Quest for Love: A cosy uchronia?

Book chapter

Butler, A. 2019. Quest for Love: A cosy uchronia? in: Morgan, G. and Palmer-Patel, C. (ed.) Sideways in Time: Critical Essays on Alternate History Fiction Liverpool Liverpool University Press. pp. 163-177
AuthorsButler, A.
EditorsMorgan, G. and Palmer-Patel, C.
Abstract

The catastrophe science fiction of John Wyndham was once dismissed as being cosy. “Random Quest”, one of several works that David Ketterer labelled “time schism love stories”, is an alternate history. But is this story (and its British film adaption, Quest For Love (1971)) also cosy? Just as his catastrophic narratives invoke the blind forces of evolution that resist anthropocentric visions of the world, so here the blind forces of physics and chance resist the inevitability of true love. A potential intertext, Johann Wolfgang von Goethe’s novel Die Wahlverwandtschaften (Elective Affinities, 1809), features a heroine Ottiline who shares her name with the heroine of “Random Quest” and offers a pseudoscientific model for predestined love that bears fruit in the film’s assumption of a cosy ending.

KeywordsScience fiction; Film; Film adaptations; John Wyndham
Page range163-177
Year2019
Book titleSideways in Time: Critical Essays on Alternate History Fiction
PublisherLiverpool University Press
Output statusPublished
Place of publicationLiverpool
ISBN9781789620139
9781789624328
9781802076950
Publication dates
Print25 Sep 2019
Publication process dates
AcceptedMar 2018
Deposited01 Nov 2023
Official URLhttps://academic.oup.com/liverpool-scholarship-online/book/33826/chapter-abstract/288621832?redirectedFrom=fulltext
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/91z52/quest-for-love-a-cosy-uchronia

  • 27
    total views
  • 1
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

“Why don’t you go home?”: The folk horror revival in contemporary Cornish gothic films
Butler, Andrew M 2023. “Why don’t you go home?”: The folk horror revival in contemporary Cornish gothic films. in: Johnson, W. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Folk Horror London Routledge.
Post-imperial melancholy in English utopias of the long seventies
Butler, A. 2022. Post-imperial melancholy in English utopias of the long seventies. in: The Cambridge Companion to British Utopian Literature and Culture, 1945-2020 Cambridge University Press.
Science fiction at a crossroads?
Butler, A. 2022. Science fiction at a crossroads? Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction. 51 (142), pp. 5-12.
“A New Rose Hotel is a New Rose Hotel is a New Rose Hotel”: Non-places in William Gibson’s screen adaptations
Butler, A. 2021. “A New Rose Hotel is a New Rose Hotel is a New Rose Hotel”: Non-places in William Gibson’s screen adaptations. in: Murray, M. R. and Milges, M. (ed.) William Gibson and the Future of Contemporary Culture Iowa City University of Iowa Press. pp. 97-109
Fabulation and salvation [in Reviews of books]
Butler, A. 2018. Fabulation and salvation [in Reviews of books]. Extrapolation. 59 (2), pp. 186-189. https://doi.org/10.3828/extr.2018.12
Early cyberpunk film (1980-1999)
Butler, A. 2019. Early cyberpunk film (1980-1999). in: McFarlane, A., Schmeink, L. and Murphy, G. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture London Routledge.
New Wave At-itudes
Butler, A. 2015. New Wave At-itudes. Science Fiction Studies. 42 (1), pp. 166-170. https://doi.org/10.5621/sciefictstud.42.1.0166
Cogging-ative estrangement
Butler, A. 2017. Cogging-ative estrangement. Science Fiction Studies. 44 (3), pp. 599-601. https://doi.org/10.5621/sciefictstud.44.3.0599
Terry Pratchett appreciation
Butler, A. 2015. Terry Pratchett appreciation. Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction. 120.
The Arthur C. Clarke award: thirty years on
Butler, A. 2016. The Arthur C. Clarke award: thirty years on. Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction.
Futurology
Butler, A. 2014. Futurology. in: Latham, R. (ed.) The Oxford Handbook of Science Fiction Oxford Oxford University Press.
Abjection and the constructions of race and racism in district 9
Butler, A. 2015. Abjection and the constructions of race and racism in district 9. in: Küchler, U., Maehl, S. and Stout, G. (ed.) Alien Imaginations: Science Fiction and Tales of Transnationalism New York Bloomsbury. pp. 95-112
British science fiction
Butler, A. 2016. British science fiction. in: Einaus, A. (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to the English Short Story Cambridge Cambridge University Press.
