4D Printing of NiTi auxetic structure with improved ballistic performance

Auxetic structures have attracted attention in energy absorption applications owing to their improved shear modulus and enhanced resistance to indentation. On the other hand, four-dimensional (4D) printing is an emerging technology that is capable of 3D printing smart materials with additional functionality. This paper introduces the development of a NiTi negative-Poisson’s-ratio structure with superelasticity/shape memory capabilities for improved ballistic applications. An analytical model was initially used to optimize the geometrical parameters of a re-entrant auxetic structure. It was found that the re-entrant auxetic structure with a cell angle of −30° produced the highest Poisson’s ratio of −2.089. The 4D printing process using a powder bed fusion system was used to fabricate the optimized NiTi auxetic structure. The measured negative Poisson’s ratio of the fabricated auxetic structure was found in agreement with both the analytical model and the finite element simulation. A finite element model was developed to simulate the dynamic response of the optimized auxetic NiTi structure subjected to different projectile speeds. Three stages of the impact process describing the penetration of the top plate, auxetic structure, and bottom plate have been identified. The results show that the optimized auxetic structures affect the dynamic response of the projectile by getting denser toward the impact location. This helped to improve the energy absorbed per unit mass of the NiTi auxetic structure to about two times higher than that of the solid NiTi plate and five times higher than that of the solid conventional steel plate.

[1] J.L. Williams, J.L. Lewis, (1982) Properties and an anisotropic model of cancellous bone from the proximal tibial epiphysis, J Biomech Eng, 104 50-56.
[2] R. Gatt, M. Vella Wood, A. Gatt, F. Zarb, C. Formosa, K.M. Azzopardi, A. Casha, T.P. Agius, P. Schembri-Wismayer, L. Attard, N. Chockalingam, J.N. Grima, (2015) Negative Poisson's ratios in tendons: An unexpected mechanical response, Acta Biomater, 24 201-208.
[3] H. Kimizuka, H. Kaburaki, Y. Kogure, (2000) Mechanism for negative poisson ratios over the alpha- beta transition of cristobalite, SiO2: A molecular-dynamics study, Phys Rev Lett, 84 5548-5551.
[4] M. Sanami, N. Ravirala, K. Alderson, A. Alderson, (2014) Auxetic materials for sports applications, Procedia Engineering, 72 453-458.
[5] L. Santo, (2016) Shape memory polymer foams, Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 81 60-65.
[6] F. Scarpa, (2008) Auxetic materials for bioprostheses [In the Spotlight], Signal Processing Magazine, IEEE, 25 128-126.
[7] L. Boldrin, S. Hummel, F. Scarpa, D. Di Maio, C. Lira, M. Ruzzene, C.D.L. Remillat, T.C. Lim, R. Rajasekaran, S. Patsias, (2016) Dynamic behaviour of auxetic gradient composite hexagonal honeycombs, Composite Structures, 149 114-124.
[8] M.H. Hajmohammad, A.H. Nouri, M.S. Zarei, R. Kolahchi, (2019) A new numerical approach and visco-refined zigzag theory for blast analysis of auxetic honeycomb plates integrated by multiphase nanocomposite facesheets in hygrothermal environment, Engineering with Computers, 35 1141-1157.
[9] G. Imbalzano, P. Tran, T.D. Ngo, P.V.S. Lee, (2016) A numerical study of auxetic composite panels under blast loadings, Composite Structures, 135 339-352.
[10] J. Schultz, (2011) Modeling and finite element analysis methods for the dynamic crushing of honeycomb cellular meso-structures.
[11] C. Qi, S. Yang, D. Wang, L.-J. Yang, (2013) Ballistic resistance of honeycomb sandwich panels under in-plane high-velocity impact, The Scientific World Journal, 2013.
[12] G. Imbalzano, P. Tran, T.D. Ngo, P.V.S. Lee, (2017) Three-dimensional modelling of auxetic sandwich panels for localised impact resistance, Journal of Sandwich Structures and Materials, 19 291-316.
[13] W.A. Gooch Jr, (2011) Potential applications of titanium alloys in armor aystems, in: Titanium 2011 International Titanium Association, San Diego, California.
[14] N. Chan, K.E. Evans, (1997) Fabrication methods for auxetic foams, Journal of Materials Science, 32 5945-5953.
