Facilitation skills: the catalyst for increased effectiveness in consultant practice and clinical systems leadership

Consultant practitioner is the pinnacle of the clinical career ladder for all health care disciplines in the United Kingdom. Consultant nurse, midwife and health visitor roles build on the clinical credibility and expertise characteristic of advanced level practice, but also possess expertise in: clinical systems leadership and the facilitation of culture change, learning and development; advanced consultancy approaches, and research and evaluation to prioritise person-centred, safe and effective care across patient pathways.
This project aimed to help new and emerging consultants to become more effective in their role through a programme of support to develop their expertise.

Emancipatory action research, supported by claims, concerns and issues tool, derived from Stakeholder Evaluation, and other methods (active learning, action learning, collaborative workshops and individual tools e.g. qualitative 360 degree feedback and reflective reviews) comprised the supportive intervention which enabled participants to research their own practice.

The programme’s methodology and methods helped participants to: research their own practice; theorise from practice; grow the facilitation skills needed to develop and demonstrate their own effectiveness; foster the effectiveness of others and; transform practice culture. Greater effectiveness in their multiple roles was demonstrated, as was the impact of this on others, services and organisations.
The study concludes that the support programme augmented by the methodology, facilitation skills and the 10 principles derived from a concept analysis of work-based learning is central to achieving improved effectiveness and transformation of others, services and organisations. Theoretical insights at collective/community levels also resulted. Key recommendations are identified for commissioners, higher education and research.

1) Avery, L., and J. Butler. 2008. “An Evaluation of the Role of Diabetes Nurse Consultants in the UK.” Journal of Diabetes Nursing 12 (2): 60–63.
2) Bellman, L., and P. Corrigan. 2010. “Using Action Research to Develop a Thoracic Support Nurse Role to Enhance Quality of Care.” Nursing times 106: 22. Accessed January 8 2015. http://www.nursingtimes.
3) net/nursing-practice/specialisms/practice-nursing/using-action-research-to-develop-a-thoracicsupport- nurse-role-to-enhance-quality-of-care-/5015619.article
4) Binnie, A., and A. Titchen. 1999. Freedom to Practise: The Development of Patient-Centred Nursing. Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
5) BRII (Bristol Royal Infirmary Inquiry) 2001. “The Report of the Public Inquiry into Children’s Heart Surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary 1984–1995.” Learning from Bristol. Presented to Parliament by the Secretary of State for Health by Command of Her Majesty July 2001 CM 5207(I).
6) Cardiff S. 2014. Person-Centred Leadership: A Critical Participatory Action Research Study Exploring and Developing a New Style of (Clinical) Nurse Leadership, Published Doctor of Philosophy Thesis, University of Ulster, Northern Ireland, in co-operation with the School of Nursing’s Knowledge Centre for the Implementation and Evaluation of Evidence-Based Practice at Fontys University of Applied Science. Eindhoven, the Netherlands: Ridderprint BV.
7) Coster, S., S. Redfern, J. Wilson-Barnett, A. Evans, R. Peccei, and D. Guest. 2006. “Impact of the Role of Nurse, Midwife and Health Visitor Consultant.” Journal of Advanced Nursing 55 (3): 352–363.
8) Dewar, B., and Sharp. 2013. “Appreciative Dialogue for Co-Facilitation in Action Research and Practice Development.” International Practice Development Journal 3 (2): 7.
9) Dewing, J. 2008. “Becoming and Being Active Learners and Creating Active Learning Workplaces: The Value of Active Learning in Practice Development.” In International Practice Development in Nursing and Healthcare, edited by K. Manley, B. McCormack and V. Wilson, 273–294. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
10) DH (Department of Health). 1999. Making a Difference: Strengthening the Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting Contribution to Health and Healthcare. London: HMSO. DH (Department of Health). 2000. The NHS Plan. London: DH.
11) DH (Department of Health). 2002. Implementing the NHS Plan – Ten Key Roles for Nurses DH London PL CNO (2002)5. Accessed March 14, 2016, http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20040105143802/doh.gov.uk/...
12) Fay, B. 1987. Critical Social Science: Liberation & Its Limits. Cambridge: Polity Press.
13) Francis R. 2010. Independent Inquiry into Care Provided by mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust January 2005 – March 2009 Volume I. London: The Stationary Office, HC375-I.
14) Garbett, R., and B. McCormack. 2002. “A Concept Analysis of Practice Development.” Nursing Times Research 7 (2): 87–100.
15) Garbett, R., S. Hardy, K. Manley, A. Titchen, and B. McCormack. 2007. “Developing a Qualitative Approach to 360 Degree Feedback to Aid Understanding and Development of Clinical Expertise.” Nursing Management 15: 342–347.
