A systematic review and psychometric evaluation of resilience measurement scales for people living with dementia and their carers

Psychometrically sound resilience outcome measures are essential to establish how health and care services or interventions can enhance the resilience of people living with dementia (PLWD) and their carers. This paper systematically reviews the literature to identify studies that administered a resilience measurement scale with PLWD and/or their carers and examines the psychometric properties of these measures. Electronic abstract databases and the internet were searched, and an international network contacted to identify peer-reviewed journal articles. Two authors independently extracted data. They critically reviewed the measurement properties from the available psychometric data in the studies, using a standardised checklist adapted for purpose. Fifty-one studies were included in the final review, which applied nine different resilience measures, eight developed in other populations and one developed for dementia carers in Thailand. None of the measures were developed for use with people living with dementia. The majority of studies (N = 47) focussed on dementia carers, three studies focussed on people living with dementia and one study measured both carers and the person with dementia. All the studies had missing information regarding the psychometric properties of the measures as applied in these two populations. Nineteen studies presented internal consistency data, suggesting seven of the nine measures demonstrate acceptable reliability in these new populations. There was some evidence of construct validity, and twenty-eight studies hypothesised effects a priori (associations with other outcome measure/demographic data/differences in scores between relevant groups) which were partially supported. The other studies were either exploratory or did not specify hypotheses. This limited evidence does not necessarily mean the resilience measure is not suitable, and we encourage future users of resilience measures in these populations to report information to advance knowledge and inform further reviews. All the measures require further psychometric evaluation in both these populations. The conceptual adequacy of the measures as applied in these new populations was questionable. Further research to understand the experience of resilience for people living with dementia and carers could establish the extent current measures -which tend to measure personal strengths -are relevant and comprehensive, or whether further work is required to establish a new resilience outcome measure.

Streiner, D.L., Norman, G.R., Cairney, J., 2015. Health measurement scales:
A practical guide to their development and use, fifth ed. Oxford University
Press. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1093/ med/ 97801 99685 219. 001. 0001.
2. JPND Working Group on Longitudinal Cohorts, 2015. Dementia Outcome
Measures: Charting New Territory. https:// www. neuro degen erati onres
earch. eu/ wp-​conte nt/ uploa ds/ 2015/ 10/ JPND-​Report-​Fount ain. pdf
3. Department of Health, 2009. Living well with dementia: A National
Dementia Strategy. https:// assets. publi shing. servi ce. gov. uk/ gover nment/
uploa ds/ system/ uploa ds/ attac hment_ data/ file/ 168220/ dh_ 094051. pdf
4. World Health Organisation and Alzheimer’s Disease International, 2012.
Dementia: A Public Health Priority. Accessed from: https:// www. who. int/
mental_ health/ publi catio ns/ demen tia_ report_ 2012/ en/.
5. Welsh Government, 2018. Dementia Action Plan for Wales 2018–2022.
https:// gov. wales/ sites/ defau lt/ files/ publi catio ns/ 2019-​04/ demen tiaaction-​plan-​for-​wales.
pdf.
6. Windle G. What is resilience? a review and concept analysis. Rev Clin
Gerontol. 2011;21(2):152–69.
7. Angevaare MJ, Roberts J, van Hout H, Joling KJ, Smalbrugge M, Schoonmade
LJ, Windle G, Hertogh C. Resilience in older persons: a systematic
review of the conceptual literature. Ageing Res Rev. 2020;63: 101144.
https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. arr. 2020. 101144.
8. World Health Organisation, 2015. World Report on Ageing and Health.
Accessed from: https:// www. who. int/ ageing/ events/ world-​report-​2015-​launch/ en/.
9. Cherry MG, Salmon JM, Dickson JM, Powell D, Sikdar S, Ablett J. Factors
influencing the resilience of carers of individuals with dementia. Rev Clin
Gerontol. 2013;23:251–66.
10. Joling KJ, Windle G, Dröes RM, Meiland F, van Hout HP, MacNeil Vroomen
J, van de Ven PM, Moniz-Cook E, Woods B. Factors of resilience in informal
caregivers of people with dementia from integrative international data
analysis. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord. 2016;42(3–4):198–214. https:// doi.
org/ 10. 1159/ 00044 9131.
