Thinking hats and good men: structured techniques in a problem construction task

Problem construction as a sub-component of problem finding is often one of the initial steps in problem solving and research has suggested that actively engaging in problem construction can lead to a more beneficial outcome and facilitate creativity. Here, we examine two techniques that may be used to help ‘scaffold’ problem construction ability: the six thinking hats and the six good men. These techniques can require the participant to either adopt multiple perspectives, incorporating a range of specific questions, or utilise a range of simple open ended questions. We had 100 participants take part in an on-line study that involved presenting them with a problem and requiring them to restate the problem in as many different ways as they could within a 3-min time frame. Participants were randomly allocated to groups comprising the six hats technique, the six men, or a no-intervention control group, and performance was measured in terms of the fluency, quality and originality of the responses. Results showed that both six hats and six men techniques produced greater fluency relative to controls, with a more robust effect for those using the six men. In terms of originality, both techniques proved beneficial relative to controls, with a more robust effect from those using the six hats. Hence, both techniques benefited performance, though in distinct ways. These results are discussed in terms of the potential benefits obtained by explicitly scaffolding thinking.

Amabile, 1983, T.A. Amabile
The social psychology of creativity: A componential conceptualization
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 45 (1983), pp. 357–376

Amabile, 1996 T.A. Amabile
Creativity in context
Westview, Boulder, CO (1996)

Annesley, 2010 T.M. Annesley
Who, What, When, Where, How and Why: The ingredients in the recipe for a successful methods section
Clinical Chemistry, 56 (6) (2010), pp. 897–901

Baer, 1988 J.M. Baer
Long-term effects of creativity training with middle school students
Journal of Early Adolescence, 8 (2) (1988), pp. 183–193

Basadur et al., 1982 M. Basadur, G.B. Graen, S.G. Graen
Training in creative problem solving: Effects on ideation and problem finding and solving in an industrial research organisation
Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 30 (1982), pp. 41–70

Benjes-Small et al., 2014 C. Benjes-Small, E. Berman, S. Van Patten
Put on your thinking hat! A creative approach to argument analysis
Paper presented at the Center for Instructional Development and Educational Research, VirginaTech (2014)

Birdi, 2007 K. Birdi
A lighthouse in the desert? Evaluating the effects of creativity training on employee innovation
Journal of Creative Behaviour, 41 (4) (2007), pp. 249–270

Childs, 2012 P. Childs
Use of six hats in STEM subjects
The Higher Education Academy (2012), pp. 1–7

Cohen, 1988 J. Cohen
Statistical power analysis for the behavioural sciences
Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ (1988)

Daniels et al., 1985 R.R. Daniels, R.G. Heath, K.S. Enns
Fostering creative behaviour among university women
Roeper Review, 7 (3) (1985), pp. 164–166

de Bono, 2009 E. de Bono
Six thinking hats
Penguin, London (2009)

Dillon, 1982 J.T. Dillon
Problem finding and solving
Journal of Creative Behaviour, 16 (1982), pp. 97–111

Fasko, 2001 D. Fasko
Education and creativity
Creativity Research Journal, 13 (3) (2001), pp. 317–327

Feldhusen and Clinkenbeard, 1986 J.F. Feldhusen, P.R. Clinkenbeard
Creativity instructional materials: A review of research
Journal of Creative Behaviour, 20 (3) (1986), pp. 153–182

Fontenot, 1993 N.A. Fontenot
Effects of training in creativity and creative problem finding upon business people
Journal of Social Psychology, 133 (1) (1993), pp. 11–22

Forster et al., 2004 J. Forster, R.S. Friedman, N. Liberman
Temporal construal effects on abstract and concrete thinking: Consequences for insight and creative cognition
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 87 (2) (2004), pp. 177–189

Geissler et al., 2012 G.L. Geissler, S.W. Edison, J.P. Wayland
Improving students’ critical thinking, creativity and communication skills
Journal of Instructional Pedagogies, 8 (2012), pp. 1–11

Getzels and Smilansky, 1983 J.W. Getzels, J. Smilansky
Individual differences in pupil perceptions of school problems
British Journal of Educational Psychology, 531 (1983), pp. 307–316

Haman, 1996 G. Haman
Techniques and tools to generate breakthrough products
M.D. Rosenau, A. Griffin, G.A. Castellion, N.F. Anschuetz (Eds.), PDMA handbook of new product development, John Wiley and Sons, New York (1996), pp. 167–178

Hennessey and Amabile, 1987 B.A. Hennessey, T.A. Amabile
Creativity and learning
NEA Professional Library, Washington, DC (1987)

Hodge and Ozag, 2007 E.M. Hodge, D.J. Ozag
Experiencing ‘six thinking hats’: A practical system for improving managerial decision making in online course instruction
Business Eduction Forum, 61 (4) (2007), pp. 26–29

Isaksen et al., 2011
S.G. Isaksen, K.B. Dorval, D.J. Treffinger
Creative approaches to problem solving: A framework for innovation and change
(3rd ed.)Sage, London (2011)

Karadag et al., 2009 M. Karadag, S. Saritas, E. Erginer
Using the ‘six thinking hats’ model of learning in a surgical nursing class: Sharing the experience and student options
Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing, 26 (3) (2009), pp. 59–69

