EU-Russia strategic energy culture: progressive convergence or regressive dilemma?

Journal article


Hadfield, A. 2016. EU-Russia strategic energy culture: progressive convergence or regressive dilemma? Geopolitics. 21 (4), pp. 779 -798. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650045.2016.1219342
AuthorsHadfield, A.
Abstract

This article argues that strategic culture, long consigned to the margins of broader, more substantial IR theories, offers a novel mode by which to explore recent developments in EU-Russia energy relations. Approaching seminal strategic policies from the perspective of institutionalised norms and cultural value-sets, strategic culture explores the power of the past and its ability to produce and influence national attitudes in governments and societies. This enables analyses of strategic energy relations between actors like the EU and Russia to move beyond obvious polarities to nuanced insights about the national value sets by which energy security is itself rendered strategic. Beginning with the individual strategic cultures of both the EU and Russia within the area of contemporary energy security policies, the article then appraises the range of bilateral EU-Russia energy security policies, suggesting that in many ways, these shared policies constitute a sector-specific strategic energy culture that includes both the EU and Russia. Areas of ongoing intransigence and policy convergence in EU-Russia energy security approaches constitute the case studies, illustrating that both sides are essentially motivated toward the same goals of energy security, market prosperity and actor-based prestige, but on the basis of vastly different visions, using widely diverse modes of implementation, and with dissimilar standards of evaluation. The analysis then appraises whether this co-constituted area is progressive or regressive in terms of the cooperation or conflict generated between the two sides, concluding that a basis of acknowleged commonalities – made available through strategic culture perspectives – both sides retain the impetus to cooperate to the point of complete agreement on some areas, whilst simultaneously remaining in conflict to the point of aggression in others.

KeywordsEU; Russia; Strategic Culture; Energy Security; Strategic Energy Culture
Year2016
JournalGeopolitics
Journal citation21 (4), pp. 779 -798
PublisherTaylor & Francis
ISSN1465-0045
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1080/14650045.2016.1219342
Publication dates
Online15 Aug 2016
Publication process dates
Deposited27 Oct 2016
Accepted author manuscript
Output statusPublished
Permalink -

https://repository.canterbury.ac.uk/item/87y5y/eu-russia-strategic-energy-culture-progressive-convergence-or-regressive-dilemma

Download files


Accepted author manuscript
  • 64
    total views
  • 327
    total downloads
  • 0
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

