Bringing critical realism to nursing practice: Roy Bhaskar's contribution

In the context of modern nursing practice that is embedded within complex social situations, critical discussions about the contribution of major philosophers are relevant and important. Whilst nurse theorists have advanced and shaped nursing as a discipline, other major philosophers can offer much to advance nursing enquiry. In this paper, we focus on philosopher Roy Bhaskar who, amongst others, developed critical realism, a philosophy for social science which connects with how many of us think about the world. Bhaskar's work focuses our attention on the interplay between structure and agency and on the search for the causative or generative mechanisms that explain the social world. Bhaskar was interested in human emancipation, and we suggest his work is of great importance to advance understanding of complex social situations. Critical realism has already been endorsed by a range of disciplines, especially in research which focuses on real problems and acknowledges the complexities of the social world. In recent evidence from healthcare literature, there has been a surge in research using realist methodology (realist evaluation and realist synthesis), which is underpinned by the philosophy of critical realism and which offers a different perspective to understanding nursing and healthcare problems through the realist lens. However, we suggest that sufficient attention is not always paid to the philosophical roots of this methodology. In this paper, we provide insight into Bhaskar's work and demonstrate how research positioned within critical realism and realist methodology can advance nursing and healthcare‐related knowledge. Through shining a light on Bhaskar, we illustrate how critical realism philosophy is a natural fit with human and health science enquiry, including nursing.

Abhyankar P., Cheyne H., Maxwell M. et al. (2013) A
realist evaluation of a normal birth programme. Evidence-Based Midwifery, 1194, 112–119.
Angus J. (2012) Using critical realism in nursing and
health research: promise and challenges. Nursing
Inquiry, 19(1), 1–3.
Angus J., Miller K.L., Pulfer T. et al. (2006) Studying
delays in breast cancer diagnosis and treatment: critical
realism as a new foundation for inquiry. Oncology Nursing Forum, 33(4), E62–E70.
Bergin M., Wells J.S.G. & Owen S. (2008) Critical realism:
a philosophical framework for the study of gender and
mental health. Nursing Philosophy, 9(3), 169–179.
Bhaskar R. (1979) Philosophy and the Human Sciences:
the Possibility of Naturalism: a Philosophical Critique of
the Contemporary Human Sciences, 3rd edn. Routledge,
London.
Bhaskar R. (1989) The Possibility of Naturalism, 2nd edn.
Harvester, Brighton.
Bhaskar R. & Hartwig M. (2010) The Formation of Critical Realism. Routledge, Abingdon, Oxon.
Byng R., Norman I. & Redfern S. (2005) Using realistic
evaluation to evaluate a practice-level intervention to
improve primary health care for patients with long-term
mental illness. Evaluation, 11(1), 69–93.
Clark A.M., Whelan H.K., Barbour R. & MacIntyre P.D.
(2005) A realist study of the mechanisms of cardiac
rehabilitation. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 52(4), 362–
371.
Clark A.M., Lissel S.L. & David C. (2008) Complex critical realism. Tenets and application in nursing research.
Advances in Nursing Science, 31(4), E67–E79.
Connelly J. (2001) Critical realism and health promotion:
effective practice needs an effective theory. Health Education Research, 16(2), 115–119.
Cruickshank J. (2011) The positive and the negative.
Assessing critical realism and social constructionism as
post-positivist approaches to empirical research in the
social sciences. Paper 42. International Migration Institute, University of Oxford, Oxford.
Dobson P.J. (2005) Critical realism as an underlying
philosophy for IS research. In: Encyclopedia of Information Science and Technology, (eds. P.J. Dobson), 2nd
edn. Edith Cowan University, Australia.
Doi D., Cheyne H. & Jepson R. (2014) Alcohol brief
interventions in Scottish antenatal care: a qualitative
study of midwives’ attitudes and practices. BMC
Pregnancy and Childbirth, 14, 170.
Ehrbar H.G. (1998) Marxism and critical realism. Presentation for the Heterodox Economics Students Association. Available at: www.econ.utah.edu/ehrbar/marxre.pdf
[accessed 7 May 2016].
Critical Realism Bhaskar Nursing Realist 9 of 11
Fleetwood S. & Ackroyd S. (2004) Realist Applications in
Organisation and Management Studies. Routledge, London and New York. 13 p. ISBN: 0-415-34510-3
Gill M. & Turbin V. (1999) Evaluating ‘realistic evaluation’: evidence from a study of CCTV. Crime Prevention
Studies, 10(1), 179–199.
