Reflections on a crisis: political disenchantment, moral desolation, and political integrity

Declining levels of political trust and voter turnout, the shift towards populist politics marked by appeals to ‘the people’ and a rejection of ‘politics-as-usual’, are just some of the commonly cited manifestations of our culture of political disaffection. Democratic politics, it is argued, is in crisis. Whilst considerable energy has been expended on the task of lamenting the status of our politics and pondering over recommendations to tackle this perceived crisis, amid this raft of complaints and solutions lurks confusion. This paper seeks to explore the neglected question of what the precise nature of the crisis with which we are confronted involves, and, in so doing, to go some way towards untangling our confusion. Taking my cue from Machiavelli and his value-pluralist heirs, I argue that there is a rift between a morally admirable and a virtuous political life. Failure to appreciate this possibility causes narrations of crisis to misconstrue the moral messiness of politics in ways that lead us to misunderstand how we should respond to disenchantment. Specifically, I suggest that: (i) we think that there is a moral crisis in politics because we have an unsatisfactorily idealistic understanding of political integrity in the first place; and (ii) it is a mistake to imagine that the moral purification of politics is possible or desirable. Put simply, our crisis is not moral per se but primarily philosophical in nature: it relates to the very concepts we employ—the qualities of character and context we presuppose whilst pondering over political integrity.

Allen, Nicholas, and Sarah Birch. 2011. Political conduct and misconduct: probing public opinion. Parliamentary Affairs 64: 61–81.

Allen, Nicholas, and Sarah Birch. 2012. On either side of a moat? Elite and mass attitudes towards right and wrong. European Journal of Political Research 51: 89–116.

Arnsperger, Christian, and Emmanuel Picavet. 2004. More than modus vivendi, less than overlapping consensus: Towards a political theory of social compromise. Social Science Information 43: 167 - 204.

Audit of political engagement. 2012. Hansard Society.
http://www.hansardsociety.org.uk/blogs/press_releases/archive/2012/0... 10 May 2016.

Bellamy, Richard. 2010. Dirty hands and clean gloves: Liberal ideals and real politics, European Journal of Political Theory 9: 412 – 430.

Bellamy, Richard. 2012. Democracy, compromise and the representation paradox: Coalition government and political integrity, Government and Opposition 47: 441 – 465

Bellamy, Richard, Markus Kornprobst, and Christine Reh. 2012. Introduction: Meeting in the middle. Government and Opposition 47: 275 – 295.

Berlin, Isaiah. 1969. Two concepts of liberty. In Four essays on liberty, ed. Henry Hardy, 118 – 172. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Berlin, Isaiah. 1980. The originality of Machiavelli. In Against the current: Essays in the history of ideas, ed. Henry Hardy, 20 – 73. New York: Viking.

Berlin, Isaiah. 1990. The Pursuit of the Ideal, in The Crooked Timber of Humanity: Chapters in the History of Ideas, ed. H. Hardy, 1 – 20. London: John Murray.

Berlin, Isaiah. 1999. Concepts and categories, ed. Henry Hardy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Brand, Russell. 2013. Brand on revolution: ‘we no longer have the luxury of tradition’. New Statesman, http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2013/10/russell-brand-on-revolu... Accessed 15 November 2016.

Boggs, Carl. 2000. The end of politics. London: Guilford Press.

Boudreaux, Donald. J., and Dwight R. Lee. 1997. Politics as the art of confined compromise. Cato Journal 16: 365 – 81.

Bunting, Madeleine. 2010. Introduction. In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf. Accessed 03 September 2016.

Bunting, Madeleine, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. 2010. Citizen ethics in a time of crisis. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf. Accessed 03 September 2016.

Bush, George H. W. 2011. Speaking of freedom: The collected speeches. New York. Scribner.

Butterfield, Roger. 1946. Mr Mencken sounds off. Life Magazine 21: 45–52.

Canovan, Margaret. 1981. Populism. London: Junction Books.

Canovan, Margaret. 1999. Trust the people! Populism and the two faces of democracy, Political Studies 47: 2-16.

Carens, Joseph. 1979. Compromises in politics, Nomos 21: 123- 141.

Colbert, Jack. 2015. Someone has to do it: towards a practical defence of politicians, Contemporary Politics 21: 468-484.

Crouch, Colin. 2004. Post-democracy. London: Polity Press.

Crozier, Michael., Samuel Huntington, and Joji Watanuki. 1975. The crisis of democracy: On the governability of democracies, New York, New York University Press.

Dalton, Russell. 2004. Democratic challenges, democratic choices: The erosion of political support in advanced industrialised democracies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Dionne, Eugene. 2009. Why Americans hate politics. New York: Touchstone.

Flinders, Matthew. 2009. Bridging the gap: Revitalising politics and the politics of public expectations, Representation 54: 337 – 347.

Flinders, Matthew. 2010. In defence of politics. The Political Quarterly 81: 319 – 328.

Flinders, Matthew. 2012a. Defending Politics: why democracy matters in the twenty first century. Oxford: Oxford University.

Flinders, Matthew. 2012b. The demonization of politicians: moral panics, folk devils and MPs’ expenses, Contemporary Politics 1: 1 -17.

