Formally equal, but not really: the second stage of an ongoing study into English school students’ perceptions of ‘the citizen’

Journal article


Leighton, R. 2018. Formally equal, but not really: the second stage of an ongoing study into English school students’ perceptions of ‘the citizen’. Citizenship Teaching and Learning. 13 (1), pp. 31-44. https://doi.org/10.1386/ctl.13.1.31_1
AuthorsLeighton, R.
Abstract

This paper presents a discussion based primarily upon the findings of the second stage of on-going research into school students’ perceptions of ‘the Citizen’.

The first stage was an analysis of images in textbooks intended for GCSE Citizenship Studies students aged 14-16, the second stage – a year later – involved interviews with A Level Citizenship Studies students aged 16-18 and with teachers of Citizenship. It was found that the images present a particular and unrepresentative image of ‘being British’, a part of which students appear to absorb into their own perceptions, irrespective of their personal experiences. The homogeneity of responses, across class, ethnicity, gender and professional role struck the researcher as notable, and similarities and differences are examined. The images represent a highly selective and distorted version of the reality of being English, one which promotes a false consciousness and acceptance of the status quo; uncovering whether or to what extent that version of reality is accepted by those involved is the purpose of this study.

Responses in interviews showed that neither the students nor their teachers subscribed to the message behind the images, and that they had their own versions of the reality of ‘the Citizen’.

KeywordsCitizen; class; ethnicity; gender; students; teachers
Year2018
JournalCitizenship Teaching and Learning
Journal citation13 (1), pp. 31-44
PublisherIngenta
ISSN1751-1917
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1386/ctl.13.1.31_1
Publication dates
Print01 Mar 2018
Publication process dates
Deposited08 Feb 2018
Accepted2018
Accepted author manuscript
Output statusPublished
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/8881w/formally-equal-but-not-really-the-second-stage-of-an-ongoing-study-into-english-school-students-perceptions-of-the-citizen

Download files

Accepted author manuscript
  • 2
    total views
  • 1
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Theorizing young people's perceptions of their citizenship identity
Leighton, R. and Nielsen, L. 2018. Theorizing young people's perceptions of their citizenship identity. in: Pineda-Alfonso, J. (ed.) Handbook of Research on Education for Participation Citizenship and Global Prosperity Pennsylvania, USA IGI Global.
Ethnicity, gender, social class and citizenship: comparative views from England and Sweden
Leighton, R. and Nielsen, L. 2017. Ethnicity, gender, social class and citizenship: comparative views from England and Sweden. Teaching Citizenship. 45, pp. 42-43.
What are the gender, class and ethnicity of citizenship? A study of upper secondary school students’ views on citizenship education in England and Sweden
Nielsen, L. and Leighton, R. 2017. What are the gender, class and ethnicity of citizenship? A study of upper secondary school students’ views on citizenship education in England and Sweden. Confero. https://doi.org/10.3384/confer.2001-4562.170530
England's self-image as portrayed in public examination Citizenship Education textbooks
Leighton, R. 2014. England's self-image as portrayed in public examination Citizenship Education textbooks. in: Cunningham, P. and Fretwell, N. (ed.) Innovative Practice and Research Trends in Identity, Citizenship and Education London CiCe. pp. 140-155
Testament video interview with Ralph Leighton
Blamires, M. and Leighton, R. 2013. Testament video interview with Ralph Leighton.
Citizenship education for children of the elite in England
Leighton, R. 2013. Citizenship education for children of the elite in England. in: Cunningham, P. (ed.) Identities and Citizenship Education: Controversy, Crisis and Challenges London CiCe. pp. 420-428
Overcoming the nocebo effect - a radical approach to citizenship education
Leighton, R. 2013. Overcoming the nocebo effect - a radical approach to citizenship education. International Journal of Education for Social Justice. 2 (1).
Citizenship teachers: different types, different needs
Leighton, R. 2012. Citizenship teachers: different types, different needs.
Introducing pre-service citizenship teachers to the design and implementation of focus days to enhance their professional learning
Leighton, R. 2011. Introducing pre-service citizenship teachers to the design and implementation of focus days to enhance their professional learning. Citizenship Teaching and Learning. 7 (1), pp. 89-102. https://doi.org/10.1386/ctl.7.1.89_1
Education and schooling 11-16 years
Peterson, A. and Leighton, R. 2012. Education and schooling 11-16 years. in: Arthur, J. and Peterson, A. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Education Abingdon Routledge. pp. 190-198
Sociology of education
Leighton, R. 2012. Sociology of education. in: Arthur, J. and Peterson, A. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Education Abingdon Routledge. pp. 58-65
Post 14 Citizenship examinations
Leighton, R. 2006. Post 14 Citizenship examinations. http://citized.info.
Some insights into Citizenship teacher training in France
Leighton, R. and Pink, R. 2006. Some insights into Citizenship teacher training in France.
Teaching Citizenship is a subversive activity
Leighton, R. 2005. Teaching Citizenship is a subversive activity.
What you give is what you get
Leighton, R. 2004. What you give is what you get.
Who are you? An introductory examination of Citizenship education
Leighton, R. 2002. Who are you? An introductory examination of Citizenship education.
Can education be subversive? Postman And Weingartner and the case of citizenship in the National Curriculum for England
Leighton, R. 2006. Can education be subversive? Postman And Weingartner and the case of citizenship in the National Curriculum for England.
Trainees, mentors and citizenship: fair conflict resolution begins here
Leighton, R. 2004. Trainees, mentors and citizenship: fair conflict resolution begins here. Teaching Citizenship. 9, pp. 26-31.
The (f)utility of focus days in developing citizenship education
Leighton, R. 2010. The (f)utility of focus days in developing citizenship education.
Radical education: the past?
Leighton, R. 2009. Radical education: the past? in: Arthur, J. and Davies, I. (ed.) The Routledge Education Studies Textbook London, UK Routledge. pp. 207-215
Developing active participation in citizenship
Leighton, R. 2010. Developing active participation in citizenship. in: Gearon, L. (ed.) Learning to Teach Citizenship in the Secondary School London, UK Routledge. pp. 135-143
The nature of citizenship education provision: an initial study
Leighton, R. 2004. The nature of citizenship education provision: an initial study. Curriculum Journal. 15 (2), pp. 167-181. https://doi.org/10.1080/0958517042000226829
Revisiting Postman and Weingartner’s ‘New education’ – is teaching citizenship a subversive activity?
Leighton, R. 2006. Revisiting Postman and Weingartner’s ‘New education’ – is teaching citizenship a subversive activity? International Journal of Citizenship Teaching and Learning. 2 (1), pp. 79-89.
Planning, evaluating and auditing the whole-school provision
Leighton, R. 2007. Planning, evaluating and auditing the whole-school provision. in: Gearon, L. (ed.) A Practical Guide to Teaching Citizenship in the Secondary School London Routledge. pp. 72-78
Teaching citizenship education: a radical approach
Leighton, R. 2011. Teaching citizenship education: a radical approach. London Continuum.