The Jack-Roller and the life history method: notes on the Chicago School’s Clifford Shaw and Howard Becker’s humanistic narrative of young male and female delinquents in different ages

Journal article

Blackman, Shane 2021. The Jack-Roller and the life history method: notes on the Chicago School’s Clifford Shaw and Howard Becker’s humanistic narrative of young male and female delinquents in different ages. YOUNG. 30 (3), pp. 213 - 229. https://doi.org/10.1177/11033088211046168

Publication dates
Authors	Blackman, Shane
Abstract	Clifford Shaw’s (1930) The Jack-Roller is a landmark study of naturalism, ethnography and crime. It is the ‘own story’ of Stanley—a young delinquent in Chicago. Shaw’s series of ethnographic studies on delinquency sought to humanize deviance in opposition to pathological understandings of delinquency. The article looks on the representation of crimes committed and punishment received by young male and female delinquents. Shaw’s argument focuses on structural inequalities and poverty as the cause of deviance; as a result, female delinquency was not explained by sexual promiscuity, although he failed to recognize young women’s vulnerabilities. The second edition of The Jack-Roller introduced by Howard Becker (1966, Introduction. The Jack-Roller: A delinquent boy’s own story, pp. v–xviii) redefined Shaw’s study within the symbolic interactionist tradition. From the 1950s, Shaw and Becker disagreed over the writing of the deviant’s ‘own story,’ the control of the narrative and the authorial voice. The article adds to the literature on narrative, female deviance and youth delinquency.
Keywords	Deviance; Ethnography; Chicago School; Female delinquency; Crime
Year	2021
Journal	YOUNG
Journal citation	30 (3), pp. 213 - 229
Publisher	SAGE
ISSN	1103-3088
	1741-3222
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)	https://doi.org/10.1177/11033088211046168
Official URL	https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/11033088211046168
Online	09 Oct 2021
Publication process dates
Deposited	26 Apr 2023
Publisher's version	11033088211046168.pdf License CC BY 4.0 File Access Level Open
Output status	Published

Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/8z539/the-jack-roller-and-the-life-history-method-notes-on-the-chicago-school-s-clifford-shaw-and-howard-becker-s-humanistic-narrative-of-young-male-and-female-delinquents-in-different-ages

Download files

Publisher's version

	11033088211046168.pdf
License: CC BY 4.0
File access level: Open

77
total views
105
total downloads
2
views this month
10
downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Introduction to special issue: youth, rural places and marginalisation

Østergaard, Jeanette, Pless, Mette, Blackman, Shane and MacDonald, Robert 2024. Introduction to special issue: youth, rural places and marginalisation. Journal of Youth Studies. 27 (9), pp. 1227-1239. https://doi.org/10.1080/13676261.2024.2404919

Black ethnographic activists: Exploring Robert Park, scientific racism, The Chicago School, and FBI files through the Black sociological experience of Charles S. Johnson and E. Franklin Frazier

Blackman, S. 2023. Black ethnographic activists: Exploring Robert Park, scientific racism, The Chicago School, and FBI files through the Black sociological experience of Charles S. Johnson and E. Franklin Frazier. Symbolic Interaction. 46 (3), pp. 287-310. https://doi.org/10.1002/symb.628

David Matza from naturalism to cultural criminology: Exploring subculture and alcohol in an ethnographic study of young adults in the UK

Blackman, S. and McPherson, R. 2022. David Matza from naturalism to cultural criminology: Exploring subculture and alcohol in an ethnographic study of young adults in the UK. in: Conner, C.T. (ed.) Subcultures United Kingdom Emerald. pp. 99-111

‘Comfortably numb:’ explorations of embodiment and recovery in an ethnography of operating theatres.