16) Gerrish, K., A. McDonnell, and F. Kennedy. 2013. “The Development of a Framework for Evaluating the Impact of Nurse Consultant Roles in the UK.” Journal of Advanced Nursing 69 (10): 2295–2308.
17) Graham I. W. 2007. Consultant Nurse-Consultant Physician: A New Partnership for Patient-Centred Care? Journal of Clinical Nursing. 16 (10): 1809–1817.
18) Gregorowski, A., E. Brennan, S. Chapman, F. Gibson, K. Khair, L. May, and A. Lindsay-Waters. 2013. “An Action Research Study to Explore the Nature of the Nurse Consultant Role in the Care of Children and Young People.” Journal of Clinical Nursing. 22 (1–2): 201–210.
19) Grundy, S. 1982. “Three Modes of Action Research.” Curriculum Perspectives 2 (3): 23–34.
20) Grundy S., and Kemmis. 1981. “‘Educational Action Research in Australia: The State of the Art’ Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the Australian Association for Research in Adelaide Cited by Grundy S (1982) Three Modes of Action Research.” CurriculumPerspectives 2 (3): 23–34.
21) Guba, E. G., and Y. S. Lincoln. 1989. Fourth Generation Evaluation. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
22) Guest D., S. Redfern, J. Wilson-Barnet, P. Dewe, R. Peccei, P. Rosenthal, A. Evans, C. Young, J. Montgomery, and P. Oakley. 2001. A Preliminary Evaluation of the Establishment of Nurse, Midwife and Health Visitor Consultants. Report to the Department of Health by a team from King’s College London and Birkbeck College. Management Centre, Kings College London http://www.kcl.ac.uk/nursing/nru/nurseconreport.htlm
23) Guest D., R. Peccei, P. Rosenthal, S. Redfern, J. Wilson-Barnet, P. Dewe, S. Coster, A. Evans, andA. Sudbury. 2004. An Evaluation of the Impact of Nurse, Midwife and Health Visitor Consultants. London: Management Centre, Kings College. http://www.kcl.ac.uk/nursing/nru/nurseconreport.htlm
24) Hardy, S., A. Titchen, B. McCormack, K. Manley. 2009. Revealing Nursing Expertise through Practitioner Inquiry. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell
25) Harvey, G., A. Loftus-Hill, J. Rycroft-Malone, A. Titchen, A. Kitson, B. McCormack, and K. Seers. 2002.
26) “Getting Evidence into Practice: The Role and Function of Facilitation.” Journal of Advanced Nursing 37 (6): 577–588.
27) Humphreys, A., S. Johnson, J. Richardson, E. Stenhouse, and M. Watkins. 2007. “A Systematic Review and Meta-Synthesis: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Nurse, Midwife/Allied Health Professional Consultants.” Journal of Clinical Nursing. 16 (10): 1792–1808.
28) Jinks, A. M., and G. Chalder. 2007. “Consensus and Diversity: An Action Research Study Designed to Analyse the Roles of a Group of Mental Health Consultant Nurses.” Journal of Clinical Nursing 16: 1323–1332.
29) Johns, C. 1995. “Achieving Effective Work as Professional Activity.” In Towards Advanced Nursing Practice: Key Concepts for Health Care, edited by J. E. Schober and S. M. Hinchliff, 252–280. London: Arnold.
30) Kemmis, S., and R. McTaggart. 1988. The Action Research Planner 3rd ed. Victoria: Deakin University Press, McTaggart.
31) Kennedy, F., A. McDonnell, K. Gerrish, A. Howarth, C. Pollard, J. Redman. 2011. “Evaluation of the Impact of Nurse Consultant Roles in the United Kingdom: A Mixed Method Systematic Literature Review”. Journal of Advanced Nursing 2012 Apr;68(4):721–742. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365- 2648.2011.05811.x. Epub 2011 Sep 26.
32) Kings Fund. 2015. The Practice of System Leadership: Being Comfortable with Chaos. London: Kings Fund.
33) Kirkup, B. 2015. The Report of the Morecambe Bay Investigation. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data...
34) Lathlean, J. 2007. “Researching the Implementation of Pioneering Roles in Nursing and Midwifery: Empirical Insights about Lecturer Practitioners, Consultant Nurses and Nurse Registrars.” Journal of Research in Nursing 12 (1): 29–39.
35) Lathlean, J., and A. Masterson. 2004. Evaluation of Nurse and Midwife Consultant Roles: An Initial Study. Final Report. Southampton: School of Nursing and Midwifery: University of Southampton.
36) van Lieshout F. 2013. Taking Action for Action. a Study of the Interplay between Contextual and Facilitator Characteristics in Developing an Effective Workplace Culture in a Dutch Hospital Setting, through Action Research. in: Institute of Nursing Research. Belfast, UK: University of Ulster
37) Manley. 1996. Consultancy MSc Nursing. Distance Learning Module London: RCN Institute.
