Integrating Relevance Theory and Critical Realism for the analysis of manipulation

Conference paper


Castaldi, J. 2024. Integrating Relevance Theory and Critical Realism for the analysis of manipulation.
AuthorsCastaldi, J.
TypeConference paper
Description

Despite the difficulty of ascertaining the manipulative intent of text producers, early pragmatic and discourse approaches (e.g. de Saussure, 2005) only focused on text producers to explore the mechanisms behind alleged manipulative texts. Recently, however, scholars have suggested a focus shift from the intention of the text producers to the effects on the text receivers (e.g. Maillat and Oswald, 2009; Oswald, 2014) and others have attempted to pursue this line of enquiry empirically (e.g. Castaldi, 2022). This paper follows this ‘addressee-oriented’ view of investigating manipulation and argues that aspects from Relevance Theory (Sperber and Wilson, 1995) can be drawn upon in order to explore manipulation and ideology formation.

The paper begins by proposing a more nuanced understanding of RT’s contextual effect and, by integrating a Critical Realist epistemology, argues that manipulation can occur at three different levels of representation and interpretation of ‘reality’: the real, the basic social reality and the constructed discursive reality. After introducing and explaining the ontology of these three levels of reality, these are mapped out against a more nuanced taxonomy of contextual effect, which is derived by differentiating between evidential effects and ideological effects. The former pertains to the domain of ‘knowledge’, while the latter to the domain of ‘opinions’.

In the second part, examples from an on-going project on the representation of Ukrainian Displaced People on UK television are used to exemplify the methodological framework proposed. Evidence is provided to show how “a set of constraints limiting the processes of contextual selection” (Maillat and Oswald, 2009, p. 361) can be applied at all the three levels of reality introduced in the first part of the paper and to show how these rely on cultural constructs that, from the perspective of a British audience, create proximity with the Ukrainian Displace People and distance with Russia.

KeywordsRelevance Theory; Critical Realism; Manipulation; Media discourse; Media effects
Year2024
Conference10th International Conference on Intercultural Pragmatics and Communication
Related URLhttps://inprapisa2024.com/
Publication process dates
Deposited07 Jun 2024
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/98104/integrating-relevance-theory-and-critical-realism-for-the-analysis-of-manipulation

  • 18
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 4
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Refining concepts for empirical multimodal research: defining semiotic modes and semiotic resources
Castaldi, J. 2024. Refining concepts for empirical multimodal research: defining semiotic modes and semiotic resources. Frontiers in Communication. 9, p. 1336325. https://doi.org/10.3389/fcomm.2024.1336325
Book review: Mari-Liis Madisson and Andreas Ventsel, <i>Strategic Conspiracy Narratives: A Semiotic Approach</i>
Castaldi, J. 2023. Book review: Mari-Liis Madisson and Andreas Ventsel, <i>Strategic Conspiracy Narratives: A Semiotic Approach</i>. Media, War & Conflict. 17 (1), pp. 139-141. https://doi.org/10.1177/17506352231212406
Technology and language learning: A multimodal perspective
Castaldi, J. 2024. Technology and language learning: A multimodal perspective.
What does the other look like? A critical multimodal analysis of the representation of otherness in British television programmes about Ukrainian Displaced People
Castaldi, J. 2024. What does the other look like? A critical multimodal analysis of the representation of otherness in British television programmes about Ukrainian Displaced People.
Review of Serafis (2023): Authoritarianism on the Front Page: Multimodal Discourse and Argumentation in Times of Multiple Crises in Greece
Castaldi, J. 2023. Review of Serafis (2023): Authoritarianism on the Front Page: Multimodal Discourse and Argumentation in Times of Multiple Crises in Greece. Journal of Language and Politics. 23 (1), pp. 138-141. https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.23122.cas
Discussing the Greek civil war in digital agoras. An interdisciplinary approach to multimodal historical documentation.
Castaldi, J. and Foundouka, I. C. 2023. Discussing the Greek civil war in digital agoras. An interdisciplinary approach to multimodal historical documentation.
YouTube digital spaces: a form of contemporary global agora? A case study of the documentary Greece: the hidden war
Castaldi, J. 2023. YouTube digital spaces: a form of contemporary global agora? A case study of the documentary Greece: the hidden war.
Multisensory processing, affect and multimodal manipulation: A cognitive-semiotic empirical study of travel documentaries
Castaldi, J. 2023. Multisensory processing, affect and multimodal manipulation: A cognitive-semiotic empirical study of travel documentaries.
Cognition, relevance and ideology formation through travel documentaries: A longitudinal approach to audiences
Castaldi, J. 2023. Cognition, relevance and ideology formation through travel documentaries: A longitudinal approach to audiences.
Epistemic vigilance in travel documentaries: investigating top-down and bottom-up processes in multimodal manipulation
Castaldi, J. 2023. Epistemic vigilance in travel documentaries: investigating top-down and bottom-up processes in multimodal manipulation.
Beyond language: multimodal literacy and ELT. Opportunities and challenges
Castaldi, J. 2023. Beyond language: multimodal literacy and ELT. Opportunities and challenges.
Ideology and manipulation in travel documentaries: a cognitive-semiotic approach
Castaldi, J. 2022. Ideology and manipulation in travel documentaries: a cognitive-semiotic approach.
Cognition and ideological effects in the interaction between viewers and BBC travel documentaries: combining multimodal critical discourse analysis and audience research
Castaldi, J. 2022. Cognition and ideological effects in the interaction between viewers and BBC travel documentaries: combining multimodal critical discourse analysis and audience research.
Keeping the myth of the British Empire alive: combining a multi-semiotic analysis of two BBC travel documentaries with audience research
Castaldi, J. 2022. Keeping the myth of the British Empire alive: combining a multi-semiotic analysis of two BBC travel documentaries with audience research.
Political semiotics in non-political genres: investigating multimodal manipulation
Castaldi, J. 2022. Political semiotics in non-political genres: investigating multimodal manipulation.
Multimodal manipulation in travel documentaries: bypassing epistemic vigilance
Castaldi, J. 2021. Multimodal manipulation in travel documentaries: bypassing epistemic vigilance.
The British Empire in BBC travel documentaries: investigating multimodal manipulation
Castaldi, J. 2021. The British Empire in BBC travel documentaries: investigating multimodal manipulation.
Cognition and ideological effects in the interaction between viewers and BBC travel and cultural documentaries: combining multimodal critical discourse analysis and audience research
Castaldi, J. 2021. Cognition and ideological effects in the interaction between viewers and BBC travel and cultural documentaries: combining multimodal critical discourse analysis and audience research . PhD Thesis Canterbury Christ Church University Centre for Language and Linguistics
A multimodal analysis of the representation of the Rohingya crisis in BBC’s Burma with Simon Reeve (2018): Integrating Audience Research in Multimodal Critical Discourse Studies
Castaldi, Jacopo 2020. A multimodal analysis of the representation of the Rohingya crisis in BBC’s Burma with Simon Reeve (2018): Integrating Audience Research in Multimodal Critical Discourse Studies. Multimodal Communication. 10 (1), pp. 55-72. https://doi.org/10.1515/mc-2020-0014