Noise, agency, and the sound of obsolete technology

Journal article


Birtwistle, A. 2017. Noise, agency, and the sound of obsolete technology. FKW // Zeitschrift für Geschlechterforschung und visuelle Kultur. 61.
AuthorsBirtwistle, A.
Abstract

In a recently published collection on materiality in art Petra Lange-Berndt asks, “what does it mean to give agency to the material, to follow the material and to act with the material” (2015:13). My article attempts to consider this question, focusing on the work of a number of musicians and composers who have chosen to engage creatively with the sounds produced by obsolete – or near obsolete – technologies of sound recording and reproduction.

Every sound technology has the capacity to generate as well reproduce sound: in the case of the wax cylinder or shellac disc, surface noise is generated by physical contact between the recording medium and the needle/stylus, and with magnetic tape noise is created by the oxides used to make the tape. We might think of these sounds as the sound of technology itself – a sounding of each medium’s material and technological bases. Historically these sounds have usually been treated a problem, and successive waves of technological innovation have been directed at removing or repressing the sound of technology. Thus the move from shellac to vinyl, the development of Dolby noise reduction, and the broader the shift from analogue to digital technology, have all been partly motivated by a desire to silence the medium itself. But what happens if we choose to work with these sounds rather than repress them; and following Lange-Berndt’s prompt, what would this change in attitude mean?

My aim in this article is to consider what the political potential of the sound of technology might be, explored through a discussion of works by Walter Ruttmann and John Oswald.

The well-established discourses around the political potential of noise in the arts have tended to construct it as a form of attack: as Jacques Attali states, “Noise is a weapon” (1985: 24). But might there be other ways in which we could consider the political dimensions of noise, and if so, how might issues of materiality and agency within play though an alternative approach to the politics of noise?

In addressing these questions, my article examines the historical and temporal dynamics at work in the sound of technology. Here I argue that the temporal displacement we witness in the contemporary use of past technologies results in an intensification and re-energisation of the various forms of noise. For the artist working with archive material or obsolete sound recording and playback equipment, temporal displacement of this sort materialises the sound of technology – materializing or rematerialising the sounds with which they work - and in so doing releases forms of potentiality that can be understood in political terms.

KeywordsNoise; Sound art; Media archaeology
Year2017
JournalFKW // Zeitschrift für Geschlechterforschung und visuelle Kultur
Journal citation61
PublisherOpen Journal Systems
ISSN0935-6967
Official URLhttps://www.fkw-journal.de/index.php/fkw/article/view/1392/1394
Publication dates
Online27 Feb 2017
Publication process dates
Deposited31 Mar 2017
Accepted author manuscript
Output statusPublished
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/88212/noise-agency-and-the-sound-of-obsolete-technology

