, B. 2024. Nexus researching church toddler groups. Canterbury National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).Enquiry through time: a review of the use of the term 'enquiry' across four decades of the professional journal Teaching History
Woolley, M. 2024. Enquiry through time: a review of the use of the term 'enquiry' across four decades of the professional journal Teaching History. in: Bain, B., Chapman, A., Kitson, A. and Schreiner, T. L. (ed.) History Education and Historical Enquiry Charlotte, NC IAP.Resources for Secondary teachers on science religion encounters
Bowie, B. Resources for Secondary teachers on science religion encounters. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).14 resources for primary teachers on science religion encounters
Bowie, B. 14 resources for primary teachers on science religion encounters. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).Pupil-centred spiritual leadership: an empirical study of thirteen church primary school headteachers in England
Eisl, Ursula, Woolley, M., Hulbert, Sabina, Casson, Ann and Bowie, Robert A. 2023. Pupil-centred spiritual leadership: an empirical study of thirteen church primary school headteachers in England. International Studies in Catholic Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/19422539.2023.2171622Questions for discussion for children, parents, schools and churches
Harrison, G. and Bowie, B. 2023. Questions for discussion for children, parents, schools and churches. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).07. Where do you go to reflect?
Bowie, R. A. 2023. 07. Where do you go to reflect? Canterbury Christ Church University.06. What do you do about faith at home? - Catholic version
Bowie, R. A. 2023. 06. What do you do about faith at home? - Catholic version. Canterbury Christ Church University.05. What do you do about faith at home? - Church of England version
Bowie, R. A. 2023. 05. What do you do about faith at home? - Church of England version. Canterbury Christ Church University.04. What does it feel like to be in collective worship? - Church of England version
Bowie, R. A. 2023. 04. What does it feel like to be in collective worship? - Church of England version. Canterbury Christ Church University.03 What does it feel like to be in collective worship? - Catholic version
Bowie, R. A. 2023. 03 What does it feel like to be in collective worship? - Catholic version. Canterbury Christ Church University.02. When do you feel close to Jesus and God?
Bowie, R. A. 2023. 02. When do you feel close to Jesus and God? Canterbury Christ Church University.01. What does it feel like to pray?
Bowie, R. A. 2023. 01. What does it feel like to pray? Canterbury Christ Church University.Spiritual flourishing in the words of the child: Final report for young people: A Faith in the Nexus study 2023
Pittaway, A., Casson, A., Watts, T. and Bowie, R. A. 2023. Spiritual flourishing in the words of the child: Final report for young people: A Faith in the Nexus study 2023. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.Spiritual flourishing in the words of the child: A Faith in the Nexus study 2023
Casson, A., Pittaway, A., Watts, T. and Bowie, R. A. 2023. Spiritual flourishing in the words of the child: A Faith in the Nexus study 2023. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.Using video and multimodal classroom interaction analysis to investigate how information, misinformation, and disinformation influence pedagogy
Riordan, J., Revell, L., Bowie, B., Thomas, C., Woolley, M. and Hulbert, S. 2023. Using video and multimodal classroom interaction analysis to investigate how information, misinformation, and disinformation influence pedagogy. Video Journal of Education and Pedagogy. 8 (1), pp. 1-28. https://doi.org/10.1163/23644583-bja10040Science religion encounters, epistemic trespass, neighbourliness and overlapping domains: theorisation and quantitative evidence of extent
Bowie, R., Aantjes, R., Woolley, M., Hulbert, S., Thomas, C., Revell, L. and Riordan, J. 2023. Science religion encounters, epistemic trespass, neighbourliness and overlapping domains: theorisation and quantitative evidence of extent. Journal of Religious Education. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40839-023-00209-wTeachers' perspectives on the relationship between secondary school departments of science and religious education: independence or mutual enrichment?
Woolley, M., Bowie, R. A., Hulbert, S., Thomas, C., Riordan, J. and Revell, L. 2023. Teachers' perspectives on the relationship between secondary school departments of science and religious education: independence or mutual enrichment? Curriculum Journal. https://doi.org/10.1002/curj.233Prioritising a sense of belonging within the rural nexus: An empirical study of five rural church primary schools
Casson, A., Woolley, M., Hulbert, S. and Bowie, R. A. 2023. Prioritising a sense of belonging within the rural nexus: An empirical study of five rural church primary schools. Rural Theology. https://doi.org/10.1080/14704994.2023.2249659Community areas of sustainable care and dementia excellence in Europe (CASCADE) - Final report findings from the evaluation study of the CASCADE model at two implementation sites in Belgium
Sangeorzan, I., Martin, A., Hatzidimitriadou, E., Smith, R., Hulbert, S. and Wright, T. 2023. Community areas of sustainable care and dementia excellence in Europe (CASCADE) - Final report findings from the evaluation study of the CASCADE model at two implementation sites in Belgium. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.Community areas of sustainable care and dementia excellence in Europe (CASCADE) - Executive report: A retrospective analysis of the ZorgSaam model of long-term home and residential care for older adults
Martin, A., Smith, R., Hatzidimitriadou, E., Sangeorzan, I., Hulbert, S. and Wright, T. 2023. Community areas of sustainable care and dementia excellence in Europe (CASCADE) - Executive report: A retrospective analysis of the ZorgSaam model of long-term home and residential care for older adults. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.Evaluation study of diabetes and wellbeing (DWELL) - Report 4: Workforce training and cost effectiveness
Hatzidimitriadou, E., Manship, S., Thompson, T., Morris, R., Moore, J., Hulbert, S. and Saloniki, E.-C. 2023. Evaluation study of diabetes and wellbeing (DWELL) - Report 4: Workforce training and cost effectiveness. Canterbury. UK Canterbury Christ Church University.Evaluation study of Diabetes and Wellbeing (DWELL) - Report 3: Process evaluation
Hatzidimitriadou, E., Manship, S., Thompson, T., Morris, R., Moore, J. and Hulbert, S. 2023. Evaluation study of Diabetes and Wellbeing (DWELL) - Report 3: Process evaluation. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.Evaluation study of diabetes and wellbeing (DWELL) - Report 2: Participant outcomes
Hatzidimitriadou, E., Manship, S., Thompson, T., Morris, R., Moore, J., Hulbert, S. and Saloniki, E.-C. 2023. Evaluation study of diabetes and wellbeing (DWELL) - Report 2: Participant outcomes. Canterbury, UK Canterbury Christ Church University.Evalatuation study of the diabetes and welbeing (DWELL) - Report 1: Evaluation methodology
Hatzidimitriadou, E., Manship, S., Thompson, T., Morris, R., Moore, J. and Hulbert, S. 2023. Evalatuation study of the diabetes and welbeing (DWELL) - Report 1: Evaluation methodology. Canterbury, UK Canterbury Christ Church University.Science religion encounters toolkit 12: science and religion in the classroom
Riordan, J. and Bowie, B. 2023. Science religion encounters toolkit 12: science and religion in the classroom. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).Science religion encounters toolkit 13: Research summaries from the project
Bowie, R. A., Woolley, M. and Aantjes, R. 2023. Science religion encounters toolkit 13: Research summaries from the project. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).How can I use questioning to explore the unexpected without losing control?