Fumurescu, Alin. 2013. Compromise: A political and philosophical history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Gerhardt, Sue. 2010. A labour of kindness. In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf Accessed 10 November 2016.

Gerson, Michael. 2012. Obama’s betrayal. The Washington Post. http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2012-08-16/opinions/35491970_1_ob... Accessed 15 October 2015.

Glover, Julian. 2010. A conflict of values. In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf Accessed 10 November 2016.

Grant, Ruth, W. 1997. Hypocrisy and integrity: Machiavelli, Rousseau and the ethics of politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gray, John. 2000. Two faces of liberalism. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Gutmann, Amy, and Dennis Thompson. 2010. The mindsets of political compromise, Perspectives on Politics, 8: 1125 -1143.

Gutmann, Amy, and Dennis Thompson. 2011. Is there room for political compromise in an era of permanent campaigning? The Christian Science Monitor. http://www.csmonitor.com/Commentary/Opinion/2011/0104/Is-thereroom-f... Accessed 10 September 2015

Gutmann, Amy, and Dennis Thompson. 2012. The spirit of compromise: Why governing demands it and campaigning undermines it. Princeton: Princeton University press.

Hamlin, Alan, and Zofia Stemplowska. 2012. Theory, ideal theory and the theory of ideals. Political Studies Review 10: 48 – 62.
Hampshire, Stuart, 1978. Public and private morality. In Public and Private Morality, ed. Stuart Hampshire, 23 – 55. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hampshire, Stuart. 1983. Morality and conflict. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Hampshire, Stuart. 1989. Innocence and experience. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Hampshire, Stuart. 1993a. The last charmer. New York Review of Books 15 – 49.

Hampshire, Stuart. 1993b. Liberalism: The new twist, The New York Review of Books 43 – 47.

Hampshire, Stuart. 2000. Justice is conflict. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.

Hatier, Cecile. 2012. ‘Them’ and ‘us’: Demonising politicians by moral double standards, Contemporary Politics, 18: 467-480.

Hay, Colin. 2007. Why we hate politics. London: Polity Press.

Hay, Colin, and Gerry Stoker. 2009. Revitalising politics: Have we lost the plot? Representation 45: 225–236.

Heath, Antony, Roger Jowell, John Curtice, and Pippa Norris. 1999. British General Election Study, 1997. [data collection]. 2nd Edition. UK Data Service. SN: 3887, http://dx.doi.org/10.5255/UKDA-SN-3887-1. Accessed 10 November 2017

Hollis, Martin. 1982. Dirty hands. British Journal of Political Science 12: 385 – 398.

Horton, John 2010. Realism, liberal moralism and a political theory of modus vivendi, European Journal of Political Theory 9: 431- 448.

Horton, John. 2011. Why the traditional conception of toleration still matters, Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 14: 289 – 305.
Jack, Linda. 2012. Nick Clegg is in too deep. The Guardian.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/23/nick-clegg-libe... 10 August 2014

Jacoby, Russell. 2009. The end of utopia: Politics and culture in an age of apathy. New York: Basic Books

Kane, John., and Haig Patapan. 2012. The democratic leader. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Keane, John. 2009. The Life and Death of Democracy. London: Simon & Shuster.

Kis, Janos. 2008. Politics as a moral problem. Budapest: Central European University Press.

Kuhner, Jeffrey. 2012. Obama’s betrayal. The Washington Times.
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/dec/07/obamas-betrayal/ Accessed 10 October 2015.

Lent, Adam. 2010. Afterword. In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf Accessed 10 November 2016.

Lepora, Chiara. 2012. On compromise and being compromised, The Journal of Political Philosophy 20: 1 – 22.

Lloyd, John. 2004. What the media are doing to our politics. London: Constable.

Macedo, Stephen. 2004. Democracy at risk: How political choices undermine citizen participation and what we can do about It. Washington DC: Brookings.

Machiavelli, Niccolò. 1985. The discourses, ed. Bernard Crick and trans. Leslie J. Walker. London: Penguin.
Machiavelli, Niccolò. 1998. The prince, trans. Harvey C. Mansfield. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Machiavelli, Niccolò. 1996. Discourses on Livy, trans. Harvey C. Mansfield and Nathan Tarcov. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Maier, Charles. 1994. Democracy and its discontents, Foreign Affairs 73: 48 – 65.

Mansfield, Harvey. C. 1996. Machiavelli’s virtue. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.

May, Simon-Cabulae. 2005. Principled compromise and the abortion controversy, Philosophy & Public Affairs 33: 317 – 348.

Meier, Kenneth. 1997. Bureaucracy and democracy: The case for more bureaucracy and less democracy, Public Administration Review 57: 193-199.

Mudde, Cas. 2004. The Populist zeitgeist. Government and Opposition: An International Journal of Comparative Politics 39: 542-563.

Nathan, Richard. 1995. Re-inventing government: What does it mean? Public Administration Review 55: 213 -215.