Download files


Accepted author manuscript
  • 5
    total views
  • 5
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Start here: Sounding the materiality of the compact audio cassette
Birtwistle, A. 2021. Start here: Sounding the materiality of the compact audio cassette. Resonance: The Journal of Sound and Culture. 2 (2), p. tbc.
Material resistance: towards a politics of listening
Birtwistle, A. 2020. Material resistance: towards a politics of listening. Echo. (1).
Le Moulin: audiovisual non-synchronization and the making of a historical documentary
Birtwistle, A. 2020. Le Moulin: audiovisual non-synchronization and the making of a historical documentary. in: Pickowicz, P.G. and Zhang, Y. (ed.) Locating Taiwan Cinema in the Twenty-First Century Amherst, New York Cambria Press. pp. 153-171
Big Paul: The death of video and the return of the repressed
Birtwistle, A. 2019. Big Paul: The death of video and the return of the repressed. in: Lissel, E., Jutz, G. and Jukić, N. (ed.) Reset the Apparatus! A Survey of the Photographic and the Filmic in Contemporary Art Berlin/Boston De Gruyter. pp. 91-104
Start Here - the art of the audio cassette
Birtwistle, A. 2017. Start Here - the art of the audio cassette. Canterbury Start Here.
Meaning and musicality: sound-image relations in the films of John Smith
Birtwistle, A. 2017. Meaning and musicality: sound-image relations in the films of John Smith. in: Rogers, H. and Barham, J. (ed.) The Music and Sound of Experimental Film New York Oxford University Press. pp. 167-183
House
Birtwistle, A. 2014. House. The Holy Underground, Baltimore, USA 11 Jul 2014
House
Birtwistle, A. 2014. House. Spectacle, 124 South 3rd St, Brooklyn, NY, 11249 05 - 21 Jun 2014
House
Birtwistle, A. 2013. House.
Review: Sync: Stylistics of Hieroglyphic Time James Tobias, Sync: Stylistics of Hieroglyphic Time. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, 2010, 304 pp.
Birtwistle, A. 2011. Review: Sync: Stylistics of Hieroglyphic Time James Tobias, Sync: Stylistics of Hieroglyphic Time. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, 2010, 304 pp. Screen. 52 (4), pp. 528-531. https://doi.org/10.1093/screen/hjr049
Listen
Birtwistle, A. and Sidney Cooper Gallery, Canterbury 2013. Listen. in: Stone, H. (ed.) John Smith Canterbury Sidney Cooper Gallery.
Electroacoustic composition and the British documentary tradition
Birtwistle, A. 2016. Electroacoustic composition and the British documentary tradition. in: Greene, L. and Kulezic-Wilson, D. (ed.) Palgrave Handbook of Sound Design and Music in Screen Media: Integrated Soundtracks Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 387-402
Photographic sound art and the silent modernity of Walter Ruttmann's 'Weekend' (1930).
Birtwistle, A. 2016. Photographic sound art and the silent modernity of Walter Ruttmann's 'Weekend' (1930). New Soundtrack. 6 (2), pp. 109-127. https://doi.org/10.3366/sound.2016.0086
House
Birtwistle, A. 2014. House. Osnabrueck, Germany 20 - 24 Apr 2014
House
Birtwistle, A. 2014. House. New York Jun 2014
Radical conformity: Len Lye and the theorisation of film practice
Birtwistle, A. 2015. Radical conformity: Len Lye and the theorisation of film practice.
Heavy weather: Michelangelo Antonioni, Tsai Ming-liang, and the poetics of environmental sound
Birtwistle, A. 2014. Heavy weather: Michelangelo Antonioni, Tsai Ming-liang, and the poetics of environmental sound. Quarterly Review of Film and Video. 32 (1), pp. 72-90. https://doi.org/10.1080/10509208.2012.757529
White noise: the representation of modernity in the films of Pai Ching-jui
Birtwistle, A. 2012. White noise: the representation of modernity in the films of Pai Ching-jui. in: Chang, B. and Klöter, H. (ed.) Imaging and Imagining Taiwan: Identity representation and cultural politics Wiesbaden Harrassowitz Verlag.
Douglas Gordon and cinematic audiovisuality in the age of television: experiencing the experience of cinema
Birtwistle, A. 2012. Douglas Gordon and cinematic audiovisuality in the age of television: experiencing the experience of cinema. Visual Culture in Britain. 13 (1), pp. 101-113. https://doi.org/10.1080/14714787.2012.641780
The Turner Prize: lead monkey of democracy
Birtwistle, A. 2000. The Turner Prize: lead monkey of democracy.
Noise, memory, monotony and drones: the sound of film technology
Birtwistle, A. 2008. Noise, memory, monotony and drones: the sound of film technology.
Noise, memory, monotony and drones: The sound of film technology
Birtwistle, A. 2009. Noise, memory, monotony and drones: The sound of film technology.
White Noise: The representation of Modernity in the films of Bai Jing-rui
Birtwistle, A. 2009. White Noise: The representation of Modernity in the films of Bai Jing-rui.
White Noise: The representation of Modernity in the films of Bai Jing-rui
Birtwistle, A. 2009. White Noise: The representation of Modernity in the films of Bai Jing-rui.
White Noise: The representation of Modernity in the films of Bai Jing-rui
Birtwistle, A. 2009. White Noise: The representation of Modernity in the films of Bai Jing-rui.
Disorganising organised sound: The silent modernity of Walter Ruttman's Weekend
Birtwistle, A. 2009. Disorganising organised sound: The silent modernity of Walter Ruttman's Weekend.
Cinesonica: sounding film and video
Birtwistle, A. 2010. Cinesonica: sounding film and video. Manchester Manchester University Press.
L'Adventurra (The Adventure)
Birtwistle, A. 1997. L'Adventurra (The Adventure).
Robert Altman’s Kansas City (1996) and the spaces of jazz
Fox, K. and Birtwistle, A. 2008. Robert Altman’s Kansas City (1996) and the spaces of jazz.
Real-time
Birtwistle, A. 2000. Real-time. in: Pearson, R. and Simpson, P. (ed.) Critical Dictionary of Film and Television Theory London Routledge.
Text
Birtwistle, A. 2000. Text. in: Pearson, R. and Simpson, P. (ed.) Critical Dictionary of Film and Television Theory London Routledge.
Mode of production
Birtwistle, A. 2000. Mode of production. in: Pearson, R. and Simpson, P. (ed.) Critical Dictionary of Film and Television Theory London Routledge.
Independent cinema
Birtwistle, A. 2000. Independent cinema. in: Pearson, R. and Simpson, P. (ed.) Critical Dictionary of Film and Television Theory London Routledge.
Stories of the Eye - Harbouring History
Birtwistle, A. 2007. Stories of the Eye - Harbouring History. Vertigo. 3 (5), p. 31.
Marking time and sounding difference: Brubeck, temporality and modernity
Birtwistle, A. 2010. Marking time and sounding difference: Brubeck, temporality and modernity. Popular Music. 29 (3), pp. 351-371. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261143010000243