Paradox and the incarnation: Why it isn’t simply a matter of logical contradiction
Conference paper
Lawson, F. 2023. Paradox and the incarnation: Why it isn’t simply a matter of logical contradiction.
Authors | Lawson, F. |
---|---|
Type | Conference paper |
Description | ‘To say that Christ is a single hypostasis who joins together two wholly distinct and unequal natures […] is to say that he is a living paradox’ (Daley, 2004, pp. 194–5). In contrast to Daley, many have argued the paradoxicality of the incarnation refers simply to “verbal puzzles” (Basinger, 1987, p. 205). Such accounts of paradox as contradiction, focus on logical contradiction and the epistemic limitations of humans to be able to hold the concepts in a coherent epistemic or theological framework (Goulder, 1979; See Hepburn, 1960). A similar approach can be seen in C. Stephen Evans’ account of our “problematic” conceptual equipment at the root of paradox. In this paper I argue that the resolution of paradox does not require the removal of divine mystery. One does not have to understand the mechanism (of the incarnation) to challenge the claim of paradox. Likewise, one does not need to have a full definition of “human” and/or “divine” to reconcile the apparently contradictory properties of the incarnation. The claim of paradox rests in assumptions regarding a dichotomous or binary understanding of the nature of the world. These assumptions stem from metaphysical assumptions about the nature of substance(s) and reality and are brough sharply in to question by a holistic (or non-binary) metaphysics. After examining the challenge of defining paradox in theological terms, I highlight how, just as paradox and mystery have often become conflated in our theological discussion, so too have the Aristotelian concepts of non-contradiction and the excluded middle. Having created greater clarity around the issues I then provide some initial responses to “paradox” in our incarnational understanding. This is by no means an exhaustive study, but instead, I propose, aims to open the dialogue to a broader conversation about the impact of assumed dualisms on our understanding of the nature of Christ (and the world). |
Keywords | Paradox; Incarnation; Non-contradiction; Holism |
Year | 2023 |
Conference | Tyndale Conference |
File | License File Access Level Open |
Web address (URL) of conference proceedings | https://www.tyndalefellowship.org/_files/ugd/8f9f88_21bc9175b4684ab5853343feda093860.pdf |
Publication process dates | |
Deposited | 10 Jul 2023 |
https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/95056/paradox-and-the-incarnation-why-it-isn-t-simply-a-matter-of-logical-contradiction
Download files
81
total views23
total downloads3
views this month0
downloads this month
Export as
Related outputs
Widening participation and success in STEM: embedding research-engaged practice to measure impact
Lawson, Finley, Colley, Stefan, Anthony, Anna, Billingsley, Berry and Harvey, Dana 2024. Widening participation and success in STEM: embedding research-engaged practice to measure impact. Widening Participation and Lifelong Learning. 26 (2), pp. 248-261. https://doi.org/10.5456/wpll.26.2.248Research co-creation and the development of epistemically insightful curricula
Lawson, F. I, Dhaliwal, M., Lawson, M. and Coates, H. 2024. Research co-creation and the development of epistemically insightful curricula. in: Billingsley, B., Chappell, K. and Simpson, S. (ed.) The Future of Knowledge: The Role of Epistemic Insight in Interdisciplinary Learning England Bloomsbury Academic.Approaching STEAM via inquiry-based responses to big questions: how “epistemic insight” changes informal science learning
Lawson, F., Colley, S. and Billingsley, B. 2024. Approaching STEAM via inquiry-based responses to big questions: how “epistemic insight” changes informal science learning. in: Thomson, M. M. (ed.) Motivation and Engagement in Various Learning Environments: Interdisciplinary Perspectives Charlotte, NC Information Age Publishing.
Collaborating to improve teaching and learning about sustainability within an international learning community
Gordon, A., Simpson, S., Lawson, F. and Thomas, C. 2023. Collaborating to improve teaching and learning about sustainability within an international learning community.The Science and Religion Forum discuss information and reality: Questions for religions and science
Lawson, F. 2023. The Science and Religion Forum discuss information and reality: Questions for religions and science. Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science. https://doi.org/10.1111/zygo.12882Co-creation of learning resources that cross disciplinary boundaries within an international learning community
Gordon, A., Thomas, C., Simpson, S. and Lawson, F. 2023. Co-creation of learning resources that cross disciplinary boundaries within an international learning community.Creating epistemically insightful learning experiences in primary classrooms: insights into the nature of science
Gordon, A., Simpson, S. and Lawson, F. 2022. Creating epistemically insightful learning experiences in primary classrooms: insights into the nature of science.Science, religion and sustainability in schools: outlining a teacher learning community approach.
Gordon, A.J., Lawson, F., Simpson, S. and Thomas, C. 2022. Science, religion and sustainability in schools: outlining a teacher learning community approach.The epistemic insight digest: Issue : Autumn 2022
Gordon, A., Shalet, D., Simpson, S., Hassanin, H., Lawson, F., Lawson, M., Litchfield, A., Thomas, C., Canetta, E., Manley, K. and Choong, C. Shalet, D. (ed.) 2022. The epistemic insight digest: Issue : Autumn 2022. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.
Epistemic insight: Teaching students about the nature of knowledge, science, religion and beyond
Lawson, F. and Billingsley, B. 2022. Epistemic insight: Teaching students about the nature of knowledge, science, religion and beyond.Insightful teaching – what role is there for research co-creation as professional development?
Lawson, F. and Lawson, M. 2022. Insightful teaching – what role is there for research co-creation as professional development?Re-imaging STEAM outreach: The role of interdisciplinarity in (re)engaging underrepresented students
Lawson, F. and Colley, S. 2022. Re-imaging STEAM outreach: The role of interdisciplinarity in (re)engaging underrepresented students.Inspiring minds research-engaged STEAM outreach: How we can and should change our practice
Lawson, F. and Colley, S. 2022. Inspiring minds research-engaged STEAM outreach: How we can and should change our practice.
A case study of how research co-creation is supporting the development of ‘Epistemically `Insightful’ curriculum transformation in English secondary schools
Lawson, F. and Lawson, M. 2022. A case study of how research co-creation is supporting the development of ‘Epistemically `Insightful’ curriculum transformation in English secondary schools.
Inspiring minds research-engaged STEAM outreach: Affecting attitudinal and attainment change through interdisciplinary outreach
Lawson, F. and Colley, S. 2022. Inspiring minds research-engaged STEAM outreach: Affecting attitudinal and attainment change through interdisciplinary outreach.