Strange boys, queer boys: gay representations in young adult fantastic fiction
Butler, A. 2016. Strange boys, queer boys: gay representations in young adult fantastic fiction. in: Roberts, J. and MacCallum-Stewart, E. (ed.) Gender and Sexuality in Contemporary Popular Fantasy: Beyond Boy Wizards and ‘Kick-Ass’ Chicks London Routledge.
Splinter swiftly: the hermeneuting parallax of Adam Roberts’s generic auteurship
Butler, A. 2016. Splinter swiftly: the hermeneuting parallax of Adam Roberts’s generic auteurship. in: Callow, jr, C. and McFarlane, A. (ed.) Adam Roberts Critical Essays Canterbury Gylphi.
Riding the new wave
Butler, A. 2018. Riding the new wave. in: Canavan, G. and Link, E. (ed.) The Cambridge History of Science Fiction Cambridge Cambridge University Press.
Invoking the holy trilogy: star wars in the Askewniverse
Butler, A. 2018. Invoking the holy trilogy: star wars in the Askewniverse. in: Hassler-Forest, D. and Guynes, S. (ed.) Star Wars and the History of Transmedia Storytelling Amsterdam Amsterdam University Press. pp. 177-198
[Review of] Peter Dickens and James S. Ormrod, eds. the Palgrave handbook of society, culture and outer space. Houndmills, Basingstoke and London, 2016. 480 pp. Cloth, £135, ISBN 978-1-137-36351-0.
Butler, A. 2017. [Review of] Peter Dickens and James S. Ormrod, eds. the Palgrave handbook of society, culture and outer space. Houndmills, Basingstoke and London, 2016. 480 pp. Cloth, £135, ISBN 978-1-137-36351-0. Utopian Studies. 28 (2), pp. 348-353. https://doi.org/10.5325/utopianstudies.28.2.0348
Walking in the Canterbury night-time economy: drinking destination or destination drinking?
Butler, A. and McPherson, R. 2016. Walking in the Canterbury night-time economy: drinking destination or destination drinking?
The estranged case of Ivan Istochnikov: the uncanny indexicality of SF photographs
Butler, A. 2015. The estranged case of Ivan Istochnikov: the uncanny indexicality of SF photographs.
Disfigured myth: the destruction of London in postmillennial SF film
Butler, A. 2015. Disfigured myth: the destruction of London in postmillennial SF film. Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction. 44 (122), pp. 20-32.
Sleeping/waking: politicizing the sublime in science fiction film special effects
Butler, A. 2015. Sleeping/waking: politicizing the sublime in science fiction film special effects. in: Redmond, S. and Marvell, L. (ed.) Endangering Science Fiction Film New York and London Routledge. pp. 117-131
Quest for Love: a cosy uchronia?
Butler, A. 2015. Quest for Love: a cosy uchronia?
Beyond New Worlds: John Carnell’s new writings
Butler, A. 2014. Beyond New Worlds: John Carnell’s new writings.
Bearly conscious? Deconstructing Pullman’s postmodern marionettes
Butler, A. 2014. Bearly conscious? Deconstructing Pullman’s postmodern marionettes. in: Butler, C. and Halsdorf, T. (ed.) Philip Pullman London Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 96-112
The Tain and the Tain: China Miéville’s gift of uncanny London
Butler, A. 2013. The Tain and the Tain: China Miéville’s gift of uncanny London. CR: The New Centennial Review. 13 (2).
Taming death: the construction of human/alien nature in Avatar
Butler, A. 2013. Taming death: the construction of human/alien nature in Avatar.
Moon: toward the cognitive uncanny
Butler, A. 2012. Moon: toward the cognitive uncanny.
Worlds apart? Hollywood, Philip K. Dick and other war crimes
Butler, A. 2013. Worlds apart? Hollywood, Philip K. Dick and other war crimes.
Splinter swiftly: the hermeneuting parallax of Adam Roberts’s generic auteurship
Butler, A. 2013. Splinter swiftly: the hermeneuting parallax of Adam Roberts’s generic auteurship.
He do the polis in different voices: Mieville’s uncanny cities in The City and The City
Butler, A. 2012. He do the polis in different voices: Mieville’s uncanny cities in The City and The City.
Psychoanalysis and fantasy
Butler, A. 2012. Psychoanalysis and fantasy. in: James, E. and Mendlesohn, F. (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Modern Fantasy Literature Cambridge Cambridge University Press.