Ewart, L. and Blackman, S. 2022. ‘Comfortably numb:’ explorations of embodiment and recovery in an ethnography of operating theatres. in: Hayre, C, Muller, D and Hackett, P (ed.) Rehabilitation in Practice: Ethnographic Perspectives Springer. pp. 199-216

Skateboarding: From urban spaces to subcultural Olympians

Bäckström, Å. and Blackman, S. 2022. Skateboarding: From urban spaces to subcultural Olympians. YOUNG. 30 (2), pp. 121-131. https://doi.org/10.1177/11033088221081944

Retrieving and Repurposing: A Grounded Approach to Hyperlocal Working Practices through a Subcultural Lens

Arnold, C. and Blackman, S. 2021. Retrieving and Repurposing: A Grounded Approach to Hyperlocal Working Practices through a Subcultural Lens. Digital Journalism. 11 (6), pp. 1065-1083. https://doi.org/10.1080/21670811.2021.1880330

Autoethnographic and qualitative research on popular music: Exploring the blues, jazz, grime, John Cage, live performance, SoundCloud and the masculinities of metal

Blackman, S., McPherson, R., Slater, S., Ilan, J., Arias, M., Espiga, P., Smith, R., Cashman, D., Garrdio, W., Kelly, T. and Spracklen, K. 2021. Autoethnographic and qualitative research on popular music: Exploring the blues, jazz, grime, John Cage, live performance, SoundCloud and the masculinities of metal. Birmingham City University.

Ethnography and medicine: the utility of positivist methods in research

Hayre, C. M., Blackman, S, Hackett, P. M. W., Muller, D. and Sim, J. 2021. Ethnography and medicine: the utility of positivist methods in research. Anthropology & Medicine. 29 (3), pp. 338-344. https://doi.org/10.1080/13648470.2021.1893657

Introduction to special issue. Distancing, disease and distress: The young and COVID-19: exploring young people’s experience of inequalities and their resourcefulness during the pandemic

Bengtsson, T., Blackman, S., King, Hannah and Østergaard, J. 2021. Introduction to special issue. Distancing, disease and distress: The young and COVID-19: exploring young people’s experience of inequalities and their resourcefulness during the pandemic. YOUNG. 29 (4_suppl), pp. S5-S10. https://doi.org/10.1177/11033088211032792

The subcultural imagination: critically negotiating the co-production of ‘subcultural subjects’ through the lens of C. Wright Mills

Blackman, Shane and Kempson, Michelle 2021. The subcultural imagination: critically negotiating the co-production of ‘subcultural subjects’ through the lens of C. Wright Mills. Sociological Research Online. 28 (1), pp. 58-72. https://doi.org/10.1177/13607804211006112

‘He enjoyed it more than I did!': young British Sikh women negotiating safe sex in heterosexual encounters

Mahendru, Ritu and Blackman, Shane 2019. ‘He enjoyed it more than I did!': young British Sikh women negotiating safe sex in heterosexual encounters. Journal of Youth Studies. 23 (8), pp. 1039-1053. https://doi.org/10.1080/13676261.2019.1654088

Ethnography and emotions: new directions for critical reflexivity within contemporary qualitative health care research

Phillips, A., Blackman, S. and Sah, R. 2019. Ethnography and emotions: new directions for critical reflexivity within contemporary qualitative health care research. in: Hayre, C. M. and Muller, D. (ed.) Enhancing healthcare and rehabilitation: the impact of qualitative research London CRC Press.

“Sociologist as hero”? Robert Park, the Chicago School, and the origin and destination of sociology

Blackman, S. 2017. “Sociologist as hero”? Robert Park, the Chicago School, and the origin and destination of sociology. Symbolic Interaction. 41 (3), pp. 411-414. https://doi.org/10.1002/symb.346

Towards ‘sensible’ drug information: critically exploring drug intersectionalities, ‘Just Say No,’ normalisation and harm reduction

Blackman, S., Bradley, R., Fagg, M. and Hickmott, N. 2017. Towards ‘sensible’ drug information: critically exploring drug intersectionalities, ‘Just Say No,’ normalisation and harm reduction. Drugs: Education, Prevention, and Policy. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687637.2017.1397100

No blue plaques ‘in the land ofgrey and pink’: the Canterbury sound, heritage and the alternative relationships of popular music and place

Blackman, S. and Draganova, A. 2018. No blue plaques ‘in the land ofgrey and pink’: the Canterbury sound, heritage and the alternative relationships of popular music and place. in: Holland, S. and Spracklen, K. (ed.) Subcultures, bodies and spaces: essays on alternativity and marginalisation Emerald.