[15] R.S. Webber, K.L. Alderson, K.E. Evans, (2008) A novel fabrication route for auxetic polyethylene, part 2: Mechanical properties, Polymer Engineering and Science, 48 1351-1358.
[16] Y. Yao, Y. Luo, Y. Xu, B. Wang, J. Li, H. Deng, H. Lu, (2018) Fabrication and characterization of auxetic shape memory composite foams, Composites Part B: Engineering, 152 1-7.
[17] A.D. Lantada, A. de Blas Romero, M. Schwentenwein, C. Jellinek, J. Homa, (2016) Lithography-based ceramic manufacture (LCM) of auxetic structures: present capabilities and challenges, Smart Materials and Structures, 25 054015.
[18] B. Xu, F. Arias, S.T. Brittain, X.-M. Zhao, B. Grzybowski, S. Torquato, G.M. Whitesides, (1999) Making negative Poisson's ratio microstructures by soft lithography, Advanced Materials, 11 1186-1189.
[19] H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2009) Alumina composite suspension preparation for softlithography microfabrication, Microelectronic Engineering, 86 929-932.
[20] H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2013) Fabrication and characterization of stabilised zirconia micro parts via slip casting and soft moulding, Scripta Materialia, 69 433-436.
[21] H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2009) Fabrication of Al2O3/SiC Composite Microcomponents using Non‐aqueous Suspension, Advanced Engineering Materials, 11 101-105.
[22] H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2011) Multiple replication of thick PDMS micropatterns using surfactants as release agents, Microelectronic Engineering, 88 3275-3277.
[23] H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2013) Net shape manufacturing of ceramic micro parts with tailored graded layers, Journal of Micromechanics and Microengineering, 24 015018.
[24] Z. Zhu, H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2010) A soft moulding process for manufacture of net-shape ceramic microcomponents, The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 47 147-152.
[25] M.A. El-Sayed, H. Hassanin, K. Essa, (2016) Bifilm defects and porosity in Al cast alloys, The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 86 1173-1179.
[26] H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2010) Functionally graded microceramic components, Microelectronic Engineering, 87 1610-1613.
[27] K. Essa, F. Modica, M. Imbaby, M.A. El-Sayed, A. ElShaer, K. Jiang, H. Hassanin, (2017) Manufacturing of metallic micro-components using hybrid soft lithography and micro-electrical discharge machining, The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 91 445-452.
[28] H. Hassanin, K. Jiang, (2010) Optimized process for the fabrication of zirconia micro parts, Microelectronic Engineering, 87 1617-1619.
[29] M.A. El-Sayed, H. Hassanin, K. Essa, (2016) Effect of casting practice on the reliability of Al cast alloys, International Journal of Cast Metals Research, 29 350-354.
[30] C. Qiu, N.J.E. Adkins, H. Hassanin, M.M. Attallah, K. Essa, (2015) In-situ shelling via selective laser melting: Modelling and microstructural characterisation, Materials & Design, 87 845-853.
[31] H. Hassanin, Y. Alkendi, M. Elsayed, K. Essa, Y. Zweiri, (2020) Controlling the properties of additively manufactured cellular structures using machine learning approaches, Advanced Engineering Materials, 22 1901338.
[32] H. Hassanin, K. Essa, C. Qiu, M. Abdelhafeez Ali, J.E. Adkins Nicholas, M. Attallah Moataz, (2017) Net-shape manufacturing using hybrid selective laser melting/hot isostatic pressing, Rapid Prototyping Journal, 23 720-726.
[33] K. Essa, R. Khan, H. Hassanin, M.M. Attallah, R. Reed, (2016) An iterative approach of hot isostatic pressing tooling design for net-shape IN718 superalloy parts, The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 83 1835-1845.
[34] K. Essa, H. Hassanin, M.M. Attallah, N.J. Adkins, A.J. Musker, G.T. Roberts, N. Tenev, M. Smith, (2017) Development and testing of an additively manufactured monolithic catalyst bed for HTP thruster applications, Applied Catalysis A: General, 542 125-135.
[35] H. Klippstein, H. Hassanin, A. Diaz De Cerio Sanchez, Y. Zweiri, L. Seneviratne, (2018) Additive manufacturing of porous structures for unmanned aerial vehicles applications, Advanced Engineering Materials, 20 1800290.
[36] Y. Li, Z. Feng, L. Huang, K. Essa, E. Bilotti, H. Zhang, T. Peijs, L. Hao, (2019) Additive manufacturing high performance graphene-based composites: A review, Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, 124 105483.
