From indifference to hostility: police sfficers, organisational responses and the symbolic value of ‘in-service’ higher education in policing

Journal article


Hallenberg, K. and Cockcroft, T. 2017. From indifference to hostility: police sfficers, organisational responses and the symbolic value of ‘in-service’ higher education in policing. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice. https://doi.org/10.1093/police/paw055
AuthorsHallenberg, K. and Cockcroft, T.
Abstract

The relationship between Higher Education (HE) and the knowledge and skill requirements of police officers remains a contentious policy area in England. This paper addresses experiences of 31 officers from a large urban force who have undertaken HE level study whilst in service. Overwhelmingly, officers reported a sense of indifference on the part of the organisation to their successful completion of an HE level educational programme. In addition, some participants experienced tokenistic acknowledgement of their achievement whilst others perceived outright hostility. In light of the findings we argue that, for the police organisation, there is a danger that the value of HE appears in its symbolic cultural capital rather than in the substantive knowledge and skills graduate officers could bring to the organisation and practice of policing. Moreover, the lack of structural and cultural integration has a detrimental effect on how officers with ‘in-service’ degrees view their work, career prospects and the organisation as a whole.

KeywordsPolice education; higher education; organisational responses
Year2017
JournalPolicing: A Journal of Policy and Practice
PublisherOxford Journals
ISSN1752-4512
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1093/police/paw055
Publication dates
Print31 Jan 2017
Publication process dates
Deposited21 Dec 2016
Accepted15 Dec 2016
Accepted author manuscript
Output statusPublished
Additional information

Article embargoed for 24 months as per licence - needs date setting when published. CC 21.12.2016

Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/87zwv/from-indifference-to-hostility-police-sfficers-organisational-responses-and-the-symbolic-value-of-in-service-higher-education-in-policing

Download files

  • 138
    total views
  • 193
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

This is not a drill: scoping police and partnership preparedness for the consequences of climate change
Lydon, D., Hallenberg, K. and Kapageorgiadou, V. 2023. This is not a drill: scoping police and partnership preparedness for the consequences of climate change.
Social and environmental justice for a sustainable future
Hallenberg, K., Maclean, A., Consorte-McCrea, A., Ali, Z., Makinde, M. and Martin, E. 2023. Social and environmental justice for a sustainable future.
"It's just some numbers": Awareness of far-right tattoos
Hallenberg, K. and Blackburn, B. 2022. "It's just some numbers": Awareness of far-right tattoos.
This is not a drill: police preparedness for climate emergency
Hallenberg, K., Lydon, D. and Kapageorgiadou, V. 2022. This is not a drill: police preparedness for climate emergency. Policing Insight.
This is not a drill: police preparedness for climate emergency: summary report of a scoping study
Hallenberg, K., Lydon, D. and Kapageorgiadou, V. 2022. This is not a drill: police preparedness for climate emergency: summary report of a scoping study. Canterbury Christ Church University.
Unpacking the Blue Box: structure, control and education in policing
Cockcroft, T. and Hallenberg, K. 2021. Unpacking the Blue Box: structure, control and education in policing. Policing and Society. 32 (9), pp. 1146-1165. https://doi.org/10.1080/10439463.2021.2016755
Authority, legitimacy and limits – who shapes police education? Reflections from England
Hallenberg, K. 2021. Authority, legitimacy and limits – who shapes police education? Reflections from England.
Still Here and Still Queer: LGBTQIA+ Staff Network in time of pandemic
Hallenberg, K., Digby-Bowl, C., Dainton, M. and Sanders, H. 2021. Still Here and Still Queer: LGBTQIA+ Staff Network in time of pandemic.
Crime, harm, and climate change nexus
Hallenberg, K. 2021. Crime, harm, and climate change nexus. in: Leal Filho, W., Azul, A.M., Brandli, L., Lange Salvia, A., Özuyar, P.G. and Wall, T. (ed.) Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions Cham Springer.
Police professionalisation: Some structural, cultural and pedagogic issues
Hallenberg, K. and Cockcroft, T. 2019. Police professionalisation: Some structural, cultural and pedagogic issues.
“That‘s that effing degree!“ – organisational responses to officers engaging in higher education
Hallenberg, K. and Cockcroft, T. 2017. “That‘s that effing degree!“ – organisational responses to officers engaging in higher education.
From indifference to hostility – organisational responses to graduate officers
Cockcroft, T. and Hallenberg, K. 2016. From indifference to hostility – organisational responses to graduate officers.
Education and the police professionalisation agenda: a perspective from England and Wales
Tong, S. and Hallenberg, K. 2017. Education and the police professionalisation agenda: a perspective from England and Wales. in: Rogers, C. and Frevel, B. (ed.) Higher Police Education: An international perspective Springer.
Beyond criminal justice: connecting justice and sustainability
Hallenberg, K. and Haddow, C. 2016. Beyond criminal justice: connecting justice and sustainability. The Law Teacher. 50 (3), pp. 352-370. https://doi.org/10.1080/03069400.2016.1262985
Theorising police professionalisation and academic education
Hallenberg, K. 2013. Theorising police professionalisation and academic education.
Beyond crime: justice and sustainability in the classroom and community
Hallenberg, K. and Haddow, C. 2015. Beyond crime: justice and sustainability in the classroom and community.
Criminology picks up the gauntlet: responses to the Whole Earth exhibition
Hallenberg, K. and Tennant, M. 2015. Criminology picks up the gauntlet: responses to the Whole Earth exhibition.
Criminology picks up the gauntlet: responses to the Whole Earth exhibition
Hallenberg, K. and Tennant, M. 2016. Criminology picks up the gauntlet: responses to the Whole Earth exhibition. in: Woodfield, K. (ed.) Inspire – Teaching and Learning in the Social Sciences HEA.
Opinion piece: on sustainability
Hallenberg, K. 2015. Opinion piece: on sustainability. in: Lea, J. (ed.) Enhancing Learning and Teaching in Higher Education: Engaging with the Dimensions of Practice McGraw Hill Education.
Leading sustainability in higher education
Hallenberg, K. 2016. Leading sustainability in higher education.
Watching the detectives: researching investigative practice
Hallenberg, K., O'Neill, M. and Tong, S. 2015. Watching the detectives: researching investigative practice. in: Brunger, M., Tong, S. and Martin, D. (ed.) Introduction to Policing Research: Taking Lessons From Practice London Routledge. pp. 101-117
Scholarly detectives: Police professionalisation via academic education
Hallenberg, K. 2012. Scholarly detectives: Police professionalisation via academic education. PhD Thesis The University of Manchester School of Law
Police and higher education
Hallenberg, K. and Cockcroft, T. 2014. Police and higher education. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.
Benefits and challenges of academic police education
Hallenberg, K. 2016. Benefits and challenges of academic police education. in: Phillips, S. (ed.) Change and Reform in Law Enforcement: Old and New Efforts from Across the Globe IPES. pp. 3-26