Youth marginality in Britain: contemporary studies of austerity

Blackman, S. and Rogers, R. Blackman, S. and Rogers, R. (ed.) 2017. Youth marginality in Britain: contemporary studies of austerity. Bristol Policy Press.

Critically theorising young adult marginality: historical and contemporary perspectives

Blackman, S. and Rogers, R. 2017. Critically theorising young adult marginality: historical and contemporary perspectives. in: Blackman, S. and Rogers, R. (ed.) Marginality in Britain: Contemporary Studies of Austerity Bristol Policy Press.

Critically theorising young adult marginality: historical and contemporary perspectives

From niche to stigma - headshop to prison: exploring the rise and fall of synthetic cannaboid use amongst young adults

Blackman, S. and Bradley, R. 2017. From niche to stigma - headshop to prison: exploring the rise and fall of synthetic cannaboid use amongst young adults. International Journal of Drug Policy. 40, pp. 70-77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2016.10.015

David Bowie: a portrait of a life less ordinary

Blackman, S. 2016. David Bowie: a portrait of a life less ordinary. Kent on Sunday.

Conclusions: C Wright-Mills, the 'subcultural' imagination, reflexivity and the subcultural subject

Blackman, S. and Kempson, M. 2016. Conclusions: C Wright-Mills, the 'subcultural' imagination, reflexivity and the subcultural subject. in: Blackman, S. and Kempson, M. (ed.) The Subcultural Imagination: Theory, Research and Reflexivity in Contemporary Youth Cultures Routledge. pp. 178-185

Introducing the sociological and the subcultural imagination

Kempson, M. and Blackman, S. 2016. Introducing the sociological and the subcultural imagination. in: Blackman, S. and Kempson, M. (ed.) The Subcultural Imagination: Theory, Research and Reflexivity in Contemporary Youth Cultures Routledge. pp. 1-16

Do general radiographic examinations resemble a person-centred environment?

Hayre, C., Blackman, S. and Eyden, A. 2016. Do general radiographic examinations resemble a person-centred environment? Radiography. 22 (4), pp. e245-e251. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.radi.2016.07.001

Emotional imagination in ethnography: towards a theoretical understanding of reflexive sociological fieldwork with young people

Blackman, S. 2016. Emotional imagination in ethnography: towards a theoretical understanding of reflexive sociological fieldwork with young people. Research Seminary Workshop. SFI - The Danish National Centre for Social Research, Copenhagen, Denmark 18 Apr 2016

New research sensitivities and sociology: ethnographic research methods and the study of young people's culture

Blackman, S. 2011. New research sensitivities and sociology: ethnographic research methods and the study of young people's culture.

What future for drug policy? Assessing the 'legitimation crisis' for drug prohibition under drug normalisation within young people's culture

Blackman, S. 2011. What future for drug policy? Assessing the 'legitimation crisis' for drug prohibition under drug normalisation within young people's culture.

Binge drinking Britain: changing our drinking culture

Blackman, S. and Doherty, L. 2015. Binge drinking Britain: changing our drinking culture.

Ethnographic methods intoxication and research positionality

Blackman, S. 2015. Ethnographic methods intoxication and research positionality.

Ethnography, youth subcultures and deviance: critical intersections and reflexifity

Blackman, S. 2014. Ethnography, youth subcultures and deviance: critical intersections and reflexifity.