11. Teahan Á, Lafferty A, McAuliffe E, Phelan A, O’Sullivan L, O’Shea D, Fealy
G. Resilience in family caregiving for people with dementia: a systematic
review. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2018;33(12):1582–95. https:// doi. org/ 10.
1002/ gps. 4972 (Epub 2018 Sep 19 PMID: 30230018).
12. Lamont, R.A., Nelis, S.M., Quinn, C., Martyr, A., Rippon, I., Kopelman, M.D.,
Hindle, J.V., Jones, R.W., Litherland, R., Clare, L., on behalf of the IDEAL
study team. 2020 Psychological predictors of ’living well’ with dementia:
findings from the IDEAL study Aging Ment Health 24 956 964 https:// doi.
org/ 10. 1080/ 13607 863. 2019. 15668 11
13. Windle G, Bennett KM, Noyes J. A methodological review of resilience
measurement scales. Health Qual Life Outcomes. 2011;9:8. https:// doi.
org/ 10. 1186/ 1477-​7525-9-8.
14. Cosco TD, Kaushal A, Richards M, Kuh D, Stafford M. Resilience measurement
in later life: a systematic review and psychometric analysis.
Health Qual Life Outcomes. 2016;14:16. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1186/
s12955-​016-​0418-6.15. Harding AJE, Morbey H, Ahmed F, Opdebeeck C, Ying-Ying W, Williamson
P, Swarbrick C, Leroi I, Challis D, Davies L, Reeves D, Holland
F, Hann M, Hellström I, Hydén L, Burns A, Keady J, Reilly S. Developing
a core outcome set for people living with dementia at home in their
neighbourhoods and communities: study protocol for use in the
evaluation of non-pharmacological community-based health and
social care interventions. Trials. 2018;19:247. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1186/
s13063-​018-​2584-9.
16. Webster L, Groskreutz D, Grinbergs-Saull A, Howard R, O’Brien JT,
Mountain G, Banerjee S, Woods B, Perneczky R, Lafortune L, Roberts C,
McCleery J, Pickett J, Bunn F, Challis D, Charlesworth G, Featherstone K,
Fox C, Goodman C, Jones R, Lamb S, Moniz-Cook E, Schneider J, Shepperd
S, Surr C, Thompson-Coon J, Ballard C, Brayne C, Burns A, Clare
L, Garrard P, Kehoe P, Passmore P, Holmes C, Maidment I, Robinson L,
Livingston G. Core outcome measures for interventions to prevent or
slow the progress of dementia for people living with mild to moderate
dementia: Systematic review and consensus recommendations. PLoS
ONE. 2017;12(6): e0179521. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1371/ journ al. pone.
01795 21.
17. Cosco TD, Kok A, Wister A, Howse K. Conceptualising and operationalising
resilience in older adults. Health Psychol Behav Med. 2019;7:90–104.
https:// doi. org/ 10. 1080/ 21642 850. 2019. 15938 45.
18. Stansfeld J, Stoner C, Wenborn J, Vernooij-Dassen M, Moniz-Cook E,
Orrell M. Positive psychology outcome measures for family caregivers
of people living with dementia: a systematic review. Int Psychogeriatr.
2017;29(8):1281–96. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1017/ S1041 61021 70006 55.
19. Stoner CR, Orrell M, Long M, Csipke E, Spector A. The development and
preliminary psychometric properties of two positive psychology outcome
measures for people with dementia: the PPOM and the EID-Q. BMC
Geriatr. 2017;17:72. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1186/ s12877-​017-​0468-6.
20. Stoner CR, Orrell M, Spector A. Review of positive psychology outcome
measures for chronic illness, traumatic brain injury and older adults:
adaptability in dementia? Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord. 2015;40(5–
6):340–57. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1159/ 00043 9044 (Epub 2015 Sep 25 PMID:
26401914).
21. Francis DO, McPheeters ML, Noud M, Penson DF, Feurer ID. Checklist
to operationalize measurement characteristics of patient-reported
outcome measures. Syst Rev. 2016;5(1):129. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1186/
s13643-​016-​0307-4.
