Youth footballers and the coach: Generation Z

Youth football nurseries have historically served to expand grassroots football with a commitment to improving talent. Building on recent research on the Developmental Model of Sport Participation and the Long-Term Athlete Development model, this study explored the experiences for youth footballers in the coaching setting. This study investigated the perceptions and beliefs of youth footballers (13-15 years) on their experiences in youth football club nurseries in Malta. The focus was on (i) the youth footballer-coach relationship; (ii) experiences from the coaching sessions and games; and (iii) environment factors of significant others. Forty-two youth footballers from six nurseries participated in six in-depth semi-structured focus-groups. Thematic analysis was used to analyse the data. The footballer-coach relationships revealed that participants desire for a coach that does not yell/ shout and remains calm, is caring and encouraging. The coach impacts resilience, motivation, mental-wellbeing, and decisions for dropouts. Youth footballers preferred deliberate play rather than deliberate practice pedagogies. Interestingly, co-operative coaching style was preferred by confident and skilful youths; while the command coaching style was reassuring for those who believed that they had a lot to learn. The findings showed that most participants preferred to play and enjoy themselves, rather than win every game and not play. The Gen Z characteristics of high expectations for success emerged in this study, but the focus on winning, rather than game strategy development was important to some of the youth footballers. This study recommends that the youth footballer-coaching relationship would benefit from the knowledge and application of advanced social-psychological disciplines from sports coaching sciences; and that youth football nursery programmes should be structured around participants and transitions of continued participation at recreational and high levels of performance.

Atkinson M. 2012. Key concepts in sport and exercise research methods. SAGE (Thousand Oaks, CA)
Bailey R.P. Dismore H. and Morley, D. 2009. ‘Talent development in physical education: a national survey of practices in England’, Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 14 (1) 59–72.

Baker J. and Young B. 2014. '20 Years Later: Deliberate Practice and the Development of Expertise in Sport', International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 7(1) 135-157.

Balyi I. and Hamilton A. 2004. Long-Term Athlete Development: Trainability in Childhood and Adolescence. Windows of Opportunity. Optimal Trainability. National Coaching Institute British Columbia & Advanced Training and Performance Ltd (Victoria).

Balyi I. Way R. and Higgs C. 2013. Long-Term Athlete Development. Human Kinetics (Champaign IL).

Barbour R. 2008. Introducing Qualitative Research. A Student Guide To The Craft Of Doing Qualitative Research. SAGE (London).

Bolotin A. and Bakayev V. 2017. 'Pedagogical Conditions Necessary for Effective Speed-Strength Training of Young Football Players (15-17 Years Old)'. Journal of Human Sport and Exercise, 12(2), 405-413. doi:10.14198/jhse.2017.122.17

Bonney D. Ireland J. Miller C. Mackreth K. and van Wely S. 2004. Advanced PE for OCR A2. Heinemann Educational Publishers (Oxford).

Braun V. and Clarke V. 2006. 'Using Thematic Analysis In Psychology'. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.

Braun V. Clarke V. Hayfield N. and Terry G. 2019. Thematic Analysis. Handbook of Research Methods in Health Social Sciences 843-860. In P. Liamputtong (Ed.), Handbook Of Research Methods In Health Social Sciences. (pp. 843–860). SAGE (London).

Bryman, A. 2016. Social Research Methods (5th edn). Oxford University Press (Oxford).
Busuttil G. 2011. A case study of drop outs in a Maltese football nursery. BSc (Hons) Sports and Physical Activity Disseration. University of Malta.

Camilleri P. 2014. The positive and negative aspects of young people's involvement in football. BA (Hons) Youth and Community Studies Dissertation. University of Malta

Cassar A. and Gauci M.R. 2015. Talent Development in Maltese Football Nurseries. B.Ed (Hons) Dissertation. University of Malta

Cervello E. Escarti A. and Guzman J. 2007. 'Youth Sport Drop Out from fhe Achievement Goal Theory'. Psicothema 19(1), 65-71.

Chatoupis C. 2015. 'Pairing Learners by Companionship: Effects on Motor Skill Performance and Comfort Levels in the Reciprocal Style of Teaching'. Physical Educator, 72(5), 307-323.

Cohen, L., Manion, L. and Morrison, K. (2018) Research Methods in Education, 8th edn. London: Routledge.