Doing ethnography with young people: from description to theory

Blackman, S. 2014. Doing ethnography with young people: from description to theory.

"Malinowski broke my heart!" Ethnography, emotion and youth: critical engagements with the new reflexifity

Blackman, S. 2014. "Malinowski broke my heart!" Ethnography, emotion and youth: critical engagements with the new reflexifity.

Mods! A cosmopolitan youth subculture?

Blackman, S. 2013. Mods! A cosmopolitan youth subculture?

Subjectivities, seductions and subculture: working towards a model of reflexive fieldwork relations in ethnographic studies with young people

Blackman, S. 2013. Subjectivities, seductions and subculture: working towards a model of reflexive fieldwork relations in ethnographic studies with young people.

Insider voices: addressing the challenge of ventriloquism and edgework in reflexive ethnographic accounts with young people

Blackman, S. 2012. Insider voices: addressing the challenge of ventriloquism and edgework in reflexive ethnographic accounts with young people.

Mods! Subaltern cosmopolitanism of a utopian and dystopian youth subculture

Blackman, S. 2011. Mods! Subaltern cosmopolitanism of a utopian and dystopian youth subculture.

New ethnographies of intoxication

Blackman, S. 2011. New ethnographies of intoxication.

Beyond laughing! A critical challenge to the notion of 'binge drinking' among young people?

Blackman, S. and McPherson, R. 2011. Beyond laughing! A critical challenge to the notion of 'binge drinking' among young people?

Living and breathing ethnography with young people: the critical tensions between edgework and ventriloquism in qualitative fieldwork

Blackman, S. 2011. Living and breathing ethnography with young people: the critical tensions between edgework and ventriloquism in qualitative fieldwork.

Writing and publishing your research in peer reviewed journals

Blackman, S. 2011. Writing and publishing your research in peer reviewed journals.

Model girls in magazine culture: young women, feminism and the American dream. Fashioning Teenagers: A Cultural History of Seventeen Magazine by Kelley Massoni Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, 2010

Blackman, S. 2012. Model girls in magazine culture: young women, feminism and the American dream. Fashioning Teenagers: A Cultural History of Seventeen Magazine by Kelley Massoni Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, 2010. Symbolic Interaction. 35 (4), pp. 501-503. https://doi.org/10.1002/symb.33

Drug normalisation

Blackman, S. and Measham, F. 2014. Drug normalisation. in: Heith, J., Copes, C. and Forsyth, J. (ed.) Encyclopedia of Social Deviance Thousand Oaks, CA. SAGE. pp. 285-295

Review symposium: Gill Jones Youth Cambridge: Polity, 2009, £14.99 pbk (ISBN: 9780745640952), 224pp

Blackman, S. 2011. Review symposium: Gill Jones Youth Cambridge: Polity, 2009, £14.99 pbk (ISBN: 9780745640952), 224pp. Sociology. 45, pp. 512-517. https://doi.org/10.1177/0038038511399630

Subculture

Blackman, S. 2014. Subculture. in: Heith, J., Copes, C. and Forsyth, J. (ed.) Encyclopedia of Social Deviance Thousand Oaks, CA. SAGE. pp. 707-711

The emotional imagination: exploring critical ventriloquy and emotional edgework in reflexive sociological ethnography with young people

Blackman, S. 2016. The emotional imagination: exploring critical ventriloquy and emotional edgework in reflexive sociological ethnography with young people. in: Blackman, S. and Kempson, M. (ed.) The Subcultural Imagination: Theory, Research and Reflexivity in Contemporary Youth Cultures London Routledge.