Solar flares: science fiction in the 1970s
Butler, A. 2012. Solar flares: science fiction in the 1970s. Liverpool Liverpool University Press.
Unimportant failures? The fall and rise of The Man Who Fell to Earth
Butler, A. 2013. Unimportant failures? The fall and rise of The Man Who Fell to Earth. in: Van Parys, T. and Hunter, I. (ed.) Science Fiction across Media: Adaptation/Novelization Canterbury Gylphi. pp. 81-96
Journeys beyond being: the cyberpunk-flavoured novels of Jeff Noon
Butler, A. 2000. Journeys beyond being: the cyberpunk-flavoured novels of Jeff Noon. in: Gatt-Rutter, J. (ed.) Novel Turns Towards 2000: Critical Perspectives on Contemporary Narrative Writing from Western Europe Melbourne Vox Hispanica.
Proto-SF/proto-queer: the strange cases of Dr Frankenstein and Mr Hyde
Butler, A. 2002. Proto-SF/proto-queer: the strange cases of Dr Frankenstein and Mr Hyde. Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction. 86, pp. 7-16.
Philip K. Dick
Butler, A. 2009. Philip K. Dick. in: Bould, M., Butler, A., Roberts, A. and Vint, S. (ed.) Fifty Key Figures in Science Fiction Oxford Routledge. pp. 66-71
Jean Baudrillard
Butler, A. 2009. Jean Baudrillard. in: Bould, M., Butler, A., Roberts, A. and Vint, S. (ed.) Fifty Key Figures in Science Fiction Oxford, UK Routledge. pp. 17-22
Psychoanalysis
Butler, A. 2009. Psychoanalysis. in: Butler, A., Bould, M., Roberts, A. and Vint, S. (ed.) The Routledge Companion to Science Fiction Oxford, UK Routledge. pp. 288-297
Unimportant failures: The fall and rise of the man who fell to Earth
Butler, A. 2009. Unimportant failures: The fall and rise of the man who fell to Earth.
Machines extraordinaires: Going beyond the Gernsback-Campbell Continuum in Seventies Science Fiction
Butler, A. 2009. Machines extraordinaires: Going beyond the Gernsback-Campbell Continuum in Seventies Science Fiction.
Saying the words you can't say on television on television: Dysphemism and the poetics of ''bad'' language
Butler, A. 2009. Saying the words you can't say on television on television: Dysphemism and the poetics of ''bad'' language.
Peeling, crashing, crying and electric love: The discovery of male homosexuality in 1970s science fiction
Butler, A. 2009. Peeling, crashing, crying and electric love: The discovery of male homosexuality in 1970s science fiction.
Loving that which you can lose: Solaris, the Seventies and the Science Fiction Art Film
Butler, A. 2009. Loving that which you can lose: Solaris, the Seventies and the Science Fiction Art Film.
A celebration of British science fiction
Sawyer, A., Butler, A. and Mendlesohn, F. 2005. A celebration of British science fiction. Guildford Science Fiction Foundation.
An unofficial companion to the novels of Terry Pratchett
Butler, A. 2008. An unofficial companion to the novels of Terry Pratchett. Santa Barbara, USA Praeger.
Terry Pratchett
Butler, A. 2007. Terry Pratchett. Harpenden, UK Pocket Essentials.
Philip K. Dick
Butler, A. 2007. Philip K. Dick. Harpenden, UK Pocket Essentials.
'My particular virus': (re)reading Jack Womack’s Dryco Chronicles
Butler, A. 2000. 'My particular virus': (re)reading Jack Womack’s Dryco Chronicles. in: Sawyer, A. and Seed, D. (ed.) Speaking Science Fiction: Dialogues and Interpretations Liverpool Liverpool University Press. pp. 188-200
The good life? The cosiness of survivors
Butler, A. 2010. The good life? The cosiness of survivors.
Beyond the Gernsback/Campbell continuum: rereading and rewriting Wells for the 1970s
Butler, A. 2010. Beyond the Gernsback/Campbell continuum: rereading and rewriting Wells for the 1970s.