Côté J. & Abernethy B. 2012. A developmental approach to sport expertise. In Murphy S. (Ed.) The Oxford handbook of sport and performance psychology. (pp. 435–447). Oxford University Press (Oxford).

Côté J. and Hay J. 2002. Children' s Involvement in Sport: a developmental perspective. In J. M. Silva and D. Stevens (Eds.) Psychological foundations of sport (2nd ed).(pp. 484–502) .Allyn and Bacon (Boston MA). pp.

Côté J. and Vierimaa M. 2014. The developmental model of sport participation: 15 years after its first conceptualization. Science and Sports, 29S, 63-69.

Cronin C. and Armour K. 2013. '‘Being’ in the coaching world: new insights on youth performance coaching from an interpretative phenomenological approach'. Sport Education and Society, 22(8), 919-931.

Dhivyadeepa E. 2015. Sampling Techniques in Educational Research. Laxmi Book (Publication Pune, Maharashtra).

Ennis C.D. and Chen S. 2012. Interviews and focus groups In K. Armour and D. Macdonald (eds.) Research methods in physical education and youth sport. (pp. 217-236). Routledge, (Abingdon).

Ericsson K. 2003. Development of elite performance and deliberate practice: An update from the perspective of the expert performance approach. In J. Starkes and K. Ericsson Expert Performance in Sports. Human Kinetics (Champaign IL).

Ericsson K. Tesch-Roemer C. and T.Krampe R. 1993. 'The Role of Deliberate Practice in the Acquisition of Expert Performance'. Psychological Review, 100(3), 363–406.

Ferreira M. and Armstrong K. 2002. 'An Investigation of the Relationship Between Parents’ Causal Attributions of Youth Soccer Dropout, Time in Soccer Organisation, Affect Towards Soccer and Soccer Organisation, and Post-Soccer Dropout Behaviour. Sport Management Review, 5(2), 149-178.
Flores-Aguilar G. Prat-Grau M. Ventura Vall-Llovera C. and Ríos Sisó X. 2021' ‘I was Always Made Fun of for Being Fat’: First-Hand Accounts of Bullying in Children’s Football'. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 26(6) 549-561 DOI: 10.1080/17408989.2020.1826918

Franks M. Hodges N. and More K. 2001. 'Analysis Of Coaching Behaviour'. International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport, 1(1), 27-36.

Gergen K. 2015. An invitation to social construction. 3rd Edition. (SAGE London).

Gould D. Nalepa J. and Mignan M. 2020. 'Coaching Generation Z Athletes'. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 32(1) 104-120.

Harell M. C. and Bradley M. A. 2009. Data Collection Methods Semi-Structured Interviews and Focus Groups. RAND Corporation (Santa Monica: CA).

Jones I. Brown L. and Holloway I. 2012. Qualitative Research in Sport and Physical Activity. SAGE (London).

Jowett S. and Lavallee D.(eds.) 2007. Social Psychology in Sport. Human Kinetics (Champaign IL).

Krueger R.A. and Casey M.A. 2015. Focus groups: a practical guide for applied research. (5th edn). SAGE (London).

Kvale, S., & Brinkmann, S. (2009). InterViews: Learning the craft of qualitative research interviewing (2nd edn). SAGE (London).

Larsen T. Hoye A. Tojmsland H. Holsen I. Wold B. Heuze J. Sarrazin P. 2015. 'Creating A Supportive Environment Among Youth Football Players: A Qualitative Study of French and Norwegian Youth Grassroots Football Coaches'. Health Education, 115(6) 570-586.

LLoyd R.S. and Oliver J. 2012. 'The Youth Physical Development Model.' Strength and Conditioning, 34(3) 61-72.

Mageau G. and Vallerand R. 2003. The Coach-Athlete Relationship: A Motivational Model . Journal of Sports Sciences, 21,883–904.

Maguire M. and Delahunt B. 2017. Doing a Thematic Analysis: A Practical Step-by-Step Guide for Learning and Teaching Scholars. All Ireland Journal of Higher Education, 9(3) 3351-3364.

Marshall N. M. 1996. Sampling For Qualitative Research. Family Practice, 13(6), 522-526.

Martens R. 2012. Successful Coaching (4th ed). Human Kinetics (Champaign IL).