Normalisation of Hedonism? Challenging convergence culture through ethnographic studies of alcohol consumption on young adults - a feminist exploration

Blackman, S., Doherty, L. and McPherson, R. 2015. Normalisation of Hedonism? Challenging convergence culture through ethnographic studies of alcohol consumption on young adults - a feminist exploration. in: Staddon, P. (ed.) Women and alcohol: social perspectives Bristol Policy Press. pp. 45-64

Psychotic (e)states: where anti-social behaviour is merged with recreational drug use to signify the social problem group

Blackman, S. and Wilson, A. 2014. Psychotic (e)states: where anti-social behaviour is merged with recreational drug use to signify the social problem group. in: Pickard, S. (ed.) Anti-Social Behaviour in Britain Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 285-295

Subculture theory: an historical and contemporary assessment of the concept for understanding deviance

Blackman, S. 2014. Subculture theory: an historical and contemporary assessment of the concept for understanding deviance. Deviant Behavior. 35 (6), pp. 496-512. https://doi.org/10.1080/01639625.2013.859049

Ethnographic studies and the issue of speaking for disenfranchised young people?

Blackman, S. 2008. Ethnographic studies and the issue of speaking for disenfranchised young people?

''Insider Voices'': Critical reflections on auto ethnography and edgework in the study of young people

Blackman, S. 2009. ''Insider Voices'': Critical reflections on auto ethnography and edgework in the study of young people.

'The ethnographic mosaic': critically locating Clifford Shaw's research methods of the young person's 'own story' in contemporary reflexive sociological interpretation

Blackman, S. 2007. 'The ethnographic mosaic': critically locating Clifford Shaw's research methods of the young person's 'own story' in contemporary reflexive sociological interpretation.

Abstinence on the offensive? Critical reflections on drug normalisation, youth subcultural identities and the new forms of drug prevention, desistance, normative education and the ‘Blueprint'

Blackman, S. 2007. Abstinence on the offensive? Critical reflections on drug normalisation, youth subcultural identities and the new forms of drug prevention, desistance, normative education and the ‘Blueprint'.

Comparative youth skill acquisition in England and Germany

Blackman, S. 1994. Comparative youth skill acquisition in England and Germany. Youth and Policy. 43, pp. 1-23.

Pro-school pupils: a case study on ''boffin'' girls and boys inside and outside school

Blackman, S. 1992. Pro-school pupils: a case study on ''boffin'' girls and boys inside and outside school. Youth and Policy. 32, pp. 1-9.

Youth: positions and oppositions

Blackman, S. 1995. Youth: positions and oppositions. London, UK Avebury Press.

Keyworkers: technical and training mastery in the workplace

Brown, A., Evans, K., Blackman, S. and Germon, S. 1994. Keyworkers: technical and training mastery in the workplace. The Hyde Press.

Health, sex and drugs education - rhetoric and reality

Stears, D., Clift, S. and Blackman, S. 1995. Health, sex and drugs education - rhetoric and reality. in: Ahier, J. and Ross, A. (ed.) Social Subjects within the Curriculum: Children's Social Learning in the National Curriculum Falmer Press.

In yer face: the return of the anti-drug approach

Blackman, S. 1996. In yer face: the return of the anti-drug approach. Images: YMCA Journal of Reflective Practice. 12 (1), pp. 12-13.

Illicit drugs: endemic not epidemic

Blackman, S. 1996. Illicit drugs: endemic not epidemic. Images: YMCA Journal of Reflective Practice. 2 (1), pp. 3-4.

‘Seat of your pants’: towards a reflexive theoretical model of fieldwork relations in ethnographic studies on young people

Blackman, S. 2010. ‘Seat of your pants’: towards a reflexive theoretical model of fieldwork relations in ethnographic studies on young people.

Drug war politics: governing culture through prohibition, intoxicants as customary practice and the challenge of drug normalisation

Blackman, S. 2010. Drug war politics: governing culture through prohibition, intoxicants as customary practice and the challenge of drug normalisation. Sociology Compass. 4 (10), pp. 841-855. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1751-9020.2010.00324.x

Rituals of intoxication: young people, drugs, risk and leisure

Blackman, S. 2010. Rituals of intoxication: young people, drugs, risk and leisure. in: Bramham, P. and Wagg, S. (ed.) The New Politics of Leisure and Pleasure Basingstoke, UK Macmillan.