38) Manley, K. 1997. “A Conceptual Framework for Advanced Practice: An Action Research Project Operationalising: An Advanced Practitioner/Consultant Nurse Role.’ Journal of Clinical Nursing 6 (3): 179–190.
39) Manley, K. 2000a. “Organisational Culture and Consultant Nurse Outcomes: Part 1 Organisational Culture.” Nursing Standard 14 (36): 34–38.
40) Manley, K. 2000b. “Organisational Culture and Consultant Nurse Outcomes: Part 2 Consultant Nurse Outcomes.” Nursing Standard 14 (37): 34–39.
41) Manley K. 2001. “Consultant Nurse: Concept, Processes, Outcome Unpublished” PhD Thesis RCN Institute/ Manchester University.
42) Manley, K. 2002. “Refining the Consultant Nurse Framework: Commentary on Critique of Consultant Nurse Framework.” Nursing in Critical Care 7 (2): 84–87.
43) Manley K. 2004. “Transformational Culture: A Culture of Effectiveness.“ In Practice Development in Nursing, edited by B. McCormack, K. Manley, and R. Garbett, 51–82. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
44) Manley, K., and A. Titchen. 2012. Being and Becoming a Consultant Nurse: Towards Greater Effectiveness through a Programme of Support. London: Royal College of Nursing. Manley, K., and B. McCormack. 2003. “Practice Development: Purpose, Methodology, Facilitation and Evaluation.” Nursing in Critical Care 8 (1): 22–29.
45) Manley K., S. Hardy, A. Titchen, R. Garbett, B. McCormack. 2005. Changing Patients’ Worlds through Nursing Practice Expertise. Exploring Nursing Practice Expertise through EAR and Fourth Generation Evaluation. A Royal College of Nursing Research Report 1998–2004. London: RCN
46) Manley, K., J. Webster, N. Hale, N. Hayes, and H. Minardi. 2008. “Leadership Role of Consultant Nurses Working with Older People: A Co-Operative Inquiry.” Journal of Nursing Management 16: 147–158.
47) Manley, K., A. Titchen, and S. Hardy. 2009. “Work Based Learning in the Context of Contemporary Healthcare Education and Practice: A Concept Analysis.” Practice Development in Health Care 8 (2): 87–127.
48) Manley K., K. Sanders, S. Cardiff, J. Webster. 2011b. ‘Effective Workplace Culture: The Attributes, Enabling Factors and Consequences of a New Concept.” International Practice Development Journal 1 (2): 1–29.
49) Manley, K., J. Crisp, C. Moss. 2011. “Advancing the Practice Development Outcomes Agenda within Multiple Contexts.’ International Practice Development Journal 1 (1): 1–16.
50) Manley, K., C. Jackson, A. Martin, J. Apps, I. Setchfield, G. Oliver. 2014 Transforming Urgent & Emergency Care Together. Canterbury: England Centre for Practice Development in partnership with East Kent
51) Hospitals University NHS Foundation Trust, SEACamb, NHS Ashford CCG, NHS Canterbury & Coastal CCG, NHS South Kent Coast CCG and NHS Thanet CCG and is funded by Health Education Kent Surrey Sussex.
52) McCormack, B., K. Manley, A. Kitson, A. Titchen, and G. Harvey. 1999. “Towards Practice Development – A Vision in Reality or a Reality without Vision?” Journal of Nursing Management 7: 255–264.
53) McCormack, B., K. Manley, V. Wilson. 2004. Evaluating Practice Developments. In Practice Development in Nursing, edited by B. McCormack, K. Manley, R. Garbett, 83–117. Oxford: Blackwells.
54) McCormack, B., K. Manley, and A. Titchen. 2013. Practice Development in Nursing and Healthcare. 2nd ed. Oxford: Blackwells-Wiley.
55) McGill I., & L. Beaty. 2006. Action Learning a Guide for Professional Management and Educational Development. (2nd ed). London: Routeledge Falmer
56) McIntosh, J., and D. Tolsen. 2008. “Leadership as Part of the Nurse Consultant’s Role: Banging the Drum for Patient Care.” Journal of Clinical Nursing 18: 219–227.
57) McIntosh J., D. Tolson. 2009. “Leadership as Part of the Nurse Consultant Role: Banging the Drum for Patient Care.” Journal of Clinical Nursing 18 (2): 219–227.
58) McSherry, R., D. Mudd, and Campbell. 2007. “Evaluating the Perceived Role of the Nurse Consultant through the Lived Experience of Healthcare Professionals.” Journal Clinical Nursing 16 (11): 2066–2080.