Norris, Pippa. 1999. Critical citizens: global support for democratic government. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Norris, Pippa. 2011. Democratic deficit: Critical citizens revisited. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Oborne, Peter. 2005. The rise of political lying. UK: Simon & Schuster Ltd.

Osborne, David, and Ted Gaebler. 1993. Reinventing government: How the entrepreneurial spirit is transforming the public sector. New York: Penguin Books.

Osborne, David, and Peter Hutchinson.2004. The price of government: Getting the results we need in an era of Fiscal Crisis. New York: Basic Books.

Parijs, Philippe, van. 2012. What makes a good compromise? Government and Opposition 47: 466 - 480.

Philp, Mark. 2007. Political conduct. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Pinter, Harold. 2005. Art, truth and politics: The Nobel lecture. The Nobel Foundation,
https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2005/dec/08/theatre.nobelprize Accessed 05 September 2016.

Pullman, Philip 2010. Foreword. In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf Accessed 03 September 2016.

Quindlen, Anna. 1994. Public & private - Two class acts, New York Times,
http://www.nytimes.com/1994/11/12/opinion/public-private-two-class-a... Accessed 17 November 2016.

Ranciere, Jacques. 2006. Hatred of democracy, London: Verso.

Russell, Meg. 2005. Must politics disappoint? London: Fabian Society. http://www.fabians.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/MustPoliticsDis... Accessed 10 April 2016.

Sabl, Andrew. 2002. Ruling passions: Political offices and democratic ethics, Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Sandel, Michael. 2009. The Reith lectures: Markets and morals. http://www.bbc.co.uk.programmes/b00kt7sh. Accessed 10 November 2016.

Sandel, Michael. 2010. We need a public life with a purpose. In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf Accessed 03 September 2016.

Shklar, Judith Nisse. 1989. The Liberalism of fear. In Liberalism and the Moral Life, ed. Nancy Rosenblum, 21 – 38. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Sleat, Matt. 2013. Hope and disappointment in politics, Contemporary Politics 2: 131-145.

Stocker, Gerry. 2006a. Why politics matters: Making democracy work. London: Palgrave MacMillan.

Stocker, Gerry. 2006b. Explaining disenchantment: Finding pathways to democratic renewal. The Political Quarterly 77: 184 – 194.

Stocker, Gerry. 2006c. Politics in mass democracies: Destined to disappoint? Representation 42: 181-194.

Stocker, Gerry. 2015. Anti-Politics in Britain: Dimensions, causes and responses.
http://www.idi.org.il/media/1429259/bythepeople_stoker.pdf. Accessed 16 May 2016.

Stocker, Gerry, and Colin Hay. 2015. Understanding and challenging populist negativity towards politics: The perspectives of citizens. Political Studies. doi:10.1177/0032321715607511

Taggart, Paul. 2004. Populism and representative politics in contemporary Europe. Journal of Political Ideologies, 9 (3): 269 - 288.

Taylor, Charles. 1992. The Ethics of authenticity. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Tillyris, Demetris. 2015. Learning how not to be good: Machiavelli and the standard dirty hands thesis. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 18: 61 – 74.

Tillyris, Demetris. 2016a. Political integrity and dirty hands: Compromise and the ambiguities of betrayal. Res Publica. doi: 10.1007/s11158-016-9323-4

Tillyris, Demetris. 2016b. The virtue of vice: a defence of hypocrisy in democratic politics. Contemporary Politics 22: 1 – 20.

Tillyris, Demetris. 2016c. After the standard dirty hands thesis: Towards a dynamic account of dirty hands in politics, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 19: 161-175

Valentini, Laura. 2012. Ideal vs. non-ideal theory: A Conceptual map, Philosophy Compass 7: 654 – 664.
Vernon, Mark. 2010. Ethics with a little help from my friends. In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf Accessed 03 September 2016.

Walker, David, and Nicholas Jones. 2004. Invisible political actors: The Press as agents of anti-politics. London: New Politics Network.

Wilby, Peter. 2012. By his act of betrayal, Clegg will lose his greatest reward. The Guardian.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2010/dec/14/betrayal-clegg-... Accessed 10 August 2015.

Williams, Bernard. 1978. Politics and moral character. In Public and Private Morality, ed. Stuart Hampshire, 55 – 73. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Williams, Bernard. 2002. In the beginning was the deed: Realism and moralism in political argument. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Williams, Rowan. 2010a. Lecture for the Trinity Institute. The London Times. http:// www. timescolumns.typepad.com/files/rowan-williams-trinity-institute.doc‎ Accessed 03 September 2016

Williams, Rowan. 2010b. How to Live as if We Were Human In Citizen ethics in a time of crisis, ed. Madeleine Bunting, Mark Vernon, and Adam Lent. http://www.citizenethics.org.uk/docs/EthicsTemplateDoc.pdf Accessed 03 September 2016.

Williams, Rowan 2010c. Out of the abyss of individualism: We shouldn't leave politics to managers and economics to brokers – or be afraid to reintroduce 'virtue' to public discourse. The Guardian. http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2010/feb/21/individua... Accessed 03 September 2016

Zanetti, Véronique. 2011. Justice, peace and compromise, Analyse & Kritik 33: 423 – 439.