22. Shea BJ, Reeves BC, Wells G, Thuku M, Hamel C, Moran J, et al. AMSTAR 2:
a critical appraisal tool for systematic reviews that include randomised
or non-randomised studies of healthcare interventions, or both. BMJ.
2017;358: j4008. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1136/ bmj. j4008.
23. Mokkink LB, Terwee CB, Patrick DL, Alonso J, Stratford PW, Knol DL, Bouter
LM, de Vet HC. The COSMIN study reached international consensus
on taxonomy, terminology, and definitions of measurement properties
for health-related patient-reported outcomes. J Clin Epidemiol.
2010;63(7):737–45. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. jclin epi. 2010. 02. 006.
24. Cohen J. A power primer. Psychol Bull. 1992;112:155–9.
25. Terwee CB, Bot SD, de Boer MR, van der Windt DA, Knol DL, Dekker
J, Bouter LM, de Vet HC. Quality criteria were proposed for measurement
properties of health status questionnaires. J Clin Epidemiol.
2007;60(1):34–42. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. jclin epi. 2006. 03. 012.
26. Bull MJ. Strategies for sustaining self used by family caregivers for older
adults with dementia. J Holist Nurs. 2014;32(2):127–35. https:// doi. org/ 10.
1177/ 08980 10113 509724.
27. Dias R, Simões-Neto JP, Santos RL, Sousa MFB, de Baptista MAT, Lacerda IB,
et al. Caregivers’ resilience is independent from the clinical symptoms of
dementia. Arq Neuropsiquiatr. 2016;74(12):967–73.
28. Fitzpatrick KE, Vacha-Haase T. Marital satisfaction and resilience in caregivers
of spouses with dementia. Clin Gerontol. 2010;33(3):165–80. https://
doi. org/ 10. 1080/ 07317 11100 37765 47.
29. Kimura NRS, Neto JPS, Santos RL, Baptista MAT, Portugal G, Johannessen
A, Barca ML, Engedal K, Laks J, Rodrigues VM, Dourado MCN. Resilience in
carers of people with young-onset Alzheimer Disease. J Geriatr Psychiatry
Neurol. 2019;32(2):59–67. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1177/ 08919 88718 824039.
30. Kimura NRS, Simoes JP, Santos RL, Baptista MAT, Portugal MD, Johannessen
A, et al. Young- and late-onset dementia: a comparative study of
quality of life, burden, and depressive symptoms in caregivers. J Geriatr
Psychiatry Neurol. 2021;34(5):434–44. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1177/ 08919
88720 933355.
31. MacCourt P, McLennan M, Somers S, Krawczyk M. Effectiveness of a grief
intervention for caregivers of people with dementia. Omega (Westport).
2017;75(3):230–47. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1177/ 00302 22816 652802.
32. Monteiro AMF, Neto JPS, Santos RL, Kimura N, Baptista MAT, Dourado
MCN. Factor analysis of the resilience scale for brazilian caregivers
of people with alzheimer’s disease. Trends Psychiatry Psychother.
2021;43(4):311–9. https:// doi. org/ 10. 47626/ 2237-​6089-​2020-​0179.
33. Pessotti CFC, Fonseca LC, Tedrus, G.M.de A.S., Laloni, D.T. Family caregivers
of elderly with dementia Relationship between religiosity, resilience,
quality of life and burden. Dement Neuropsychol. 2018;12(4):408–14.
https:// doi. org/ 10. 1590/ 1980-​57642 018dn 12-​040011.
34. Rosa, R.D.L.da., Simoes-Neto, J.P., Santos, R.L., Torres, B., Baptista, M.A.T.,
Kimura, N.R.S., Dourado, M.C.N. 2018 Caregivers’ resilience in mild and
moderate alzheimer’s disease Aging Ment Health 24 2 250 258 https://
doi. org/ 10. 1080/ 13607 863. 2018. 15335 20
35. Svanberg E, Stott J, Spector A. “Just helping”: Children living with a parent
with young onset dementia. Aging Ment Health. 2010;14(6):740–51.
https:// doi. org/ 10. 1080/ 13607 86100 37131 74.