[37] H. Hassanin, L. Finet, S.C. Cox, P. Jamshidi, L.M. Grover, D.E.T. Shepherd, O. Addison, M.M. Attallah, (2018) Tailoring selective laser melting process for titanium drug-delivering implants with releasing micro-channels, Additive Manufacturing, 20 144-155.
[38] H. Klippstein, A. Diaz De Cerio Sanchez, H. Hassanin, Y. Zweiri, L. Seneviratne, (2018) Fused deposition modeling for unmanned aerial vehicles (uavs): A review, Advanced Engineering Materials, 20 1700552.
[39] A. Galatas, H. Hassanin, Y. Zweiri, L. Seneviratne, (2018) Additive manufactured sandwich composite/ABS parts for unmanned aerial vehicle applications, Polymers, 10 1262.
[40] A. Sabouri, A.K. Yetisen, R. Sadigzade, H. Hassanin, K. Essa, H. Butt, (2017) Three-Dimensional Microstructured Lattices for Oil Sensing, Energy & Fuels, 31 2524-2529.
[41] Y.Y.C. Choong, S. Maleksaeedi, H. Eng, S. Yu, J. Wei, P.-C. Su, (2020) High speed 4D printing of shape memory polymers with nanosilica, Applied Materials Today, 18 100515.
[42] Y.Y.C. Choong, S. Maleksaeedi, H. Eng, J. Wei, P.-C. Su, (2017) 4D printing of high performance shape memory polymer using stereolithography, Materials & Design, 126 219-225.
[43] S. Li, H. Hassanin, M.M. Attallah, N.J.E. Adkins, K. Essa, (2016) The development of TiNi-based negative Poisson's ratio structure using selective laser melting, Acta Materialia, 105 75-83.
[44] C. Tan, S. Li, K. Essa, P. Jamshidi, K. Zhou, W. Ma, M.M. Attallah, (2019) Laser powder bed fusion of Ti-rich TiNi lattice structures: process optimisation, geometrical integrity, and phase transformations, International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture, 141 19-29.
[45] S. Li, H. Hassanin, M.M. Attallah, N.J. Adkins, K. Essa, (2016) The development of TiNi-based negative Poisson's ratio structure using selective laser melting, Acta Materialia, 105 75-83.
[46] F. Scarpa, P. Panayiotou, G. Tomlinson, (2000) Numerical and experimental uniaxial loading on in-plane auxetic honeycombs, The Journal of Strain Analysis for Engineering Design, 35 383-388.
[47] L.J. Gibson, M.F. Ashby, (1982) The mechanics of three-dimensional cellular materials, in: Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, The Royal Society, pp. 43-59.
[48] N. RG, C. Venkatesha, R. Jain, (2012) Numerical simulation of soft-body impact on Shape Memory Alloys (SMA), International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, 3.
[49] J.O. Hallquist, L.-D.T. Manual, (2007) Livermore Software Technology Corporation, Livermore, Ca.
[50] N. Kılıç, B. Ekici, (2013) Ballistic resistance of high hardness armor steels against 7.62 mm armor piercing ammunition, Materials & Design, 44 35-48.
[51] N. Gupta, V. Madhu, (1997) An experimental study of normal and oblique impact of hard-core projectile on single and layered plates, International journal of impact engineering, 19 395-414.
[52] M. Raguraman, A. Deb, N. Gupta, (2007) A numerical study of projectile impact on mild steel armour plates, Current Science, 93 498-506.
[53] M. Raguraman, A. Deb, (2006) Accurate prediction of projectile residual velocity for impact on single and multi-layered steel and aluminum plates, in: 9th International LS-DYNA Users Conference, Hyatt Regency Dearborn Dearborn, Michigan USA.
[54] S. Bala, J. Day, (2012) General guidelines for crash analysis in LS-DYNA, Livermore Software Technology Corporation.
[55] M. Meo, F. Marulo, M. Guida, S. Russo, (2013) Shape memory alloy hybrid composites for improved impact properties for aeronautical applications, Composite Structures, 95 756-766.
[56] A. Serjouei, R. Chi, Z. Zhang, I. Sridhar, (2015) Experimental validation of BLV model on bi-layer ceramic-metal armor, International Journal of Impact Engineering, 77 30-41.