‘The ethnographic mosaic’ of the Chicago School: critically locating Vivien Palmer, Clifford Shaw and Frederic Thrasher’s research methods in contemporary reflexive sociological interpretation

Blackman, S. 2010. ‘The ethnographic mosaic’ of the Chicago School: critically locating Vivien Palmer, Clifford Shaw and Frederic Thrasher’s research methods in contemporary reflexive sociological interpretation. in: Hart, C. (ed.) Legacy of the Chicago School: a Collection of Essays in Honour of the Chicago School of Sociology During the First Half of the 20th Century Kingswinford Midrash Publishing.

Young people, class and place

Shildrick, T., MacDonald, R. and Blackman, S. 2010. Young people, class and place. London Routledge.

Vulnerable homeless families in Rochester upon Medway

Blackman, S. 1997. Vulnerable homeless families in Rochester upon Medway. Rochester, Kent, UK Rochester City Council.

Directory for professionals working with young people

Blackman, S. and Parsons, C. 1998. Directory for professionals working with young people. Kent, UK Medway and Swale Social Services.

Developing a framework of substance misuse prevention in the South West Thames region

Blackman, S. 1998. Developing a framework of substance misuse prevention in the South West Thames region. London, UK Wandsworth Health Authority.

On the condition of the homeless and young in Swale

Blackman, S. 1997. On the condition of the homeless and young in Swale. Kent, UK Medway and Swale Social Services.

Rethinking education and democracy: a socialist alternative for the twenty first century

Blackman, S., Benn, C. and Chitty, C. 1997. Rethinking education and democracy: a socialist alternative for the twenty first century. UK Tufnell Press.

'Trying all the options' or 'Ageny hoppers': Two views of the young homeless story

Blackman, S. 1997. 'Trying all the options' or 'Ageny hoppers': Two views of the young homeless story. Images: YMCA Journal of Reflective Practice. 3 (2), pp. 6-9.

Youth homelessness and social exclusion (editorial introduction)

Blackman, S. 1998. Youth homelessness and social exclusion (editorial introduction). Youth and Policy. 59, pp. 1-7.

Youth homelessness and exclusion

Blackman, S. 1998. Youth homelessness and exclusion. Youth and Policy. 59, pp. 111-111.

Has drug culture become an inevitable part of youth culture? A critical assessment of drug education

Blackman, S. 1996. Has drug culture become an inevitable part of youth culture? A critical assessment of drug education. Educational Review. 48 (2), pp. 131-142. https://doi.org/10.1080/0013191960480203

'Destructing a giro': a critical and ethnographic study of the youth 'underclass'

Blackman, S. 1997. 'Destructing a giro': a critical and ethnographic study of the youth 'underclass'. in: MacDonald, R. (ed.) Youth, the 'Underclass' and Social Exclusion London Routledge. pp. 113-129

Disposable generation? An ethnographic study of youth homelessness in Kent

Blackman, S. 1998. Disposable generation? An ethnographic study of youth homelessness in Kent. Youth and Policy. 59, pp. 38-56.

‘Decanonised knowledge’ and the radical project: towards an understanding of cultural studies in British universities

Blackman, S. 2000. ‘Decanonised knowledge’ and the radical project: towards an understanding of cultural studies in British universities. Pedagogy, Culture and Society. 8 (1), pp. 43-67. https://doi.org/10.1080/14681360000200076

Youth subcultural theory: a critical engagement with the concept, its origins and politics, from the Chicago School to postmodernism

Blackman, S. 2005. Youth subcultural theory: a critical engagement with the concept, its origins and politics, from the Chicago School to postmodernism. Journal of Youth Studies. 8 (1), pp. 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1080/13676260500063629