59) McTaggart, R. 1991. “Principles for Participatory Action Research.” Adult Education Quarterly 41 (3): 168–187.
60) Mezirow. 1981. “A Critical Theory of Adult Learning and Education Adult Education Quarterly.” 32 (1): 3–24.
61) Mullen, C., A. Gavin-Daley, H. Kilgannon, and J. Swift. 2011. “Nurse Consultants 10 Years on: An Insight to the Role for Nurse Managers.” Journal of Nursing Management 19 (6): 820–831.
62) Nancarrow, S. 2004. “Dynamic Role Boundaries in Intermediate Care Services.” Journal of Interprofessional Care 18 (2): 141–151.
63) Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC). 2008. The Code: Standards of Conduct, Performance and Ethics for Nurses and Midwives. London: NMC.
64) Ollerton J. 2012. IPAR, an Inclusive Disability Research Methodology with Accessible Analytical Tools. International Practice Development Journal 2 (2) Article 3. http://www.fons.org/library/journal/ volume2-issue2/article3
65) Patients Association. 2009. “Patients…Not Numbers, People…Not Statistics”. Accessed January 7, 2011. http://www.patientsassociation.com/DBIMGS/file/Patients%20not%20numb...
66) Patients Association. 2010. Listen to Patients, Speak up for Change. Accessed January 13, 2011. http://www.patientsassociation.org.uk/dbimgs/Listen%20to%20patients,...(1).pdf.
67) Pawson, R., and N. Tilley. 1997. Realistic Evaluation. London: Sage.
68) Prideaux, D. 1995. “Beyond Facilitation: Action Research as Self-Research and Self-Evaluation.” Evaluation Journal of Australasia 7 (1): 3–13.
69) Redwood, S. 2007. “Evaluating Nurse Consultants’ Work through Key Informant Perceptions.” Nursing Standard 21 (17): 35–40.
70) Ryan, S., A. Hassell, C. Thwaites, K. Manley, and D. Home. 2006. “Exploring the Perceived Role and Impact of the Nurse Consultant.” Musculoskeletal Care 4 (3): 167–173.
71) Rycroft-Malone J. 2004. “Research Implementation: Evidence, Context, and Facilitation – The PARIHS Framework”. In B. McCormack, K. Manley, R. Garbett, 118–147. Oxford: Practice Development in Nursing Blackwell Publishing.
72) Schon, D. A. 1983. The Reflective Practitioner. How Professionals Think in Action. New York: Basic Books, Harper Collins.
73) Seligman, Martin E. P., and Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi. 2000. “Positive Psychology: An Introduction.” American Psychologist 55 (1): 5–14.
74) Skills for Health. 2010. “Key Elements of the Career Framework; Skills for Health.” Accessed August 1, 2015. http://www.nwwmhub.nhs.uk/media/43160/career_framework_key_elements....
75) Snoeren M., and D. Frost. 2011. Realising Participation within an Action Research Project on Two Care Innovations Units Providing Care for Older People. International Practice Development Journal 1 (2):1–18. http://www.fons.org/Resources/Documents/Journal/Vol1No2/IPDJ_0102_03...
76) Tallis, R., and J. Davis. 2013. NHS SOS: How the NHS Was Betrayed – And How We Can save It. London: One world Publications.
77) Titchen, A. 2000. Professional Craft Knowledge in Patient-Centred Nursing and the Facilitation of Its Development D.Phil. Linacre College Oxford. Oxfordshire: Ashdale Press Tackley.
78) Titchen, A. 2004. “Helping Relationships for Practice Development: Critical Companionship”. In B. McCormack, K. Manley, R. Garbett,148–174. Oxford: Practice Development in Nursing Blackwell Publishing.
79) Titchen, A. 2009. “Developing Expertise through Nurturing Professional Artistry in the Workplace.” In Revealing Nursing Expertise through Practitioner Inquiry, edited by S. Hardy, A. Titchen, B. McCormack, and K. Manley, 219–243. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
80) Titchen, A., and K. Manley. 2006. “Spiralling towards Transformational Action Research: Philosophical and Practical Journeys.” Educational Action Research 14 (3): 333–356.
81) Titchen A., K. Manley. 2007. Facilitating Research as Shared Action and Transformation. In Being Critical and Creative in Qualitative Research, edited by J. Higgs, A. Titchen, H. Byrne Armstrong, and D. Horsfall, 108–119. Sydney: Hampden Press.
82) Titchen, A., and B. McCormack. 2010. “Dancing with Stones: Critical Creativity as Methodology for Human Flourishing.” Educational Action Research: An International Journal 18 (4): 531–554.
83) Woodward, V. A., C. Webb, and M. Prowse. 2006. “Nurse Consultants: Organizational Influences on Role Achievement.” J Clin Nurs. 15 (3): 272–280.