Local perspectives through distant eyes: an exploration of English language teaching in Kerala in Southern India

PhD Thesis


Balchin, K. 2017. Local perspectives through distant eyes: an exploration of English language teaching in Kerala in Southern India. PhD Thesis Canterbury Christ Church University Faculty of Arts and Humanities
AuthorsBalchin, K.
TypePhD Thesis
Qualification namePhD
Abstract

This thesis examines professionalism of English language teaching (ELT) in one particular setting, the state of Kerala in southern India.

It reveals that there is an independent and unrecognised professionalism amongst ELT professionals in the setting. This includes a lack of recognition of the efficacy of methods and approaches traditionally used in the setting and a lack of recognition of the informal professional development that is happening in the setting. This professionalism is unrecognised by local ELT professionals because of their belief in ‘Western TESOL’. I am only able recognise it when I learn, through an autoethnography of my own professionalism, to put aside my own preoccupations with ‘Western TESOL’.

The initial objective of this study was to attempt to gain insights into local perspectives surrounding ELT methodology and teacher education, set against a background of a perceived need for methodological change in the setting. However, once the study had begun, it became clear that my own professional background and experiences, my ‘Western TESOL’ ‘professional baggage’, combined with the fact that I was coming into the setting as an outsider, seeing it through distant eyes, was affecting the ways in which I was viewing the setting and interpreting the events happening within it. As I began to offload some of this ‘professional baggage’, realising that my ‘Western TESOL’ understanding of the setting did not necessarily match local participants’ understandings of it, I began to question and re-evaluate the data I had collected. For example, I realised that I was focusing on what I saw as the negative aspects of what I was observing and being told about ELT in the setting, and comparing these to approaches to ELT in ‘Western TESOL’ settings that I was more familiar with. Over time, I began to look at these same aspects in a more positive light, seeing different perspectives and valuing what I was seeing or being told in different ways. My re-evaluations of the data from the setting over time also thus became a focus of the study.

The study as a whole is therefore ethnographic in terms of attempting to understand local perspectives, using open-ended questionnaire, classroom observation, interview and field note data, with an autoethnographic dimension to acknowledge the influence of my own distant eyes perspective in understanding these local perspectives. It brings into focus how I, as a researcher, through re-evaluating my own data and as a result gaining greater insight into my own positioning, was able to give credit to different perspectives on the data collected, particularly the data from classroom observations and teacher accounts of practice, and in the light of this to offer possible ways forward for ELT in the setting.

It has implications for local ELT professionals in terms of understanding and appreciating their own professionalism. It also has implications for TESOL professionals in unfamiliar settings in terms of the need to understand the complexity of these settings, rather than make hasty judgments about local practices, particularly in the case of ‘Western TESOL’ professionals working in ‘non-Western TESOL’ settings.

It may therefore be of interest both to ‘Western’ teachers, teacher trainers and academics working or researching, or intending to work or carry out research, in settings with which they are not familiar, particularly ‘non-Western TESOL’ settings, and to local TESOL professionals and academics in the setting for the study.

KeywordsEnglish; Language; Teaching; Kerala
Year2017
File
File
File Access Level
Restricted
Publication process dates
Deposited06 Sep 2017
Completed2017
Output statusUnpublished
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/88536/local-perspectives-through-distant-eyes-an-exploration-of-english-language-teaching-in-kerala-in-southern-india