Bowie, R. A. 2023. How can I use questioning to explore the unexpected without losing control? National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).A global citizen ITE module and science ite: supporting confidence and competence of beginning teachers
Woolley, M. and Bowie, R. A. 2023. A global citizen ITE module and science ite: supporting confidence and competence of beginning teachers . National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).An integrated philosophy of knowledge in the school curriculum vision: how schools of a Christian character might respond
Bowie, R. A. 2023. An integrated philosophy of knowledge in the school curriculum vision: how schools of a Christian character might respond. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).Paying attention to the spiritual flourishing of young children in church toddler groups: a scoping study evaluating the feasibility of a research study in this context
Casson, A., Woolley, M., Pittaway, Ann, Watts, Tansy, Kemp, Nicola, Bowie, B., Clemmey, Katie and Aantjes, R. 2023. Paying attention to the spiritual flourishing of young children in church toddler groups: a scoping study evaluating the feasibility of a research study in this context. Religions. 14 (2), p. 236. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14020236How can an interdisciplinary ITE day support student teachers of RE?
Bowie, B. and Woolley, M. 2023. How can an interdisciplinary ITE day support student teachers of RE? National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).How can I foster collaboration between the RE and science departments in my school?
Bowie, B. and Woolley, M. 2023. How can I foster collaboration between the RE and science departments in my school? National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).What role can different disciplinary knowledges play in shaping RE?
Bowie, B. and Woolley, M. 2023. What role can different disciplinary knowledges play in shaping RE? National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).How can I teach about truth in a complex world?
Bowie, B. and Woolley, M. 2023. How can I teach about truth in a complex world? National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).Sharing the purpose of secondary RE in the school
Bowie, B. and Woolley, M. 2023. Sharing the purpose of secondary RE in the school. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).What is the purpose of RE on the school curriculum?
Bowie, B. and Woolley, M. 2023. What is the purpose of RE on the school curriculum? National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).What are science/religion encounters and how can I prepare for them?
Bowie, B. and Woolley, M. 2023. What are science/religion encounters and how can I prepare for them? National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).Teachers' lived experience: voices of history teachers on the English National Curriculum
Woolley, M. 2022. Teachers' lived experience: voices of history teachers on the English National Curriculum. in: Wahlstrom, N. and Karset, B. (ed.) International Encyclopedia of Education Elsevier.Known by name: A chaplain's role
Casson, A., Pittaway, A. and Bowie, B. 2022. Known by name: A chaplain's role. Canterbury, UK Canterbury Christ Church University.Science and RE teachers' perspectives on the purpose of RE on the secondary school curriculum in England
Woolley, M., Bowie, R. A., Hulbert, S., Thomas, C., Riordan, J. and Revell, L. 2022. Science and RE teachers' perspectives on the purpose of RE on the secondary school curriculum in England. The Curriculum Journal. 34 (3), pp. 487-504. https://doi.org/10.1002/curj.191A meta approach to texts in Religious Education: Researching teachers’ engagement with sacred text scholarship in English secondary schools
Bowie, R. A, Clemmey, K. and Panjwani, F 2022. A meta approach to texts in Religious Education: Researching teachers’ engagement with sacred text scholarship in English secondary schools. British Journal of Religious Education. 44 (3), pp. 271-280. https://doi.org/10.1080/01416200.2022.2054773Nexus Teachers' Action Pack
Casson, A., Bowie, B., Hulbert, S., Pittaway, A. and Woolley, M. 2022. Nexus Teachers' Action Pack.Faith in the nexus
Casson, A., Hulbert, S., Woolley, M. and Bowie, R. A. 2022. Faith in the nexus. National Institute for Christian Education Research (NICER).Understanding and explaining pedagogical problem solving: a video-based grounded theory study of classroom pedagogy
Riordan, J., Revell, L., Bowie, B., Woolley, M., Hulbert, S. and Thomas, Caroline 2021. Understanding and explaining pedagogical problem solving: a video-based grounded theory study of classroom pedagogy. Research in Science & Technological Education. 41 (4), pp. 1309-1329. https://doi.org/10.1080/02635143.2021.2001450