Greener I. & Mannion R. (2009) A realistic evaluation of
practice-based commissioning. Policy & Politics, 37(1),
57–73.
Greenhalgh T., Humphrey C., Hughes J., Macfarlane F.,
Butler C. & Pawson R. (2009) How do you modernize a
health service? A realist evaluation of whole-scale
transformation in London. Milbank Quarterly, 87(2),
391–416.
Hacking I. (1983) Representing and Intervening: Introductory Topics in the Philosophy of Natural Science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Harre R. & Secord P.F. (1972) The Explanation of Social
Behavior. Blackwell, Oxford.
Hodgkinson G.P. & Starkey K. (2012) Extending the foundations and reach of design science: further reflections
on the role of critical realism. British Journal of Management, 23(4), 605–610.
Houston S. (2001) Beyond social constructionism: critical
realism and social work. British Journal of Social Work,
31, 845–861.
Jefferies B. (2011) Critical realism – an empirical realist
critique. Working Paper Series. 11-03. Manchester
Metropolitan University Business School, Manchester.
Joseph J. (2014) Critical realism. The Encyclopedia of Political Thought, 781–782. DOI: 10.1002/9781118474396.wbept0225
Julnes G., Mark M.M. & Henry G.T. (1998) Review: promoting realism in evaluation: realistic evaluation and
the broader context. Evaluation, 4(4), 483–504.
Kazi M. (2000) Contemporary perspectives in the evaluation of practice. British Journal of Social Work, 30(6),
755–776.
Kazi M. (2003) Realist Evaluation in Practice: Health and
Social Work. Sage Publications, London.
Kontos P.C. & Poland B.D. (2009) Mapping new theoretical and methodological terrain for knowledge translation: contributions from critical realism and the arts.
Implementation Science, 4(1), 1–10. Available at: http://
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2639531/ [accessed 27 September 2015].
Lhussier M., Carr S.M. & Robson A. (2008) The potential
contribution of realistic evaluation to small-scale community interventions. Community Practitioner, 81(9),
25–28.
Lincoln Y.S. & Guba E.G. (2000) Paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and emerging confluences. In: The
Handbook of Qualitative Research (eds N.K. Denzin &
Y.S. Lincoln), pp. 163–188, 2nd edn. Sage, London.
Linsley P., Howard D. & Owen S. (2015) The construction
of context-mechanisms-outcomes in realistic evaluation.
Nurse Researcher, 22(3), 28–34.
Marchal B., Dedzo M. & Kegels G. (2010) A realistic
evaluation of the management of a well performing
regional hospital in Ghana. BMC Health Services
Research, 10(24), 1–14. Available at: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6963/10/24 [accessed 27 September
2015].
Marchal B., van Belle S., van Olmen J. et al. (2012) Is
realist evaluation keeping its promise? A review of published empirical studies in the field of health systems
research. Evaluation, 18(2), 192–212.
Maxwell J.A. (2012) A Realist Approach for Qualitative
Research. Sage, London.
McEvoy P. & Richards D. (2003) Critical realism: a way
forward for evaluation research in nursing? Journal of
Advanced Nursing, 43(4), 411–420.
McEvoy P. & Richards D. (2006) A critical realist rationale
for using a combination of quantitative and qualitative
methods. Journal of Research in Nursing, 11(1), 66–78.
Mingers J. (2000) The contribution of critical realism as
an underpinning philosophy for OR/MS and systems.
Journal of the Operational Research Society, 51(11),
1256–1270.
Mingers J. (2011) The contribution of systemic thought to
critical realism. Journal of Critical Realism, 10(3), 303–
330.
Norrie A. (2015) Roy Bhaskar: Philosopher whose school
of critical realism challenged established ways of thinking about being and knowledge. The Independent. Available at: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/
roy-bhaskar-philosopher-whose-school-of-critical-realismchallenged-established-ways-of-thinking-10009456.html
[accessed 27 September 2015].
Oladele D., Clark A.M., Richter S. et al. (2013) Critical
realism: a practical ontology to explain the complexities
of smoking and tobacco control in different resource
settings. Global Health Action, 6, 19303.
Oltmann C. & Boughey C. (2011) Using critical realism as
a framework in pharmacy education and social pharmacy research. Research in Social and Administrative
Pharmacy, 8(4), 333–337.
O’Mahoney J. & Vincent S.(2014) Critical realism as an
empirical project: a beginner’s guide. Ch. 1. In: Studying
Organizations Using Critical Realism (eds P.K. Edwards,
J. O’Mahoney & S. Vincent). Oxford University Press,
Oxford.