Download files

  • 155
    total views
  • 168
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Using instructional technologies to cater for individual learner differences
Balchin, K. and Bouzaki, F. 2022. Using instructional technologies to cater for individual learner differences. International Journal of TESOL Studies. 4 (3), pp. 111-124. https://doi.org/10.46451/ijts.2022.03.09
Letting students speak, or be silent if they prefer
Balchin, K. and Djedid, S. 2022. Letting students speak, or be silent if they prefer. Faversham, UK IATEFL.
Exploring teachers’ capacity to engage with remote English language teaching environments
Balchin, K. 2022. Exploring teachers’ capacity to engage with remote English language teaching environments.
Teachers’ knowledge and skills for online English language teaching: the interface between theory and practice
Balchin, K. 2022. Teachers’ knowledge and skills for online English language teaching: the interface between theory and practice .
Letting silent students speak or be silent if they prefer
Balchin, K. and Djedid, S. 2021. Letting silent students speak or be silent if they prefer .
Exploring the role of context and collaboration in normalising technology use in English language teaching in secondary schools in Malaysia
Balchin, K. and Wild, C. 2020. Exploring the role of context and collaboration in normalising technology use in English language teaching in secondary schools in Malaysia. Computer Assisted Language Learning. 35 (7), pp. 1437-1457. https://doi.org/10.1080/09588221.2020.1803360
It's all in the numbers: enhancing technology use in urban and rural environments
Balchin, K. and Wild, C. 2018. It's all in the numbers: enhancing technology use in urban and rural environments. in: Tafazoli, D. and Gomez Parra, M. (ed.) Cross-Cultural Perspectives on Technology-Enhanced Language Learning Hershey, PA Information Science Reference. pp. 203-221
How learners learn, how teachers teach
Balchin, K. 2014. How learners learn, how teachers teach.
Teacher development – 21st century perspectives
Balchin, K. 2014. Teacher development – 21st century perspectives.
What’s the point of asking teachers to reflect?
Balchin, K. 2015. What’s the point of asking teachers to reflect?
Expanding the vision: a study of trainee teachers’ beliefs about using technology in the English language classroom
Balchin, K. and Wild, C. 2015. Expanding the vision: a study of trainee teachers’ beliefs about using technology in the English language classroom. Asian EFL Journal. 17 (4), pp. 37-67.
Exploring the role of recently-qualified English teachers in developing technology use in language classrooms through communities of practice
Balchin, K. and Wild, C. 2016. Exploring the role of recently-qualified English teachers in developing technology use in language classrooms through communities of practice. London British Council.
The place of technology in teacher training and teacher development programmes
Balchin, K. 2010. The place of technology in teacher training and teacher development programmes.
Using technology in second language learning: expanding the vision - a study of pre-service teachers
Balchin, K. 2010. Using technology in second language learning: expanding the vision - a study of pre-service teachers.
Communicative methodology and technology: fusion or confusion?
Balchin, K. 2010. Communicative methodology and technology: fusion or confusion?
Using technology in second language learning: what’s stopping you?
Balchin, K. and Lal, C. 2011. Using technology in second language learning: what’s stopping you?
Three years overseas: the impact of a substantial U.K.-based element in a training programme for English Language teachers
Balchin, K. and Saw, N. 2013. Three years overseas: the impact of a substantial U.K.-based element in a training programme for English Language teachers.
The influence of the activity type and of the teacher in promoting autonomous learning in the language classroom
Balchin, K., Manjit Singh, S., Saw, N. and Teoh, L. 2011. The influence of the activity type and of the teacher in promoting autonomous learning in the language classroom.
Activity-based language practice
Balchin, K. 2012. Activity-based language practice.
Where do we go from here? Practitioners’ views on the state of ELT in Kerala, Southern India
Balchin, K. 2012. Where do we go from here? Practitioners’ views on the state of ELT in Kerala, Southern India.
Classroom strategies for developing autonomous vocabulary learners
Balchin, K., Jamal, N. and Jenam, I. 2011. Classroom strategies for developing autonomous vocabulary learners.
Promoting learner autonomy among English language learners
Balchin, K. 2012. Promoting learner autonomy among English language learners. English Activities Update. 2 (1).
Towards a more communicative approach to ELT in India: the missing link between theory and practice
Balchin, K. and Lal, C. 2011. Towards a more communicative approach to ELT in India: the missing link between theory and practice. in: Jamuna, B. and Lal, C. (ed.) New Strides in English Teaching Kochi, India Gowli. pp. 93-99
Using technology in the English language classroom in Kerala: what's stopping you?
Balchin, K. 2011. Using technology in the English language classroom in Kerala: what's stopping you? Proceedings of International Conference on ELT: Pedagogical Strategies in the 21st Century.