Journeys beyond being: the cyberpunk-flavored novels of Jeff Noon
Butler, A. 2010. Journeys beyond being: the cyberpunk-flavored novels of Jeff Noon. in: Murphy, G. and Vint, S. (ed.) Beyond Cyberpunk: New Critical Perspectives Abingdon, UK Routledge. pp. 65-78
Iain M. Banks
Butler, A. 2009. Iain M. Banks. in: Bould, M., Butler, A., Roberts, A. and Vint, S. (ed.) Fifty Key Figures in Science Fiction Oxford, UK Routledge. pp. 12-17
Towards a language for science fiction studies: narratives
Butler, A. 2000. Towards a language for science fiction studies: narratives. M/C: A Journal of Media and Culture. 2 (9).
Going Uphill: An interview with Gwyneth Jones
Butler, A. 2004. Going Uphill: An interview with Gwyneth Jones. FemSpec.
Science fiction as postmodernism: the case of Philip K. Dick
Butler, A. 1996. Science fiction as postmodernism: the case of Philip K. Dick. in: Littlewood, D. and Stockwell, P. (ed.) Impossibility Fiction: Alternativity, Extrapolation, Speculation Amsterdam Rodopi.
Science fiction writing
Butler, A. 1999. Science fiction writing. in: Cook, C. (ed.) Pears Cyclopaedia 1998-1999 London Penguin.
Philip Pullman
Butler, A. 2003. Philip Pullman. in: Bleiler, R. (ed.) Supernatural Fiction Writers Charles Scribner's Sons.
Life, liberty and the pursuit of the post-human: An interview with Ken MacLeod
Butler, A. 2003. Life, liberty and the pursuit of the post-human: An interview with Ken MacLeod. in: Butler, A. and Mendlesohn, F. (ed.) The True Knowledge of Ken MacLeod Reading The Science Fiction Foundation.
Theories of humour
Butler, A. 2004. Theories of humour. in: Butler, A., James, E. and Mendlesohn, F. (ed.) Terry Pratchett: Guilty of Literature Baltimore, USA Old Earth Books. pp. 67-88
Work and masculine identity in Kevin Smith's New Jersey Trilogy
Butler, A. 2001. Work and masculine identity in Kevin Smith's New Jersey Trilogy. M/C: A Journal of Media and Culture. 4 (5).
Postmodernism and science fiction
Butler, A. 2003. Postmodernism and science fiction. in: James, E. and Mendlesohn, F. (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Science Fiction Cambridge Cambridge University Press. pp. 137-148
Total Recall (1990)
Butler, A. 2005. Total Recall (1990). in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 1307-1309
Sexuality
Butler, A. 2005. Sexuality. in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 711-713
Metropolis (1926)
Butler, A. 2005. Metropolis (1926). in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 1172-1174
The Man in the High Castle by Philip K. Dick (1962)
Butler, A. 2005. The Man in the High Castle by Philip K. Dick (1962). in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 1152-1154
Galapagos by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. (1985)
Butler, A. 2005. Galapagos by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. (1985). in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 1056-1058
E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial (1982)
Butler, A. 2005. E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial (1982). in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 1023-1025
The Drowned World by J.G. Ballard
Butler, A. 2005. The Drowned World by J.G. Ballard. in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 1014-1016
The Difference Engine by William Gibson and Bruce Sterling (1990)
Butler, A. 2005. The Difference Engine by William Gibson and Bruce Sterling (1990). in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 993-994
Comedy
Butler, A. 2005. Comedy. in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 144-146
Blade Runner
Butler, A. 2005. Blade Runner. in: Westfahl, G. (ed.) The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Science Fiction and Fantasy Themes, Works and Wonders Santa Barbara, USA Greenwood Press. pp. 934-936
William Gibson: Neuromancer
Butler, A. 2005. William Gibson: Neuromancer. in: Seed, D. (ed.) A Companion to Science Fiction Oxford, UK Blackwell. pp. 534-543
''The rumour is we're slaves'' Michael Coney's early novels
Butler, A. 2005. ''The rumour is we're slaves'' Michael Coney's early novels. in: Weiss, A. (ed.) Further Perspectives on the Canadian Fantastic: Proceedings of the 2003 Academic Conference on Canadian Science Fiction and Fantasy Canada ACCSFF. pp. 85-96
The Republic of Heaven: The betrayal of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy
Butler, A. 2005. The Republic of Heaven: The betrayal of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy. in: Moody, N. and Horrocks, C. (ed.) Children's Fantasy Fiction: Debates for the Twenty First Century Liverpool, UK Media Critical and Creative Arts, Liverpool John Moores University and Association for Research in Popular Fictions. pp. 285-298
Philip K. Dick, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
Butler, A. 2005. Philip K. Dick, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? in: Johnson, D. (ed.) The Popular and the Canonical: Debating Twentieth-Century Literature 1940-2000 Abingdon, UK Routledge. pp. 108-152
Beyond Competing for Beer Money: The Criticism of Christopher Priest
Butler, A. 2005. Beyond Competing for Beer Money: The Criticism of Christopher Priest. in: Butler, A. (ed.) Christopher Priest: The Interaction UK Science Fiction Foundation. pp. 129-145
“We Has Found the Enemy and They Is Us”: Virtual war and empathy in four children’s science fiction novels
Butler, A. 2004. “We Has Found the Enemy and They Is Us”: Virtual war and empathy in four children’s science fiction novels. The Lion and the Unicorn. 28 (2), pp. 171-185.