Outhwaite W. (1987) New Philosophies of Social Science.
Macmillan, London.
Parahoo K. (2006) Nursing Research, Principles, Process
and Issues. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.
Parlour R. & McCormack B. (2012) Blending critical realist
and emancipatory practice development methodologies:
10 of 11 Lynne Williams et al.
making critical realism work in nursing research. Nursing
Inquiry, 19, 308–321.
Pawson R. (2003) Nothing as practical as a good theory.
Evaluation, 9(4), 471–490.
Pawson R. (2006) Evidence-Based Policy – A Realist Perspective. Sage, London.
Pawson R. & Tilley N. (1997) Realistic Evaluation. Sage,
London.
Perron A. (2015) Special issues: the 2014 Banff conference: troubling practice. Nursing Philosophy, 16, 127–
129.
Pommier J., Guevel M.-R. & Jourdan D. (2010) Evaluation
of health promotion in schools: a realistic evaluation
approach using mixed methods. BMC Public Health, 10
(43), 1–12. Available at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
pmc/articles/PMC2824736/ [accessed 29 September
2015].
Porter S. (2001) Nightingale’s realist philosophy of science.
Nursing Philosophy, 2(1), 14–25.
Reisz M. (2014) Roy Bhaskar, 1944–2014. Available at:
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/people/obituaries/roy-bhas...–2014/2017419.article [accessed
27 September 2015].
Risjord M. (2010) Nursing Knowledge, Science, Practice
and Philosophy. Emory University, Wiley-Blackwell.
Roberts J.M. (2014) Critical realism, dialectics, and qualitative research methods. Journal for the Theory of
Social Behaviour, 44(1), 1–23.
Rycroft-Malone J., Fontenla M., Bick D. et al. (2010) A
realistic evaluation: the case of protocol-based care.
Implementation Science, 5(38), 1–14. Available at: http://
www.implementationscience.com/content/5/1/38 [accessed
27 September 2015].
Sayer A. (1992) Method in Social Science: a Realist
Approach. 2nd edn. Routledge, London.
Sayer A. (2000) Realism and Social Science. Sage Publications Ltd., London.
Spencer N. (1995) The rediscovery of reality. Green Left
Weekly 190.
Stake R.E. (1995) The Art of Case Study Research. Sage
Publications, London.
Stame N. (2004) Theory-based evaluation and types of
complexity. Evaluation, 10(1), 58–76.
Stickley T. (2006) Should service user involvement be consigned to history? A critical realist perspective. Journal
of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 13(5), 570–
577.
Syed J., Mingers J. & Murray P. (2009) Beyond rigour and
relevance: a critical realist approach to business education. Working Paper Series No 191. Kent Business
School, University of Kent, Canterbury.
Tilley N. (2000) Realistic evaluation: an overview. The
Founding Conference of the Danish Evaluation Society.
Available at: http://evidence-basedmanagement.com/
wpcontent/uploads/2011/11/nick_tilley.pdf [accessed 27
September 2015].
Timmins P. & Miller C. (2007) Making evaluations realistic: the challenge of complexity. Support for Learning,
22(1), 9–16.
Tolson D., McIntosh J., Loftus L. et al. (2007) Developing
a managed clinical network in palliative care: a realistic
evaluation. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 44
(2), 183–195.
Topping A. (2010) The quantitative-qualitative continuum.
In: The Research Process in Nursing (eds K. Gerrish &
A. Lacey), pp. 129–141, 6th edn. Wiley-Blackwell,
Oxford.
Wai-Chung Yeung H. (1997) Critical realism and realist
research in human geography: a method or a philosophy
in search of a method? Progress in Human Geography,
21(1), 51–74.
Wainwright S.P. (1997) A new paradigm for nursing: the
potential of realism. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 26
(6), 1262–1271.
Wand T., White K. & Patching J. (2010) Applying a realist(ic) framework to the evaluation of a new model of
emergency department based mental health nursing
practice. Nursing Inquiry, 17(3), 231–239.
Westhrop G., Prins E., Kusters C. et al. (2011) Realist
Evaluation: an Overview: Report From an Expert Seminar. Wageninen UR Centre for Development Innovation, The Netherlands.
Williams L. (2014) What works? A realist evaluation of
the role of intermediaries in promoting best practice in
infection prevention and control. Unpublished thesis.
Bangor University, Bangor.
Wilson V. & McCormack B. (2006) Critical realism as
emancipatory action: the case for realistic evaluation
in practice development. Nursing Philosophy, 7(1), 45–
57.