Measuring the effectiveness of virtuous pedagogy: a quantitative study of the What if Learning approach in Church of England schools

What If Learning is a pedagogical approach that allows teachers to deliver traditional content, as prescribed by national curricula, while at the same time promoting character virtues fundamental to Christian ethos. It encourages teachers to present topics from a different perspective, which shapes understanding through the lenses of cooperation, coaching or hospitality. What If Learning reframes ‘how’ to teach rather than changing ‘what’ to teach. This study tested the effects of a three-months-long What If Learning intervention which reshaped the delivery of lessons to reflect values of hospitality and welcome in twenty schools across five dioceses in the United Kingdom. Four hundred and seventy-four pupils and 198 of their teachers filled in online surveys presenting implicit and explicit measures of intergroup attitudes adapted from the existing literature to reflect our operationalisation of tolerance as the Christian virtue of hospitality or welcome. Data were collected from all participants at three time points: before and after the intervention and then again three months later. Analyses of variance revealed a pattern of answers largely supportive of the positive effect of the proposed pedagogical approach, although not always consistent with the hypotheses. Teachers report overwhelming positive effects of the intervention on several aspects of pupils’ behaviour and flourishing potentials. The discussion focuses on the widespread implications of these findings while acknowledging the need for additional research to strengthen our conclusions and promote the approach even further

1. Niemi, P.-M., Benjamin, S., Kuusisto, A. and Gearon, L. How and Why Education Counters Ideological Extremism in Finland. Religions 2018, 9, 420.
2. Niemi, P.-M., Kallioniemi, A. and Ghosh, R. Religion as a Human Right and a Security Threat—Investigating Young Adults’ Experiences of Religion in Finland. Religions 2019, 10, 55.
3. Gearon, L.F. Religion, Education, Security. Religions 2019, 10, 330.
4. Ofsted. Education Inspection Framework, Crown, London, UK; 2019.
5. Bowie, R. The rise and fall of human rights in English education policy: inescapable national interests and PREVENT. Journal of Education Citizenship and Social Justice 2017, 12(2), 111-122.
6. Bowie, R. Is tolerance of faiths helpful in English school policy? Reification, complexity, and values education. Oxford Review of Education 2017, 43, pp. 536-549.
7. Bowie, R. Promoting tolerance to schools in a time of extremism. In Revell, L. and Gholami, R. Eds. Education and Extremisms: Rethinking Liberal Pedagogies in the Contemporary World. Sage: London, 2018, pp. 204-216.
8. Cooling, T. and Green E. Competing Imaginations for Teaching and Learning: The findings of research into a Christian approach to teaching and learning called What If Learning. International Journal of Christianity & Education 2015, 19 (2), pp. 96-107.
9. Cooling, T. Green E., Morris A.B. and Revell, L. Christian Faith in English Church Schools: Research Conversations with Classroom Teachers. Peter Lang, London, UK ; 2016.
10. Smith D.I. On Christian Teaching: Practicing faith in the Classroom. Eerdmans: Grand Rapids, MI, USA; 2018.
11. Church of England Foundation for Educational Leadership. Leadership of Character Education: Developing Virtues and Celebrating Human Flourishing in Schools. Church of England Foundation for Educational Leadership, London, UK; 2017.
12. In unpublished correspondence Nigel Genders, director of education for the Church of England, states the Chief Inspector of Ofsted read the Church education policy and subsequently produced the government Ofsted guidance with striking similarities.For an example see the campaign established by Humanists UK https://www.justgiving.com/fundraising/nofaithschools (Accessed on 10.2.2019).
13. Bretherton, L. Hospitality as Holiness: Christian Witness Amidst Moral Diversity. Ashgate: Aldershot, UK: 2006.
14. Smith D.I. Learning from the Stranger: Christian Faith and Cultural Diversity. Eerdmans: Grand Rapids, MI, USA, 2009.
15. Church of England Education Office. What if Learning Character Development Project: Final report (Initial Phase). Report for the Department of Education. Church of England, 2016, April. Available online: https://www.canterbury.ac.uk/education/our-work/research-knowledge-e... (Accessed on 18 December 2017).
16. Church of England Education Office. What if Learning Character Development Project: Final report. Report, Church of England 2016; Available online: http://cofeworcester.contentfiles.net/media/assets/file/Final_Report... (Accessed on 10.2.2019).
17. Church of England Education Office. What if Learning Character Development Project: Case Studies 2015-2016. Report, Church of England London: UK, 2016, September. Available at http://cofeworcester.contentfiles.net/media/assets/file/Character_De...
18. Full information on the project with associated videos are available at: https://nicer.org.uk/flourishing-schools/shaping-character-in-the-cu...
19. Tajfel H. and Turner J. The social identity theory of intergroup behaviour. In Psychology of Intergroup Relations.; Worchel, S. Ed.; Nelson Hall, Chicago, USA, 1986; pp. 7-24.
20. Brewer M.B. and Brown R.J. Intergroup Relations. In The handbook of social psychology 4th ed..; Gilbert, D.T., Fiske, S.T. and Lindzey, G. Eds.; McGraw Hill: New York, 1998; Vols. 1 and 2, pp. 554-594.
21. Brown, R. Social Identity Theory: Past achievements, current problems and future challenges. European Journal of Social Psychology 2000, 30, pp. 745-778.
22. Roccas S. and Brewer M. Social Identity Complexity. Personality and Social Psychology Review 2002, 16 (2), pp. 88-106.
23. Knifsend C.A. and Juvonen J. The role of social identity complexity in inter-group attitudes among young adolescents. Social Development 2013, 22 (3), pp. 623-640.
24. McGlothlin H. and Killen M. Intergoup attitudes of European and American children attending ethnically homogenous schools Child Development 2006, 77 (5), pp. 1375-1386.
25. Miller K.P., Brewer M. and Arbuckle. Social Identity Complexity: Its Correlates and Antecedents. Group Processes and Intergroup Relations 2009, 12, pp. 79-94.
26. Brewer M.B. and Pierce K.P. Social identity complexity and outgroup tolerance. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2005, Volume, 31, pp. 428-437.
27. Baron A.S. and Banaji M.R. The development of implicit attitudes. Psychological Science 2006, 17, pp. 53-58.
28. The pupil questionnaire can be viewed at https://cccusocialsciences.az1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_dpoPsDswdgU...