NATO Redux: reviewing the July 2018 summit
Hadfield, A. and Logie, C. 2018. NATO Redux: reviewing the July 2018 summit. Ideas on Europe Blogsite.
Britain against the world? foreign and security policy in the 'age of Brexit'
Hadfield, A. 2018. Britain against the world? foreign and security policy in the 'age of Brexit'. in: Martill, B. and Staiger, U. (ed.) Brexit and Beyond: Rethinking the Futures of Europe London UCL Press. pp. 174-183
EU member states and the European neighbourhood policy
Hadfield, A. 2017. EU member states and the European neighbourhood policy. in: Schumacher, T., Marchetti, A. and Demmelhuber, T. (ed.) The Routledge Handbook on the European Neighbourhood Policy Routledge.
Kent and Medway: delivering a Brexit border: policing, security, freight and customs
Hadfield, A., Tong, S. and Centre for European Studies and the Canterbury Centre for Policing Research, Canterbury Christ Church University 2018. Kent and Medway: delivering a Brexit border: policing, security, freight and customs. Canterbury Canterbury Christ Church University.
Battle of the unions: Brexit and the Irish border issue: a two part blog
Hadfield, A. 2018. Battle of the unions: Brexit and the Irish border issue: a two part blog. Centre for European Studies (CEFEUS).
Brexit: regional rebalance vs. Westminster power grab?
Hadfield, A. 2018. Brexit: regional rebalance vs. Westminster power grab? Centre for European Studies (CEFEUS).
PESCO goes live: June 2018 European Council decisions on defence collaboration
Hadfield, A. and Logie, C. 2018. PESCO goes live: June 2018 European Council decisions on defence collaboration. PESCO Goes Live: June 2018 European Council Decisions on Defence Collaboration.
The July 2018 white paper: carte blanche or tabula rasa?
Hadfield, A. and Turner, C. 2018. The July 2018 white paper: carte blanche or tabula rasa?
Long read: Trudeau vs. Trump: a two-fold tale of tantrums and tariffs
Hadfield, A. 2018. Long read: Trudeau vs. Trump: a two-fold tale of tantrums and tariffs. Centre for European Studies (CEFEUS).
Report: EU à la carte? Chapter: European energy security in the age of Brexit
Hadfield, A. and Directorate-General for Education, Youth, Sport and Culture (European Commission) 2016. Report: EU à la carte? Chapter: European energy security in the age of Brexit. Brussels EU Publications Office. https://doi.org/10.2766/20561
Kent and Medway: Making a Success of Brexit: A Sectoral Appraisal of Small and Medium Sized Enterprises and the Rural Economy
Hadfield, A., Hammond, M. and Centre for European Studies (CEFEUS), Canterbury Christ Church University 2017. Kent and Medway: Making a Success of Brexit: A Sectoral Appraisal of Small and Medium Sized Enterprises and the Rural Economy. Canterbury Centre for European Studies (CEFEUS). https://doi.org/2
The EU's global image
Hadfield, A. 2017. The EU's global image. in: Dinan, D., Nugent, N. and Paterson, W. (ed.) European Union in Crisis London Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 294-315
Maple leaf Zeitgeist? Assessing Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s policy changes
Hadfield, A. 2017. Maple leaf Zeitgeist? Assessing Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s policy changes. The Round Table. 106 (1), pp. 23-35. https://doi.org/10.1080/00358533.2016.1272954
Emerging European geographies: the Erasmus program and Its effect on the east-west divide in a time of economic crisis
Hadfield, A. and Summerby-Murray, R. 2017. Emerging European geographies: the Erasmus program and Its effect on the east-west divide in a time of economic crisis. in: Hashimoto, T. and Rhimes, M. (ed.) Reviewing European Union Accession: Unexpted Results, Spillover Effects, and Externalities Leiden, The Netherlands Brill.
Trump, Trudeau and NAFTA 2.0: tweak or transformation?
Hadfield, A. 2017. Trump, Trudeau and NAFTA 2.0: tweak or transformation? The Round Table. 106 (2), pp. 213-215. https://doi.org/10.1080/00358533.2017.1305666
Defining and projecting EU energy policy
Kuzemko, C. and Hadfield, A. 2016. Defining and projecting EU energy policy. in: Godzimirski, J. (ed.) EU Leadership in Energy and Enviornmental Governance? Global and Local Challenges and Responses Basingstoke Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 21-50
North American and European foreign policy analysis
Hadfield, A. and Hudson, V. 2015. North American and European foreign policy analysis. in: Brummer, K. and Hudson, V. (ed.) Foreign Policy Analysis Beyond North America Boulder, Colorado Lynne Rienner. pp. 139-168
Education policy: internal consolidator or foreign policy vehicle? EU and Canadian perspectives compared.
Hadfield, A. and Summerby-Murray, R. 2015. Education policy: internal consolidator or foreign policy vehicle? EU and Canadian perspectives compared.
Vocation or vocational? Reviewing European Union education and mobility structures
Hadfield, A. and Summerby-Murray, R. 2015. Vocation or vocational? Reviewing European Union education and mobility structures. European Journal of Higher Education. 5, pp. 1-19. https://doi.org/10.1080/21568235.2015.1099453
Commune consensu: a soft power comparison of the Commonwealth and the European Union
Hadfield, A. 2015. Commune consensu: a soft power comparison of the Commonwealth and the European Union. The Round Table: The Commonwealth Journal of International Affairs. 104 (4), pp. 397-412. https://doi.org/10.1080/00358533.2015.1063845
Kent and Medway: making a success of Brexit: a sectoral appraisal
Hadfield, A., Hammond, M. and Centre for European Studies, Canterbury Christ Church University 2016. Kent and Medway: making a success of Brexit: a sectoral appraisal. Canterbury Centre for European Studies (CEFEUS). https://doi.org/1
Conclusion: foreign policy analysis and the post-Yugoslav states.
Hadfield, A. 2014. Conclusion: foreign policy analysis and the post-Yugoslav states. in: Keil, S. and Stahl, B. (ed.) The Foreign Policies of Post-Yugoslav States: From Yugoslavia to Europe Palgrave Macmillan.
Out of Africa: the energy-development nexus
Hadfield, A. 2013. Out of Africa: the energy-development nexus. in: Carbone, M. (ed.) The European Union in Africa: Incoherent Policies, Asymmetrical Partnership, Declining relevance? Manchester University Press. pp. 238-257
International justice: the corrosive effects of corruption
Hadfield, A. 2013. International justice: the corrosive effects of corruption. Synergy Magazine: Magazine of The European Law Students' Association (ELSA).
Europe and the rest of the world
Hadfield, A. and Fiott, D. 2013. Europe and the rest of the world. Journal of Common Market Studies. 51 (S1), pp. 168-182. https://doi.org/10.1111/jcms.12052
International history and international relations
Hadfield, A., Williams, A. and Rofe, S. 2012. International history and international relations. Abingdon Routledge.
Pipelines or pipedreams? The role of energy in the ENP
Hadfield, A. 2010. Pipelines or pipedreams? The role of energy in the ENP. Chatham House Briefing Notes.
ENP and EMP: the geopolitics of 'enlargement lite'
Hadfield, A. 2009. ENP and EMP: the geopolitics of 'enlargement lite'. in: Balzacq, T. (ed.) The External Dimensions of EU Justice and Home Affairs: Governance, Neighbours, Security Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 65-110
Notes from a CHOGM novice
Hadfield, A. 2008. Notes from a CHOGM novice. The Round Table. 97 (394), pp. 35-45. https://doi.org/10.1080/00358530701844510
EU-Russia energy relations: aggregation and aggravation
Hadfield, A. 2008. EU-Russia energy relations: aggregation and aggravation. Journal of Contemporary European Studies. 16 (2), pp. 231-248. https://doi.org/10.1080/14782800802309953
Differentiation and trust: Prüm and the institutional design of EU internal security
Balzacq, T. and Hadfield, A. 2012. Differentiation and trust: Prüm and the institutional design of EU internal security. Cooperation and Conflict. 47 (4), pp. 539-561. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010836712462781
British foreign policy, national identity, and neoclassical realism
Hadfield, A. 2010. British foreign policy, national identity, and neoclassical realism. Lanham, MD Rowman and Littlefield.