36. Canevelli M, Bersani FS, Sciancalepore F, Salzillo M, Cesari M, Tarsitani L,
et al. Frailty in caregivers and its relationship with psychological stress
and resilience: A cross-sectional study based on the deficit accumulation
model. J Frailty Aging. 2022;11(1):59–66. https:// doi. org/ 10. 14283/ jfa.
2021. 29.
37. Carbone E, Palumbo R, Di Domenico A, Vettor S, Pavan G, Borella E. Caring
for people with dementia under COVID-19 restrictions: a pilot study on
family caregivers. Front Aging Neurosci. 2021;13:652833.
38. Chan EWL, Yap PS, Khalaf ZF. Factors associated with high strain
in caregivers of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) in Malaysia. Geriatr Nurs.
2019;40(4):380–5. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. gerin urse. 2018. 12. 009.
39. Kalaitzaki A, Koukouli S, Foukaki ME, Markakis G, Tziraki C. Dementia family
carers’ quality of life and their perceptions about care-receivers’ dementia
symptoms: the role of resilience. J Aging Health. 2022;34(4–5):581–90.
40. McManus K, Tao H, Jennelle PJ, Wheeler JC, Anderson GA. The effect of a
performing arts intervention on caregivers of people with mild to moderately
severe dementia. Aging Ment Health. 2022;26(4):735–44. https:// doi.
org/ 10. 1080/ 13607 863. 2021. 18912 00.
41. Prins M, Willemse B, van der Velden C, Pot AM, van der Roest H. Involvement,
worries and loneliness of family caregivers of people with dementia
during the COVID-19 visitor ban in long-term care facilities. Geriatr
Nurs. 2021;42(6):1474–80. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1016/j. gerin urse. 2021. 10. 002.
42. Sutter M, Perrin PB, Peralta SV, Stolfi ME, Morelli E, Pena Obeso LA,
Arango-Lasprilla JC. Beyond strain: Personal strengths and mental health
of Mexican and Argentinean dementia caregivers. J Transcult Nurs.
2016;27(4):376–84. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1177/ 10436 59615 573081.
43. Vatter S, McDonald KR, Stanmore E, Clare L, Leroi I. Multidimensional
care burden in Parkinson-related dementia. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol.
2018;31(6):319–28. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1177/ 08919 88718 802104.
44. Vatter S, Stanmore E, Clare L, McDonald KR, McCormick SA, Leroi I. Care
Burden and Mental Ill Health in Spouses of People With Parkinson
Disease Dementia and Lewy Body Dementia. J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol.
2019;33(1):3–14. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1177/ 08919 88719 853043.
45. Vatter S, Leroi I. Resilience in people with Lewy body disorders and their
care partners: Association with mental health, relationship satisfaction,
and care burden. Brain Sci. 2022;12(2):148. https:// doi. org/ 10. 3390/ brain
sci12 020148.
46. Wuttke-Linnemann A, Henrici CB, Müller N, Lieb K, Fellgiebel A. Bouncing
back from the burden of dementia: Predictors of resilience from
the perspective of the patient, the spousal caregiver, and the dyad - an
exploratory study. GeroPsych (Bern). 2020;33(3):170–81. https:// doi. org/
10. 1024/ 1662-​9647/ a0002 38.
47. D’Onofrio G, Sancarlo D, Raciti M, Burke M, Teare A, Kovacic T, Cortis K,
Murphy K, Barrett E, Whelan S, Dolan A, Russo A, Ricciardi F, Pegman G,
Presutti V, Messervey T, Cavallo F, Giuliani F, Bleaden A, Casey D, Greco A.
MARIO project: validation and evidence of service robots for older people
with dementia. J Alzheimer’s Dis. 2019;68(4):1587–601. https:// doi. org/ 10.
3233/ JAD-​181165.
48. McGee JS, Zhao HC, Myers DR, Kim SM. Positive psychological assessment
and early-stage dementia. Clin Gerontol. 2017;40(4):307–19. https:// doi.
org/ 10. 1080/ 07317 115. 2017. 13050 32.
49. Orgeta V, Leung P, Yates L, Kang S, Hoare Z, Henderson C, Whitaker C,
Burns A, Knapp M, Leroi I, Moniz-Cook ED, Pearson S, Simpson S, Spector