McDougall M. Saarinen M. and Ryba T.V 2023. 'Coaching Generation Z: A Response to Gould et al from a Critical Cultural Perspective'. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 1-13, DOI: 10.1080/10413200.2023.2224852 (accessed 17th August 2023)

Miller B. Roberts G. and Ommundsen Y. 2003. 'Effect of Motivational Climate on Sports Participation amongst Competitive Youth Male and Female Football Players'. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine ond Science in Sports, 14, 193-202.

Mills A. Butt J. Maynard I. and Harwood C. 2012. Identifying Factors Perceived to Influence the Development of Elite Youth Football Academy Players. Journal of Sports Science, 30(15), 1592 -1640.

Mosston M. and Ashworth S. 2008. Teaching Physical Education (1st on line edition). Available at Teaching Physical Education (Accessed 15th September 2017).

Partington M. Cushion C. and Harvey S. 2013. 'An Investigation of the Effect of Athletes’ Age on the Coaching Behaviours of Professional Top-Level Youth Soccer Coaches'. Journal of Sports Sciences, 32(5), 403-414.

Reeves C. W. Nicholls A. R. and McKenna J. 2009. 'Stressors and Coping Strategies Among Early and Middle Adolescent Premier League Academy Football Players: Differences According to Age'. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 21(1), 31-48.

Rudolph C. W. Rauvola R. S. Costanza D. P. and Zacher H. 2021. 'Generations and Generational Differences: Debunking Myths in Organizational Science and Practice and Paving New Paths Forward'. Journal of Business and Psychology 36(6), 945–967.

Sieghartsleitner R. Zuber C. Zibung M. Charbonnet B. and Conzelmann A. 2019.Talent Selection in Youth Football: Technical Skills Rather than General Motor Performance Predict Future Player Status of Football Talents, Current Issues in Sport Science (CISS), 4. 011. https://doi.org/10.15203/CISS_2019.011

Sim J. Waterfield J. 2019. 'Focus Group Methodology: Some Ethical Challenges'. Quality and Quantity, 53, 3003–3022.

Skinner E. and Edge K. 2002. Self-Determination Coping and Development. In E. Deci and R. Ryan Handbook of Self-Determination Research (pp. 297-337). University of Rochester (Rochester NY).

Stafford I. 2005. Coaching for Long-term Athlete Development. Coachwise Business Solutions/The National Coaching Foundation, (Leeds).

Stephens R. Spierer D. K. and Katehis E. 2018. 'Effect of Swearing on Strength and Power Performance'. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 35, 111–117

Stewart C. 2013. 'The Negative Behaviours Of Coaches: “Don’t Be This Guy”'. The Physical Educator, 70(1) 1-14.

Strachan L. Côté J. and Deakin J. 2009. 'An Evaluation of Personal and Contextual Factors in Competitive Youth Sport', Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 21(3), 340-355.

Strachan L. Côté J. and Deakin J. 2011. 'A New View: Exploring Positive Youth Development in Elite Sport Contexts', Qualitative Research in Sport Exercise and Health, 3(1), 9-32.

Su Y. and Reeve J. 2011. 'A Meta-analysis of the Effectiveness of Intervention Programs Designed to Support Autonomy', Educational Psychology Review, 23(1),159-189.

Subijana C. L. D. Martin L. J. Tejón O. and Côté J. 2021. 'Adolescent Athletes’ Perceptions of Both Their Coachs’ Leadership and their Personal Motivation', Perceptual and Motor Skills, 128(2), 813-830.

Taylor W. Piper H. and Garratt D. 2016. Sports Coaches as ‘Dangerous Individuals’—Practice Aa Governmentality . Sport Education and Society, 21(2), 183-199.

Toering T. T. Elferink-Gemser M. T. Jordet G. and Visscher C. 2009. 'Self-regulation and performance level of elite and non-elite youth football players', Journal of Sports Sciences, 27(14), 1509–1517.

Van Yperen N. W. 2009. 'Why Some Make it and others Do Not: Identifying Psychological Factors that Predict Career Success in Professional Adult Soccer'. The Sport Psychologist 23(3), 317–329.

Wall M. and Côté J. 2007. 'Developmental Activities that Lead to Drop Out and Investment in Sport', Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 12(1), 77-87.

Wilkinson S. 2016. Analysing Focus Group Data. In D. Silverman Qualitative Research. (pp. 83-101). SAGE (Los Angeles: CA).

Youth Football Association 2015. Malta Football Nurseries. Retrieved from The Youth Football Association: http://theyouthfa.org.mt/nurseries/ (accessed 15th May 2015).