Karpova et al., 2011 E. Karpova, S.B. Marcketti, J. Barker
The efficacy of teaching creativity: Assessment of student creative thinking before and after exercises
Clothing & Textiles Research Journal, 29 (1) (2011), pp. 52–66

Kenny, 2003 L.J. Kenny
Using Edward de Bono's six hats game to aid critical thinking and reflection in palliative care
International Journal of Nursing, 9 (3) (2003), pp. 105–112

Kozbelt et al., 2010 A. Kozbelt, R.A. Beghetto, M.A. Runco
Theories of creativity
J.C. Kaufman, R.J. Sternberg (Eds.), Cambridge handbook of creativity, Cambridge University Press, New York, NY (2010)

McFadzean, 1998 E. McFadzean
The creativity continuum: Towards a classification of creative problem solving techniques
Creativity and Innovation Management, 7 (3) (1998), pp. 131–139

Mumford et al., 1994 M.D. Mumford, R. Reiter-Palmon, M.R. Redmond
Problem construction and cognition: Applying problem representations in ill-defined domains
M.A. Runco (Ed.), Problem finding, problem solving, and creativity, Ablex, Norwood, NJ (1994), pp. 3–39

Nickerson, 1999 R.S. Nickerson
Enhancing creativity
R.J. Sternberg, T.I. Lubart (Eds.), Handbook of creativity, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1999), pp. 392–430

Paletz and Peng, 2009 S.B.F. Paletz, K. Peng
Problem finding and contradiction: Examining the relationship between naive dialectical thinking, ethnicity, and creativity
Creativity Research Journal, 21 (2) (2009), pp. 1–13

Paterson, 2006 A. Paterson
Dr Edward de Bono's six thinking hats and numeracy
Australian Primary Mathematics Classroom, 11 (3) (2006), pp. 11–15

Reiter-Palmon et al., 1997 R. Reiter-Palmon, M.D. Mumford, J.O. Boes, M.A. Runco
Problem construction and creativity: The role of ability, cue consistency, and active processing
Creativity Research Journal, 10 (1) (1997), pp. 9–23

Reiter-Palmon et al., 1998 R. Reiter-Palmon, M.D. Mumford, K.V. Threlfall
Solving everyday problems creatively: The role of problem construction and personality type
Creativity Research Journal, 11 (3) (1998), pp. 187–197

Reiter-Palmon and Robinson, 2009 R. Reiter-Palmon, E.J. Robinson
Problem identification and construction: What do we know, what is the future?
Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity and the Arts, 3 (1) (2009), pp. 43–47

Reja et al., 2003 U. Reja, K.L. Manfreda, V. Hlebec, V. Vehovar
Open-ended vs. close-ended questions in web questionnaires
Developments in Applied Statistics, 19 (2003), pp. 159–177

Rizvi et al., 2011 A.A. Rizvi, M. Bilal, A. Ghaffar, M. Asdaque
Application of six thinking hats in education
International Journal of Academic Research, 3 (3) (2011), pp. 775–779

Runco and Nemiro, 1994 M.A. Runco, J. Nemiro
Problem finding, creativity and giftedness
Roeper Review, 16 (4) (1994), pp. 235–241

Runco et al., 1987 M.A. Runco, S.M. Okuda, B.J. Thurston
The psychometric properties of four systems for scoring divergent thinking tests
Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 5 (1987), pp. 149–156

Ryan and Deci, 2000 R.M. Ryan, E.L. Deci
Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: Classic definitions and new directions
Contemporary Educational Psychology, 25 (2000), pp. 54–67

Schellens et al., 2009 T. Schellens, H. Van Keer, B. De Wever, M. Valcke
Tagging thinking types in asynchronous discusson groups: Effects on critical thinking
Interactive Learning Environments, 17 (1) (2009), pp. 77–94

Scott et al., 2004 G. Scott, L.E. Leritz, M.D. Mumford
Types of creativity training: Approaches and their effectiveness
Journal of Creative Behaviour, 38 (3) (2004), pp. 149–179

Shrout and Fleiss, 1979 P.E. Shrout, J.L. Fleiss
Intraclass correlations: Uses in assessing rater reliability
Psychological Bulletin, 86 (1979), pp. 420–428

Silvia et al., 2008 P.J. Silvia, B.P. Winterstein, J.T. Willse, C.M. Barona, J.T. Cram, K.I. Hess, et al.
Assessing creativity with divergent thinking tasks: Exploring the reliability and validity of new subjective scoring methods
Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity and the Arts, 2 (2008), pp. 65–85

Smith, 1988 G.F. Smith
Towards a heuristic theory of problem structuring
Management Science, 34 (12) (1988), pp. 1489–1506

Sowden et al., in press P.T. Sowden, A. Pringle, L. Gabora
The shifting sands of creative thinking: Connections to dual process theory
Thinking & Reasoning (2014) (in press)

Sowden and Dawson, 2011 P.T. Sowden, L. Dawson
Creative feelings: The effect of mood on creative ideation and evaluation
ACM Creativity and Cognition. (2011), pp. 393–394

Wang and Horng, 2002 C. Wang, R. Horng
The effects of creative problem solving training on creativity, cognitive type and R&D performance
R&D Management, 32 (1) (2002), pp. 35–45