Portraits of teachers in landscapes of change: exploring the role of teachers in school improvement

PhD Thesis


Durrant, J. 2013. Portraits of teachers in landscapes of change: exploring the role of teachers in school improvement. PhD Thesis Canterbury Christ Church University Faculty of Education
AuthorsDurrant, J.
TypePhD Thesis
Qualification namePhD
Abstract

This thesis focuses on an investigation which aimed to explore how teachers interpret their roles and construct their professional identities in relation to school improvement and how they can be supported in their contributions in this respect. The initial research questions were set within a conceptual framework linking teacher professionalism and school improvement, in particular the symbiotic and reciprocal relationships between individuals and organisations which were illuminated by the concepts of agency and structuration. Research aims, questions and conceptual development were reflexively and iteratively modified, to encompass the significance of school context in influencing professional identity and agency and to explore intractable dilemmas arising in interpreting external and internal policy requirements in relation to personal values. The implications of narrative enquiry for validity were acknowledged, focusing on distilling the ‘essence’ of situated professional selves and identities through portraiture to explore these substantive themes.

The professional values, priorities and aspirations of six teachers were investigated through semi-structured interviews incorporating elicitation tools, and presented as a form of nested case study where individual portraits were set within the organisational landscapes of their two contrasting schools, based on evidence representing a range of perspectives. This involved navigating the methodological territory between narratives and portraits. Analysis is presented as an ‘exhibition’, with three ‘galleries’ exploring different themes emerging from the empirical evidence. This enabled comparisons to be made between the stance that teachers choose to take in relation to internally or externally driven change and their own motivations, aspirations and actions to achieve outcomes according with their personal values and concerns.

The research contributes new understandings in relation to how, within ‘imposed’, ‘selected’ and ‘constructed’ organisational environments (Bandura, 2001), teachers’ professional identities are, to a greater or lesser extent, imposed or constructed. This in turn affects their agency in influencing their professional environments aligned with their personal professional values and aspirations. The empirical evidence therefore shows the significance of organisational cultures, leadership and individual agency, in influencing how professional environments and identities are constructed or imposed. A new model is derived from the empirical evidence and parallel conceptual development, contrasting complementary epistemological, ontological and agentic perspectives for schooling. This provides a framework for developing professional identity and professionality, in which individual agency is considered a vital dimension. Since teachers have a predominantly narrative understanding of reality, it is argued that narrative and visual approaches are key to such school improvement work. Making the agentic perspective visible and developmental supports key components of agency - intentionality, forethought, self-reactiveness and self-reflectiveness (ibid.). The resulting levels of engagement give grounds for optimism in supporting teachers’ more powerful individual and collective agency, including working critically and strategically with systemic reform, contributing proactively to local initiatives for change and pursuing personal change agendas.

Year2013
File
Publication process dates
Deposited09 Apr 2013
Accepted2013
Output statusUnpublished
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/86x15/portraits-of-teachers-in-landscapes-of-change-exploring-the-role-of-teachers-in-school-improvement

Download files

  • 132
    total views
  • 206
    total downloads
  • 10
    views this month
  • 2
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Creative postgraduate pedagogy for personal and professional learning: Risks and rewards
Durrant, J. 2022. Creative postgraduate pedagogy for personal and professional learning: Risks and rewards. in: Saunders, L. and D. Trotman (ed.) The Professional Doctorate in Education: Activism, Transformation and Practice Newcastle upon Tyne Cambridge Scholars Publishing. pp. 67-90
Teacher agency, professional development and school improvement
Durrant, J. 2020. Teacher agency, professional development and school improvement. London Routledge, Taylor and Francis.
Teacher agency, professional development and school improvement
Durrant, J. 2016. Teacher agency, professional development and school improvement.
What is evidence-based practice and why does it matter?
Durrant, J. 2014. What is evidence-based practice and why does it matter? in: Austin, R. (ed.) Researching Primary Education London Learning Matters/SAGE. pp. 9-24
Teacher-led School Improvement
Durrant, J., Frost, D., Head, M. and Holden, G. 2000. Teacher-led School Improvement. London; New York Falmer Press.
A question of impact
Durrant, J. 2008. A question of impact.
A question of impact
Durrant, J. 2008. A question of impact.
Agency, enquiry and inclusion in school improvement
Durrant, J. 2009. Agency, enquiry and inclusion in school improvement.
Creativity, challenge and change
Durrant, J. 2009. Creativity, challenge and change.
Choosing to change
Durrant, J. 2007. Choosing to change.
Structured autonomy, internal accountability, sustainable improvement: learning from innovative development projects in the UK
Durrant, J. and Holden, G. 2007. Structured autonomy, internal accountability, sustainable improvement: learning from innovative development projects in the UK.
Teachers leading change: Frameworks and key ingredients for school improvement
Durrant, J. 2005. Teachers leading change: Frameworks and key ingredients for school improvement. Leading and Managing. 10 (2), pp. 10-29.
Improvement matters: An integrated approach to the question of impact
Durrant, J. 2007. Improvement matters: An integrated approach to the question of impact. Professional Development Today. 10 (2), pp. 6-12.
Teachers as leaders: exploring the impact of teacher-led development work
Frost, D. and Durrant, J. 2002. Teachers as leaders: exploring the impact of teacher-led development work. School Leadership & Management. 22 (2), pp. 143-161. https://doi.org/10.1080/1363243022000007728
Helping schools to know themselves: exploring partnerships between schools and Higher Education Institutions to generate trustful, critical dialogue for review and development
Durrant, J., Dunnill, R. and Clements, S. 2004. Helping schools to know themselves: exploring partnerships between schools and Higher Education Institutions to generate trustful, critical dialogue for review and development. Improving Schools. 7 (2), pp. 151-170. https://doi.org/10.1177/1365480204047346
Teachers leading change: Doing research for school improvement
Durrant, J. and Holden, G. 2006. Teachers leading change: Doing research for school improvement. London Paul Chapman.
Partnership, leadership and learning: building individual and organisational capacity through an accredited programme
Durrant, J. 2003. Partnership, leadership and learning: building individual and organisational capacity through an accredited programme. Professional Development Today. 2003 (Spring), pp. 6-12.