‘Lenin, anarchism and the October Revolution’

Conference paper


Bates, D. 2017. ‘Lenin, anarchism and the October Revolution’.
AuthorsBates, D.
TypeConference paper
Description

The relationship between Marxism and anarchism has been an acrimonious one. Marx’s conflicts with Proudhon and with Bakunin were perhaps as much psychological as political and philosophical. The initial fissure between Marxism and anarchism came about in the context of the second half of the nineteenth century. Bakunin’s conflict with Marx in the First International has been written about extensively (See Thomas, 1980).

The paper will explore how the initial antagonism between Marx and the anarchists comes to be operationalised by Lenin before, during, and after 1917. In 1901, Lenin wrote:
‘What has anarchism, at one time dominant in the Romance countries, contributed in recent European history? – No doctrine, revolutionary teaching, or theory. – Fragmentation of the working-class movement. – Complete fiasco in the experiments of the revolutionary movement (Proudhonism, 1871; Bakuninism, 1873) - Subordination of the working class to bourgeois politics in the guise of negation of politics.’ (Lenin, 1901)

Lenin held to this view and put his opposition to anarchism into practice as he moved to consolidate Bolshevik hegemony in Russia. The construction of the strange historical fiction of Marxism-Leninism allows for a discursive and indeed material silencing (always partial) of anarchism. This is a silencing which comes to reach beyond Russia, to all those revolutionary movements influenced by Marxism-Leninism.

The paper will then go on to revisit aspects of Lenin (and Leninism) in the context of contemporary social movements, along with providing some thoughts regarding the relationship between Marxism and anarchism today.

Year2017
ConferenceManchester Workshops in Political Theory
Publication process dates
Deposited25 Jan 2018
Completed2017
Output statusUnpublished
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/8884v/-lenin-anarchism-and-the-october-revolution

  • 44
    total views
  • 0
    total downloads
  • 4
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Academic labor and its exploitation
Bates, D. 2021. Academic labor and its exploitation. Theory and Event. 24 (4), pp. 1090-1109. https://doi.org/10.1353/tae.2021.0060
Politically engaged artistic practice: Strategies and tactics
Bates, D. and Sharkey, T. 2020. Politically engaged artistic practice: Strategies and tactics. Tate Papers. 34.
Agency
Bates, D. 2018. Agency. in: Franks, B., Jun, N. and Williams, L. (ed.) Anarchism: A Conceptual Approach London Routledge. pp. 60-73
'Reading Marx, or the uses and abuses of Marx'
Bates, D. 2018. 'Reading Marx, or the uses and abuses of Marx'.
Marxism, religion and ideology: themes from David McLellan
Bates, D. Bates, D., MacKenzie, I. and Sayers, S. (ed.) 2015. Marxism, religion and ideology: themes from David McLellan. London Routledge.
Anarchism
Bates, D. 2017. Anarchism. in: Wetherly, P. (ed.) Political Ideologies Oxford Oxford University Press. pp. 128-159
Using Geras to understand the Syrian refugee crisis
Bates, D. and Keil, S. 2016. Using Geras to understand the Syrian refugee crisis.
Post-Marxism to post-anarchism
Bates, D. 2016. Post-Marxism to post-anarchism.
Anarchism and agency
Bates, D. 2016. Anarchism and agency.
Occupy: in theory and practice
Bates, D., Ogilvie, M. and Pole, E. 2016. Occupy: in theory and practice. Critical Discourse Studies. 13 (3), pp. 341-355. https://doi.org/10.1080/17405904.2016.1141697
McLellan, Marx and method
Bates, D. 2015. McLellan, Marx and method. in: Bates, D., Mackenzie, I. and Sayers, S. (ed.) Marxism, Religion and Ideology: Themes from David McLellan London Routledge.
”The political” and emancipatory politics - reflections on Laclau and Mouffe
Bates, D. 2015. ”The political” and emancipatory politics - reflections on Laclau and Mouffe.
Using Capital volume 1 to understand academic wage labour
Bates, D. 2015. Using Capital volume 1 to understand academic wage labour.
Norman Geras, human nature and mutual indifference
Bates, D. 2015. Norman Geras, human nature and mutual indifference.
Social protest, political change and democratisation in Ukraine
Keil, S., Bates, D. and Ogilvie, M. 2015. Social protest, political change and democratisation in Ukraine. in: Price, S. and Sanz Sabido, R. (ed.) Contemporary Protest and the Legacy of Dissent London Rowman and Littlefield.
Marxist theory and the politics of occupy
Bates, D. 2015. Marxist theory and the politics of occupy.
Geras, pluralism and the International Marxist Group (IMG)
Bates, D. 2015. Geras, pluralism and the International Marxist Group (IMG).
Occupy in theory and practice
Bates, D., Ogilvie, M. and Pole, E. 2014. Occupy in theory and practice.
Occupy in theory and practice
Ogilvie, M., Bates, D. and Pole, E. 2014. Occupy in theory and practice.
Intellectuals, philosophy, and socialist strategy
Bates, D. 2013. Intellectuals, philosophy, and socialist strategy.
Networks of revolution
Bates, D. 2012. Networks of revolution.
Networks of revolution
Bates, D. 2012. Networks of revolution.
Ideology and the intellectuals
Bates, D. 2003. Ideology and the intellectuals. Imprints. 6 (3), pp. 244-269.
Situating Hardt and Negri
Bates, D. 2012. Situating Hardt and Negri. in: Berry, D., Kinna, R., Pinta, S. and Pritchard, A. (ed.) Libertarian Socialism: Politics in Black and Red Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan.
'Making politics matter': political education in a 'knowledge-exchange' context
Bates, D. 2011. 'Making politics matter': political education in a 'knowledge-exchange' context. European Political Science. 11, pp. 164-174. https://doi.org/10.1057/eps.2011.18
Immaterial labour and the retreat from class: some reflections on Hardt and Negri
Bates, D. 2011. Immaterial labour and the retreat from class: some reflections on Hardt and Negri. Studies in Marxism. 12, pp. 51-78.
Gramsci: realist or post-Marxist?
Bates, D. 2008. Gramsci: realist or post-Marxist?
Once more on Laclau and Mouffe
Bates, D. 2008. Once more on Laclau and Mouffe.
Making politics matter: Teaching politics in a knowledge transfer context
Bates, D. 2009. Making politics matter: Teaching politics in a knowledge transfer context.
Intellectuals and the retreat from class: some reflections on Hardt and Negri
Bates, D. 2007. Intellectuals and the retreat from class: some reflections on Hardt and Negri.
Hardt and Negri: anarchists or (post) Marxists?
Bates, D. 2010. Hardt and Negri: anarchists or (post) Marxists?
Locating Hardt and Negri
Bates, D. 2010. Locating Hardt and Negri.
Intellectual labour and social class
Bates, D. 2007. Intellectual labour and social class. in: Bates, D. (ed.) Marxism, Intellectuals and Politics Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 169-185
Marxism, intellectuals and politics
Bates, D. 2007. Marxism, intellectuals and politics. in: Bates, D. (ed.) Marxism, Intellectuals and Politics Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 1-18
Reading Negri
Bates, D. 2009. Reading Negri. Critique. 37 (3), pp. 465-482. https://doi.org/10.1080/03017600902989880