Thirteen ways of looking at the British boom
Butler, A. 2003. Thirteen ways of looking at the British boom. Science Fiction Studies. 30 (3), pp. 374-393.
Non-linear narrative(s) in Philip Pullman's Penny Dreadfuls
Butler, A. 2003. Non-linear narrative(s) in Philip Pullman's Penny Dreadfuls. Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction. 88, pp. 75-87.
Purloining of an agenda, or, a spectre is haunting John Clute
Butler, A. 2006. Purloining of an agenda, or, a spectre is haunting John Clute. in: Mendlesohn, F. (ed.) Polder: A Festschrift for John Clute and Judith Clute Baltimore, USA Old Earth Books. pp. 163-174
The Sparrow: music, food, sex
Butler, A. 2006. The Sparrow: music, food, sex. in: Kincaid, P. and Butler, A. (ed.) The Arthur C. Clarke Award: a critical anthology Serendip Foundation. pp. 141-151
Roundtable on science fiction criticism
Butler, A. 2006. Roundtable on science fiction criticism. Science Fiction Studies. 33 (3).
Thanks for the memories: The films of Philip K. Dick
Butler, A. 2005. Thanks for the memories: The films of Philip K. Dick. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 244, pp. 7-10.
The View from Retirement
Butler, A. 2005. The View from Retirement. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 244, pp. 3-4.
The View from the Armadillo
Butler, A. 2005. The View from the Armadillo. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 243, pp. 3-3.
The View from the Stool and Steps
Butler, A. 2005. The View from the Stool and Steps. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 242, pp. 3-3.
Robert Sheckley's Comic Labyrinths
Butler, A. 2005. Robert Sheckley's Comic Labyrinths. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 242, pp. 13-16.
The View from Behind the Sofa
Butler, A. 2005. The View from Behind the Sofa. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 241, pp. 3-3.
The View from Alderney - Kenneth Vye Bailey (1914-2005)
Butler, A. 2005. The View from Alderney - Kenneth Vye Bailey (1914-2005). Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 240, pp. 3-3.
Reading 'Red': portrait of a fairy tale
Butler, A. 2005. Reading 'Red': portrait of a fairy tale. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 239, pp. 12-17.
The View from the Erasmus Building
Butler, A. 2005. The View from the Erasmus Building. Vector: The Critical Journal of the British Science Fiction Association. 239, pp. 3-3.
LSD, Lying Ink and Lies, Inc
Butler, A. 2005. LSD, Lying Ink and Lies, Inc. Science Fiction Studies. 32 (2), pp. 265-280.
Discontinuity and D.G. Compton's The Continuous Katherine Mortenhoe
Butler, A. 2005. Discontinuity and D.G. Compton's The Continuous Katherine Mortenhoe. Foundation: The International Review of Science Fiction. 93, pp. 67-75.
Between the ''Deaths'' of science fiction: a skeptical view of anti-genres
Butler, A. 2005. Between the ''Deaths'' of science fiction: a skeptical view of anti-genres. Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts. 15 (3), pp. 208-216.
Medusa laughs: birds, thieves and other unruly women
Butler, A. 2009. Medusa laughs: birds, thieves and other unruly women. in: Mendlesohn, F. (ed.) On Joanna Russ Connecticut, USA Wesleyan University Press. pp. 143-156
"The man who fell to earth": the messiah and the amphicatastrophe
Butler, A. 2011. "The man who fell to earth": the messiah and the amphicatastrophe. in: Berman, M. and Dalvi, R. (ed.) Heroes, Monsters and Values: Science Fiction Films of the 1970s Newcastle Cambridge Scholars Publishing. pp. 179-196